Oasis Albums voted best ever by people that vote in polls on things like that

[Bellend Sebastian]

Bring back the indie record shop!

Haven't been into the city centre for ages - I sincerely hope that Rock-a-boom and BPM are still there?

They are, but for how long is anyone's guess. I always feel a bit depressed in Rock-a-boom because there's never anyone in there.

I'd be amazed if there were any independent record stores in Leicester in three years time

[Bellend Sebastian]

Having looked at the full list I'm embarassed to admit that I've got most of them, but very few of them I actually listen to.

Oh Lord, there's a Stereophonics album in there. I don't have that, although I do have one of the Muse albums. In fact, there are so many Muse and Oasis albums in there that I think that's a clue to the demographic who responded to the poll - I'm guessing a lot of the responses were from relatively young folk

[Trav Le Bleu]

Having looked at the full list I'm embarassed to admit that I've got most of them, but very few of them I actually listen to.

Oh Lord, there's a Stereophonics album in there. I don't have that, although I do have one of the Muse albums. In fact, there are so many Muse and Oasis albums in there that I think that's a clue to the demographic who responded to the poll - I'm guessing a lot of the responses were from relatively young folk

Unfortunately most people outgrow new music - or rather, they believe they do. Kids, family, work takes over and they sell their soul to the Man, Mammon or both.

Both are evil gods that stipulate that, and I quote, "thou shalt never buy new music and forever listen relentlessly to ye music of thy youth, bemoaning that there never will be music so good ever again and that thou canst nay understand a word thoust sayest within new music, nor bear the repetive beat. Is it not too loud?" 2nd Book of Midelage chapter 3 verse 5

I buck the rule. I turn 40 this year

[Bellend Sebastian]

Unfortunately most people outgrow new music - or rather, they believe they do. Kids, family, work takes over and they sell their soul to the Man, Mammon or both.

Both are evil gods that stipulate that, and I quote, "thou shalt never buy new music and forever listen relentlessly to ye music of thy youth, bemoaning that there never will be music so good ever again and that thou canst nay understand a word thoust sayest within new music, nor bear the repetive beat. Is it not too loud?" 2nd Book of Midelage chapter 3 verse 5

I buck the rule. I turn 40 this year

I sold my soul to a mammoth. Fat lot of good that did me.

I know what you mean. An added problem is that when you reach a certain age you do become more discerning and less likely to be impressed, and there comes a point where you see through the hype that's associated with new acts be they good or bad

[ASH17LCFC]

Oasis are the best band ever, They made the greatest debut album ever and then made made the greatest album of all time in WHATS THE STORY.

Then people slag them off about Be Here Now How the fook do you make better music then your first 2 albums ?

Every album there made is good in its own way.

[Bellend Sebastian]

Oasis are the best band ever, They made the greatest debut album ever and then made made the greatest album of all time in WHATS THE STORY.

Then people slag them off about Be Here Now How the fook do you make better music then your first 2 albums ?

Every album there made is good in its own way.

The NME should have stuck to its original review. 7 out of 10 they gave it, before declaring it album of the year after it sold a few hundred thousand.

Greatest album of all time indeed

[shen]

Full list

No Led Zep, no Massive Attack, no Who, no My Bloody Valentine. Makes me remember why I hate Q and dont buy at HMV.

Yes i too hate HMV... Burn that Rip of merchant down!!

I cant believe no Led Zep made it into that list either but still that is Q for you!!

Who buys that crap anyway!!!!

Led Zep are at #29 with "IV". Which is quite ridiculous...

Oasis are the most overrated band ever, They made a decent debut album and then made another decent, yet unspectacular album in WHATS THE STORY.

Then people rightly slag them off about Be Here Now They just couldn't make better music then their first 2 albums !

Every album there made is average or poor in its own way.

[Darkzzz_]

Led Zep are at #29 with "IV". Which is quite ridiculous...

You can say that again!!

[Trav Le Bleu]

Oasis are the best band ever, They made the greatest debut album ever and then made made the greatest album of all time in WHATS THE STORY.

Then people slag them off about Be Here Now How the fook do you make better music then your first 2 albums ?

Every album there made is good in its own way.

More fitting contenders for greatest debut album ever...

The Good Will Out - Embrace

The Stone Roses - The Stone Roses

3 Feet High and Rising - De La Soul

Grace - Jeff Buckley

Isn't Anything - My Bloody Valentine

Appetite for Destruction - G 'n' R

Funeral - Arcade Fire

Yo! Bum Rush the Show - Public Enemy

Unknown Pleasures - Joy Division

Lexicon of Love - ABC

There, that's ten! Definitely Maybe is a great album, but best debut album?

[Darkzzz_]

More fitting contenders for greatest debut album ever...

The Good Will Out - EmbraceThe Stone Roses - The Stone Roses

3 Feet High and Rising - De La Soul

Grace - Jeff Buckley

Isn't Anything - My Bloody Valentine

Appetite for Destruction - G 'n' R

Funeral - Arcade Fire

Yo! Bum Rush the Show - Public Enemy

Unknown Pleasures - Joy Division

Lexicon of Love - ABC

There, that's ten! Definitely Maybe is a great album, but best debut album?

It is "Definitely Maybe" a better album than that one!!

[shen]

More fitting contenders for greatest debut album ever...

The Good Will Out - Embrace

The Stone Roses - The Stone Roses

3 Feet High and Rising - De La Soul

Grace - Jeff Buckley

Isn't Anything - My Bloody Valentine

Appetite for Destruction - G 'n' R

Funeral - Arcade Fire

Yo! Bum Rush the Show - Public Enemy

Unknown Pleasures - Joy Division

Lexicon of Love - ABC

There, that's ten! Definitely Maybe is a great album, but best debut album?

Best British Album

[Webbo]

More fitting contenders for greatest debut album ever...

The Good Will Out - Embrace

The Stone Roses - The Stone Roses

3 Feet High and Rising - De La Soul

Grace - Jeff Buckley

Isn't Anything - My Bloody Valentine

Appetite for Destruction - G 'n' R

Funeral - Arcade Fire

Yo! Bum Rush the Show - Public Enemy

Unknown Pleasures - Joy Division

Lexicon of Love - ABC

There, that's ten! Definitely Maybe is a great album, but best debut album?

I've not heard of at least 6 of those, but you got at least 1 right.

[Trav Le Bleu]

It is "Definitely Maybe" a better album than that one!!

The Good Will Out is a fantastic album - one of the most angst-ridden albums ever!

Everything since then has been dire, granted

[Trav Le Bleu]

Actually, looking at that list, amazing how many of those went on to produce "meh" 2nd albums (or in Buckley's case, die )

And Futter - look the 6 albums you haven't heard of up - you won't regret it

[ASH17LCFC]

I think Oasis have made the two greatest albums ever in my opinion.

Whats the Story has it all

Def Maybe started it all and probally made the biggest impact in terms of a debut album.

Plus they made Whatever in bewteen.

1994 - 98 Oasis were better then any band to ever grace this world.

Masterplan would be my number 3 greatest album ever made.

[Guest]

I think Oasis have made the two greatest albums ever in my opinion.

Whats the Story has it all

Def Maybe started it all and probally made the biggest impact in terms of a debut album.

Plus they made Whatever in bewteen.

1994 - 98 Oasis were better then any band to ever grace this world.

Masterplan would be my number 3 greatest album ever made.

That's a kinda blinkered view mate to be fair