Stuliasz Posted 10 January 2005 Posted 10 January 2005 Hi everyone, thanks to the 35 people who voted from the two big messageboards. Here are the results: The 'Steve Walsh' Defender of the Match award: Dion Dublin – 5.70 The 'Muzzy Izzet' Midfielder of the Match award: Gareth Williams – 7.67 The 'Gary Lineker' Striker of the Match award: David Connolly – 6.03 The 'Steve Claridge' Most Agreed On Player award: Gareth Williams The 'Micky Adams' Most Disagreed On Player award: Joey Gudjonsson The 'Steve Guppy' Performance of the Day award (based on most points above average): Gareth Williams – 7.67 The 'Lee Marshall' Letdown of the Day award (based on the most points below average): Chris Makin – 3.91 The 'Alan Birchenall' Most Generous Voter award: Chris_Unwin (Talking Balls) – 6.36 The ‘Uriah Rennie’ Fairest Voter award: Muzzy Magic (FoxesTalk); step (Talking Balls); Lisa (FoxesTalk); dirkster72 (FoxesTalk) – 5.57 The 'Andy from Long Eaton' Harshest Voter award: King_Kyle_lcfc (FoxesTalk) – 4.36 The 'Ade Akinbiyi' Flop of the Match award: Chris Makin – 3.91 The 'Keith Weller' Man of the Match award: Gareth Williams – 7.67 Complete results (35 votes): 1 – Gareth Williams – 7.67 2 – Jordan Stewart – 6.62 3 – David Connolly – 6.03 4 – Dion Dublin – 5.70 5 – Martin Keown – 5.59 6 – Nikos Dabizas – 5.54 7 – Joey Gudjonsson – 5.33 8 – Kevin Pressman – 4.99 9 – James Scowcroft – 4.56 10 – Scot Gemmill – 4.54 11 – Chris Makin – 3.91 Sub – Alan Maybury – 6.36 Sub – Marc de Vries – 5.82 Sub – Lilian Nalis – 5.25 Voter Lowdown Generous voters: Ashov, beaumontfox, Bobby Smith, Cat_burger, Chris_Unwin, Cobbo, dan_84, gregs_y2k, hullfox, Lboro fox, lemoi, Mike Hunt Smells, sheffield_fox, sparky, The Voice From Above Fair voters: coxie71, Craig, dirkster72, Jimmy Lad, Lisa, MuzzyMagic, PFKAKTF FOX, step Harsh voters: alex, Compton Fox, davieg, EMC Fox, Jonbluefox9, King_Kyle_lcfc, lazzer, mitcho_uk, Ox Fox, Petrescu, Scowy, True_Blue_Matt Thanks to everyone who voted this week and please please keep voting!
Guest Posted 10 January 2005 Posted 10 January 2005 Woohoo!! Two fair's running!! Keep up the good work SF!
davieG Posted 10 January 2005 Posted 10 January 2005 I resent the implication that people currently scoring low are harsh voters and not classed as fair. It could be that those who are considered fair are in fact generous and those classified as generous are decidedly over generous, blinkered or easily pleased/taken in.
Little Nicky Posted 10 January 2005 Posted 10 January 2005 I resent the implication that people currently scoring low are harsh voters and not classed as fair. It could be that those who are considered fair are in fact generous and those classified as generous are decidedly over generous, blinkered or easily pleased/taken in. 53708[/snapback] Totally agree Davie
Stuliasz Posted 10 January 2005 Author Posted 10 January 2005 I think its a fair system the way I do it, its all in proportion to the overall average for that game, not below a certain set score like below 5 is harsh or whatever, its so many below the average of that particular game that gets put into the harsh category. I think this is a good way of doing it and I will continue to do it, and if you don't like it, then thats up to you!
davieG Posted 10 January 2005 Posted 10 January 2005 I think its a fair system the way I do it, its all in proportion to the overall average for that game, not below a certain set score like below 5 is harsh or whatever, its so many below the average of that particular game that gets put into the harsh category. I think this is a good way of doing it and I will continue to do it, and if you don't like it, then thats up to you! 53718[/snapback] I'm just being a little tease SheffFox, you certainly don't have to justify your methods to me or anyone else. I'm perfectly happy with what you present, in fact I wear my harshness with pride so that when CL really get's us playing as a team and with everyone committed to the cause my scores will be able to go up proportionally whilst others will only be able to demonstrate a slight improvement.
Scow Posted 10 January 2005 Posted 10 January 2005 I like being harsh, shows that I don't take any crap from those bunch of useless wankers.
Stuliasz Posted 10 January 2005 Author Posted 10 January 2005 Or maybe it shows that you are just a stingy bar-steward???
Scow Posted 10 January 2005 Posted 10 January 2005 Or maybe it shows that you are just a stingy bar-steward??? 53771[/snapback] Maybe, but I doubt it.
Recommended Posts
Archived
This topic is now archived and is closed to further replies.