norwichfox Posted 30 August 2015 Share Posted 30 August 2015 All these red cards being shown, this season, I would like to see a "sin-bin" system with a minimum of t0 minutes, max of 15 mins for offences where a double yellow card has got a player sent off for some quite trivial reasons, foul and a wrong word with the ref for instance. To punish the whole team for some petty offence is a poor solution (unless it's our opposition of course ) Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
filbertstreet Posted 30 August 2015 Share Posted 30 August 2015 We haven't got any red cards so far yet have we? Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
Stinkenzo Posted 30 August 2015 Share Posted 30 August 2015 They could just try not to get sent off Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
EGBFitness Posted 30 August 2015 Share Posted 30 August 2015 We could change the shape of the ball too? Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
FireFox Posted 30 August 2015 Share Posted 30 August 2015 Would a pitch made out of ice be better? Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
norwichfox Posted 30 August 2015 Author Share Posted 30 August 2015 We haven't got any red cards so far yet have we? Thankfully we had a crap ref yesterday, otherwise Huth was off with a decent ref. We could change the shape of the ball too? When Inler gets in the side and gets some of those outside the area shots off, he may well change the shape of the ball.. Would a pitch made out of ice be better? Good idea, it worked well for us in '63 Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
Buzzell Posted 30 August 2015 Share Posted 30 August 2015 Can we put this idea in the sin bin? Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
Fox92 Posted 30 August 2015 Share Posted 30 August 2015 No. Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
gerrytaggart Posted 30 August 2015 Share Posted 30 August 2015 We should play 4 quarters instead of two halves. More chance to have a p!ss and buy a warm pie. Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
willie-bell-in-rothley Posted 30 August 2015 Share Posted 30 August 2015 Sh#te idea Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
EGBFitness Posted 30 August 2015 Share Posted 30 August 2015 We should play 4 quarters instead of two halves. More chance to have a p!ss and buy a warm pie. Baltie Pie? If not I'm against this idea unfortunately Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
Hungry Hungry Fox Posted 30 August 2015 Share Posted 30 August 2015 This needs to be in the general section Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
THEBIGJOHNSTEADER; Posted 30 August 2015 Share Posted 30 August 2015 Pr1ck Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
marbles Posted 30 August 2015 Share Posted 30 August 2015 We should play 4 quarters instead of two halves. More chance to have a p!ss and buy a warm pie. With a sin bin, it seems 3 periods would be more appropriate. Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
Fox42 Posted 30 August 2015 Share Posted 30 August 2015 Wasn't there a proposition to have an orange card which results in a sin bin sentence not too long ago? Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
norwichfox Posted 30 August 2015 Author Share Posted 30 August 2015 This needs to be in the general section My mistake , it should....mods please move Wasn't there a proposition to have an orange card which results in a sin bin sentence not too long ago? I wasn't aware of it, checked and you're right, some French bloke who wanted to eject septic bladder, so can't be all bad. Orang would be a bad choice of colour, purple with gold braid would be nice Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
Kitchandro Posted 30 August 2015 Share Posted 30 August 2015 Nah Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
katieakita Posted 30 August 2015 Share Posted 30 August 2015 Teams seem happy to take a yellow against us to stop the likes of Vardy,Shinji and Mahrez running past them would have certainly had an impact in the Sunderland game. Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
DANGEROUS TIGER Posted 30 August 2015 Share Posted 30 August 2015 We could change the shape of the ball too? Yes please! Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
MPH Posted 30 August 2015 Share Posted 30 August 2015 If people think they won't miss a whole game, it will probably result in an increase in fouls in the game.. Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
Captain... Posted 31 August 2015 Share Posted 31 August 2015 The problem is whichever team was temporarily down to 10 men would just be ultra negative, park the bus and waste time for however long they were down to 10 men. Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
Isle of Wight Fox 86 Posted 31 August 2015 Share Posted 31 August 2015 All these red cards being shown, this season, I would like to see a "sin-bin" system with a minimum of t0 minutes, max of 15 mins for offences where a double yellow card has got a player sent off for some quite trivial reasons, foul and a wrong word with the ref for instance. To punish the whole team for some petty offence is a poor solution (unless it's our opposition of course ) Being a ref myself, having a player say a "wrong" word to the ref is correctly a yellow card. They are doing a job and shouldn't be swore at by some overpaid pre-madonna. its like someone, or sometimes, 4 or 5 players coming into your work and calling you all the names under the sun and having to have the will power to completely ignore it. I very much doubt many people would be able to not say a word and just carry on with what they are doing. Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
Nick Posted 31 August 2015 Share Posted 31 August 2015 Referees should be allowed to punish players who are violent or abusive with a free shot to the nose. That'd curb the behaviour in no time. Or perhaps the ref shouldn't do it, maybe the opposing manager or a volunteer from the crowd? Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
Col city fan Posted 31 August 2015 Share Posted 31 August 2015 Good thread this and I was thinking about this very subject last night. It's not always the refs fault I don't reckon. The fault lies with them 'implementing the letter of the law', which has become so ridiculously petty in some cases (eg. A player gets a 90th minute winner, gets all excited, whips off his shirt and gets a second yellow card). It's also ruining football matches..as a spectacle. A good example being the Southampton game yesterday which was effectively over before it had began. It was rubbish to watch because we were simply waiting for the Saints to score the first, the second, the third goal..... Players can be to blame....doing daft things themselves which play into the refs hands... There is no common sense anymore. The refs have become like robots (because they are ordered to be by the FA). You could literally get a computer to referee a football match these days...analysing each incident, based on whether such and such a player has done one thing or another. The best refs still have that human element...they still talk to the players and explain what's happening. Whether a sin bin situation would work is debatable. To get a player off the field for twenty minutes would certainly affect the game, but I think the depleted team would probably go all defensive, sit on the ball and wait for the player to return to the field of play. I really don't know. What I do know is that all these red cards (some clearly valid, some ridiculous) ruin the game as a spectator sport. As an aside, I've been posting in the betting thread for ages (probably over a year now), that football is becoming almost impossible to predict because of the all the sendings off. Only this weekend, I've had small bets on three games where 'my team' has had a player sent off.. In all three it's been a sending off for 'my team' which effectively knackers the bet often very early on. Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
Captain... Posted 31 August 2015 Share Posted 31 August 2015 @Col, that really depends if it was a justified red or not. You can't complain you lost your bet because a player was sent off for punching someone. But it is an interesting point about how it affects betting and it is also an industry powerful enough to make a stand. If Paddy Power recruited some ex referees to create a panel to assess games. There remit would be to decide whether referees have ruined a game. Paddy power or another betting company would then agree to cancel losing bets in games that have been ruined, giving their stake back as betting credit. First of all they would always be on the ref's side as they will lose out if a game is classed as ruined, secondly it would put pressure on the FA and ref's association to do something about it. One option is when a red card is issued the fourth official or a TV ref has 5 minutes to overturn or correct a decision. So it may turn out to be a 5 minute sin bin, while the game continues. If after 5 minutes the TV ref sees no reason to overturn the decision it stays as a red. Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
Recommended Posts
Archived
This topic is now archived and is closed to further replies.