Our system detected that your browser is blocking advertisements on our site. Please help support FoxesTalk by disabling any kind of ad blocker while browsing this site. Thank you.
Jump to content

Poznan34

Member
  • Posts

    2,271
  • Joined

  • Last visited

  • Days Won

    1

Posts posted by Poznan34

  1. 12 minutes ago, Ric Flair said:

    I get why fans want a more proven manager, but what you also get with a proven manager is a catalogue of failures (unless you're a very attractive proposition) and repeat pattern behaviour of sticking with the same principles that got them the sack before.

     

    But going for a manager with minimal 1st team managerial experience is a punt that you're relying on high reward from high risk. The rewards though can be massive and as fans it's unlikely we truly know whether such a manager is destined to do so, where as a robust recruitment process from an effective sporting director and board should be able to tap in to that.

     

    There's plenty of examples either way of such appointments that go astonishingly well and utterly wrong but I see precious little evidence of better success rate going for the types of proven manager we could attract.

    Yeah, but there's also option C:

     

    - Proven manager but unproven in English football - in the mold of Iraola, Hurzeler, Glasner 

     

    It's not just Moyes or RVN

    • Like 4
  2. 57 minutes ago, Iwebema said:

    Similar to the Ayew deal, it's fine enough as a squad addition, he's certainly a much better back up GK than we have.

     

    But again similar to the Ayew deal IF the numbers are true, then you have to wonder what on earth we are doing that's up to 18m for a 33 and 31 year old who are essentially back ups and don't improve us in any way.

     

    For a team that is in trouble for serious PSR breaches who had to conduct an internal review to understand how the most expensive premier league team in history got relegated, to sink that kind of money into these kind of players is quite frankly beyond irresponsible.

     

    Hopefully it's not true, but we've over paid for every single player so far and outside of Okoli, I don't believe any of these are Glover scouted targets. 

    Still time for Top to sack the board to give us the best chance of promotion next season. If not, bottom half Championship life beckons until he sells the club. 

     

    Spoiler alert: he won't 

  3. Just now, themightyfin said:

    About 20 people. Hardly what I would say "fans demanding chsnge" 

    lol OK, we're just going to start making things up now are we? It was far more than 20.

  4. 3 minutes ago, themightyfin said:

    I don't see the fans demanding change.

    Only some here on Foxestalk that makes up a very small % of the fanbase that actually attend matches.

    I think the vast majority will be oblivious to anything  going on behind the scenes at the club.

     

    Fans demanding change suggests thousands upon thousands protesting and I don't see any of that. 

    Various loud and sustained anti Rudkin chants at Fulham

    • Like 3
  5. 25 minutes ago, Foxmeister said:

    The success of a football club is almost entirely about identifying quality players and appointing a good manager.

     

    We've predominantly signed shockers over the last 8 years and, with hindsight, the fees and wages look awful. Nobody complains or gives credit for Mads, Fofana, Maddison, Maguire etc. 

     

    Once the players are identified Rudkin and Whelan are tasked with getting the deal done and end up carrying the can for poor scouting. 

     

    The saddest part for me is the division this has caused among supporters, I know the personal insults of those that dissent are a sign of the times but surely there's a more respectful debate to be had.

    And who is responsible for appointing the scouts? It's Rudkin. He's responsible for the football side of the club. And it's seriously failed over the last few years. So, the fans demand change. 

×
×
  • Create New...