ktfoxes

It was his mistake that led to the goal, and the shot that McCarthy saved, what is the point of blaming the players around him instead of criticizing him?

Except it was the amount they were going to pay before all their issues flared up, you're basically asking Rudkin not only to understand the finances of a completely club but also see the future and know that they are going to get themselves into trouble barely a week later and pull out.

It's his job to get the highest fee possible and Sheffield United were willing to pay that, you can hardly blame Rudkin for Sheffield United's own financial problems under your own weird logic he'd have accepted the first offer and got well below what they were willing to pay which we would all rightfully call stupid

No, Martin said him and Mavididi were dropped because they were likely to leave and it didn't make sense to drop Mcfarlane or Howell from the bench for players likely to leave. And "rejecting bids" is just basic negotiations not "no more interest"

Should have brought Page if you were going to play Choudhury as an 8 anyway

Nvm

I don't think Joseph changing to a first team number after impressing in preseason is the same as McCarthy going from 12 to 29 for no reason (why not just take 29 from the start?), but we'll see

Yes, during training not in game

McCarthy's number is 12 not 29

Not sure, maybe Mavididi if he leaves or he doesn't "replace" anyone and Cullen plays as a striker rather than an attacking midfielder

Not the same position at all

You say this like non big 6 teams losing the best U-18 academy prospects is a unique problem that we're facing, in reality it's the standard, The rate that we are producing talents like Monga, Noubisse, Page, Motsi, Nyoni, Evans probably makes it look like we get picked off routinely but after retaining Monga, Page and Evans on pro deals I'd say we're one of the best at keeping our young talents compared to other non big 6 teams

People forget it's a two way street, same for Cartwright. They are 21/22 years old why would they stick around as fringe options when they have options elsewhere?

Where are you getting this idea that he's not going to play?

I'm sure Alves is not stupid enough to take competition/depth in his position as an insult, nor does he think he's 100% owed a starting spot

Just incorrect. RM's actual words (when asked about TRANSFERS, not "arrivals" so both signings and sales) : “Yes, I think so," "Who and when I haven’t got a clue, I’m sure we’ll update you as and when. The situation we’re in, with the size of the squad, the amount of interest we have in some of our players, it’s only natural that things will happen and start turning as they have done this week. I expect more to happen this week and whatever we’ll do, we’ll be happy with." A couple days later Fatawu was sold confirming what he said. He never promised signings this week, there's no indication he was "lied to", you guys just fell for a click bait tweet or read something from someone else without confirming what he actually said for yourself.

Wonder why Donnelly is wearing 14

One article said Middlesbrough didn't want to pay 15, the other says Rangers want to play 7. How are they in anyway similar

You can't say that Top and Rudkin are living in the past for trying to replicate Maresca and then bring up Pearson, you're doing the exact same thing

The last time we played "possession football" was with Maresca when we got promoted, Cooper, Ruud and Rowett were not possession managers and they got us relegated, Marti was more of a possession manager than them but he'd still have games with 30-40% possession. So the only point is that the fanbase aren't getting behind it, not that it "hasn't worked for years"

Still not seen a single post about Challinor's actual play style, does anybody actually know?