I'm not debating who's better, but we were going to let Swindells leave weren't we, he had one very good and important innings so we've gave him a two year deal. Which is idiotic considering we've signed Cox who is obviously first choice and they clearly aren't overly bothered about playing Swindells. Add in to that we also have Hill and Handscomb who can keep if needed, it's a terrible decision. You can't criticise Jarvis and the club and seemingly ignore this decision because you have a soft spot for Swindells.