Stuliasz Posted 9 August 2004 Posted 9 August 2004 Hi everyone, I've had an idea. How about everyone on here who went to the game on Saturday gives me their average ratings for all of our players, I'll keep a record of it and the player with the best average at the end of the season wins the player of the season, and I'll also announce the TB player of the match after each match as well. Only players who have played over 15 minutes in the game should qualify for a rating. This is running on here and on Talking Balls, if you have already stated your ratings on Talking Balls, please do not do so again. I'll get the ball rolling (you can use .5 of ratings if you like): Walker 8 Makin 7 Stewart 4 Dabizas 9 Heath 9 Scowcroft 7 Wilcox 6 Nalis 8 Williams 7.5 Connolly 9 Dublin 5
Muz Posted 9 August 2004 Posted 9 August 2004 Walker 8 Makin 7 Wilcox 7 Dabizas 7 Heath 7 Stewart 4 Williams 8 Nalis 7.5 Scowcroft 6.5 Dublin 5 Connolly 9
Mark Posted 9 August 2004 Posted 9 August 2004 Walker 8 Makin 8 Stewart 6 Dabizas 8 Heath 8 Scowcroft 6 Wilcox 3 Nalis 7 Williams 7 Connolly 9 Dublin 4
Fox 4 Life Posted 9 August 2004 Posted 9 August 2004 Walker 8 Makin 8 Stewart 4 Dabizas 9 Heath 8 Scowcroft 6 Wilcox 5 Nalis 7 Williams 7 Connolly 9 Dublin - looked ok when he was on so 6
Mark Posted 9 August 2004 Posted 9 August 2004 3 votes for Stewart worse than Wilcox already? :laugh: Funny
Cat Burger Posted 9 August 2004 Posted 9 August 2004 Walker 8 Makin 8 Dabizas 8 Heath 8 Stewart 4 Scowcroft 6 Nalis 7.5 Williams 7.5 Wilcox 4 Dublin 5 Connolly 9
Scow Posted 9 August 2004 Posted 9 August 2004 Walker 7 Makin 8 Stewart 5 Dabizas 7 Heath 6 Scowcroft 7 Wilcox 4 Nalis 7 Williams 6 Connolly 7 Dublin 5
Oli Posted 9 August 2004 Posted 9 August 2004 Walker-9 Makin-8 Stewart-5 Dabizas-6 Heath-8 Scowcroft-8 Wilcox-5 Nalis-7 Williams-7 Connolly-8 Dublin-6
Carlo Posted 9 August 2004 Posted 9 August 2004 Walker 7 Makin 7 Stewart 5 Dabizas 7 Heath 7 Williams 6 Nalis 6 Scowcroft 6 Wilcox 6 Conolley 8 Dublin 4 Subs not on long enough to mark
Stuliasz Posted 9 August 2004 Author Posted 9 August 2004 Just to let you know the votes will be counted and verified at 10pm this evening.
Buzzell Posted 9 August 2004 Posted 9 August 2004 Walker-9 Makin-7 Stewart-5 Dabizas-7 Heath-8 Scowcroft-6 Wilcox-5 Nalis-7 Williams-8 Connolly-8 Dublin-6
Ash Posted 9 August 2004 Posted 9 August 2004 Walker 8 Makin 8 Stewart 4 Dabizas 9 Heath 6 Scowcroft 7 Wilcox 6 Nalis 7 Williams 7 Connolly 9 Dublin -6
Stuliasz Posted 9 August 2004 Author Posted 9 August 2004 Hi people, thank you for the excellent response on this. 24 people so far have given their ratings from this and another board. If we can get as many as we can before 10pm that would be great.
gagandeep Posted 9 August 2004 Posted 9 August 2004 Walker 8 Makin 7 Stewart 6 Dabizas 10 Heath 9 Scowcroft 7 Wilcox 5 Nalis 8 Williams 7 Connolly 9 Dublin 5 subs keown 5.5 blake 5 (neither had the chance to make much of a diffreence, but keown did 1 good clearing header.)
Wellman Posted 9 August 2004 Posted 9 August 2004 Walker 8 Makin 7 Stewart 6 Dabizas 9 Heath 9 Scowcroft 7 Wilcox 4 Nalis 8 Williams 7 Connolly 9 Dublin 5
Stuliasz Posted 9 August 2004 Author Posted 9 August 2004 Ok people this is a last call for ratings, I will be announcing the results shortly after 10pm. Dont you all get too excited!
Stuliasz Posted 9 August 2004 Author Posted 9 August 2004 OK everyone, thanks for voting, we got 27 votes in all over the end. Not a bad response at all in a day. I'll be doing the same after the Derby match. Here are the results: Man of the match: David Connolly (8.48) Flop of the match: Dion Dublin (4.54) Best defender: Nikos Dabizas (7.74) Best midfielder: Lilian Nalis (7.07) Best attacker: David Connolly (8.48) Harshest voter: Semper Eadem (6.09 overall) Most generous voter: gagandeep (7.36 overall) Heres the lowdown: 1 - David Connolly - 8.48 2 - Ian Walker - 7.85 3 - Nikos Dabizas - 7.74 4 - Matt Heath - 7.41 5 - Chris Makin - 7.22 6 - Lilian Nalis - 7.07 7 - Gareth Williams - 7.04 8 - James Scowcroft - 6.81 9 - Jason Wilcox - 5.15 10 - Jordan Stewart - 4.85 11 - Dion Dublin - 4.54 Connolly a comfortable winner this weekend thanks to his giving the West Ham defence one hell of a run around. Dublin and Stewart was a close run thing, but it seems like a lot of people were disappointed with Dion and he is this weekend's flop.
Mark Posted 9 August 2004 Posted 9 August 2004 Very good! I look forward to one of these after every game Spot on i agree with most of that, especially the position of Connolly & Scowcroft
gagandeep Posted 9 August 2004 Posted 9 August 2004 OK everyone, thanks for voting, we got 27 votes in all over the end. Not a bad response at all in a day. I'll be doing the same after the Derby match. Here are the results: Man of the match: David Connolly (8.48) Flop of the match: Dion Dublin (4.54) Best defender: Nikos Dabizas (7.74) Best midfielder: Lilian Nalis (7.07) Best attacker: David Connolly (8.48) Harshest voter: Semper Eadem (6.09 overall) Most generous voter: gagandeep (7.36 overall) Heres the lowdown: 1 - David Connolly - 8.48 2 - Ian Walker - 7.85 3 - Nikos Dabizas - 7.74 4 - Matt Heath - 7.41 5 - Chris Makin - 7.22 6 - Lilian Nalis - 7.07 7 - Gareth Williams - 7.04 8 - James Scowcroft - 6.81 9 - Jason Wilcox - 5.15 10 - Jordan Stewart - 4.85 11 - Dion Dublin - 4.54 Connolly a comfortable winner this weekend thanks to his giving the West Ham defence one hell of a run around. Dublin and Stewart was a close run thing, but it seems like a lot of people were disappointed with Dion and he is this weekend's flop. maybe i'll have to be a bit harsher for derby
Stuliasz Posted 9 August 2004 Author Posted 9 August 2004 That is well good. Great Idea keep it up mate. As long as people vote after each match, I shall keep it up mate!
Recommended Posts
Archived
This topic is now archived and is closed to further replies.