Alexikokopops Posted 26 July 2005 Share Posted 26 July 2005 ,Jul 26 2005, 3:45 PM]They wanted 3 points at least, because it would mean Livingston would be relegated instead of Dundee (Livingston had a much better goal difference). 144467[/snapback] So what does `Dundee were relegated all along` mean? 144490[/snapback] Dundee were bottom after the last game of last season. Livingston were fined for the Kachloul incident. Dundee are trying to get points docked from Livingstons total so that Livingston would finish bottom in the table because the feel the fine isn't enough punishment. Dundee would therefore stay up and Livingston would be relegated. Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
Solihullfox Posted 26 July 2005 Share Posted 26 July 2005 Yes, this is where the supposition/theory from Lush runs out of steamNow we'll have to turn our attention to Peter Crouch eh ! 144433[/snapback] Sorry, MR PERFECT 144465[/snapback] The title is a great weight or me to live up to Lush. Please don't spend too much time trying to spot a mistake from me, believe me I do make them, very occasionally 144479[/snapback] why have a go at me then 144493[/snapback] I wasn't having a go at you Lush, no hard feelings? Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
lush Posted 26 July 2005 Share Posted 26 July 2005 ,Jul 26 2005, 3:45 PM]They wanted 3 points at least, because it would mean Livingston would be relegated instead of Dundee (Livingston had a much better goal difference). 144467[/snapback] So what does `Dundee were relegated all along` mean? 144490[/snapback] Dundee were bottom after the last game of last season. Livingston were fined for the Kachloul incident. Dundee are trying to get points docked from Livingstons total so that Livingston would finish bottom in the table because the feel the fine isn't enough punishment. Dundee would therefore stay up and Livingston would be relegated. 144495[/snapback] yeah i know that, but dundee were only relegated yesterday, not before then, which is what you said. Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
lush Posted 26 July 2005 Share Posted 26 July 2005 I wasn't having a go at you Lush, no hard feelings? 144497[/snapback] Oh, ok, no hard feelings dude. Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
Alexikokopops Posted 26 July 2005 Share Posted 26 July 2005 ,Jul 26 2005, 4:18 PM] ,Jul 26 2005, 3:45 PM]They wanted 3 points at least, because it would mean Livingston would be relegated instead of Dundee (Livingston had a much better goal difference). 144467[/snapback] So what does `Dundee were relegated all along` mean? 144490[/snapback] Dundee were bottom after the last game of last season. Livingston were fined for the Kachloul incident. Dundee are trying to get points docked from Livingstons total so that Livingston would finish bottom in the table because the feel the fine isn't enough punishment. Dundee would therefore stay up and Livingston would be relegated. 144495[/snapback] yeah i know that, but dundee were only relegated yesterday, not before then, which is what you said. 144508[/snapback] No the were relegated when they played their last match of teh season and drew, finishing below Dunfermline. Yesterday the decision to uphold the fine against Livingston was made, stopped any chance of Dundee's relegation being confirmed. See? http://news.bbc.co.uk/sport1/hi/football/s...rem/4569111.stm http://news.bbc.co.uk/sport1/hi/football/t...ton/4712927.stm Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
Cal Posted 26 July 2005 Share Posted 26 July 2005 Sorry to get my head in, But it seems the way you've explained things is Crystal . I dont know why people dont understand P.s not having a go Lush Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
lush Posted 26 July 2005 Share Posted 26 July 2005 No the were relegated when they played their last match of teh season and drew, finishing below Dunfermline.Yesterday the decision to uphold the fine against Livingston was made, stopped any chance of Dundee's relegation being confirmed. 144511[/snapback] Correct me if im wrong here, but had livingstone been fined 3pts yesterday, dundee would`ve stayed up? Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
lush Posted 26 July 2005 Share Posted 26 July 2005 Sorry to get my head in, But it seems the way you've explained things is Crystal . I dont know why people dont understand P.s not having a go Lush 144537[/snapback] feel free to stick ya head in, im confused. Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
Alexikokopops Posted 26 July 2005 Share Posted 26 July 2005 ,Jul 26 2005, 4:40 PM]No the were relegated when they played their last match of teh season and drew, finishing below Dunfermline.Yesterday the decision to uphold the fine against Livingston was made, stopped any chance of Dundee's relegation being confirmed. 144511[/snapback] Correct me if im wrong here, but had livingstone been fined 3pts yesterday, dundee would`ve stayed up? 144555[/snapback] That's what they were pushing for. But Dundee were relegated during the time when the appeal was going on, because it was just an appeal against their relegation. I suppose you could technically look at like they were only "technically" relegated once this whole appeal business was out of the way, but then we'd just be getting pedantic Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
Scow Posted 26 July 2005 Share Posted 26 July 2005 I don't think it's that hard to grasp in all honesty. Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
lush Posted 26 July 2005 Share Posted 26 July 2005 That's what they were pushing for.But Dundee were relegated during the time when the appeal was going on, because it was just an appeal against their relegation . I suppose you could technically look at like they were only "technically" relegated once this whole appeal business was out of the way, but then we'd just be getting pedantic 144674[/snapback] I wasnt being pedantic, i just didnt know they were defo relegated and appealing. i got the impression that neither had been relegated until yesterday. Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
Alexikokopops Posted 26 July 2005 Share Posted 26 July 2005 ,Jul 26 2005, 9:25 PM]That's what they were pushing for.But Dundee were relegated during the time when the appeal was going on, because it was just an appeal against their relegation . I suppose you could technically look at like they were only "technically" relegated once this whole appeal business was out of the way, but then we'd just be getting pedantic 144674[/snapback] I wasnt being pedantic, i just didnt know they were defo relegated and appealing. i got the impression that neither had been relegated until yesterday. 144688[/snapback] I was only messing with the pedantic bit (hence the ) Glad it's all sorted Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
Recommended Posts
Archived
This topic is now archived and is closed to further replies.