Our system detected that your browser is blocking advertisements on our site. Please help support FoxesTalk by disabling any kind of ad blocker while browsing this site. Thank you.
Jump to content
Finchy

Anyone like The Charlatans?

Recommended Posts

Posted
They used to be good.

I've seen them twice in the past 3 or 4 years though and can confirm they are a bag of sh ite now.

That's a bit harsh.

I'd still go and see them at a push. I haven't got the last album but the one with the lake on the front (Up at The Lake, no less) a couple of years ago was really good, I thought

Posted
They used to be good.

I've seen them twice in the past 3 or 4 years though and can confirm they are a bag of sh ite now.

Aye - past the sell by date now.

And if you think TPH was "a bit harsh"...

I have a theory that all rock/pop musicians should be culled at 40 - incapable of producing good music beyond that age

There are a few exceptions to the rule, but worth the sacrifice to avoid the dross I feel!

Posted
Aye - past the sell by date now.

And if you think TPH was "a bit harsh"...

I have a theory that all rock/pop musicians should be culled at 40 - incapable of producing good music beyond that age

There are a few exceptions to the rule, but worth the sacrifice to avoid the dross I feel!

Disagree with that one chap, and you're closer to 40 than I am! (and you may yet have a classic album in you).

The last Morrissey (49 this year) album is top, and the last 3 Fall Albums are brilliant (Mark E Smith is 51 this year - doesn't look a day over 65).

I'd be all for culling Oasis at 40. Or indeed 30 for that matter, but better late than never

Posted
Disagree with that one chap, and you're closer to 40 than I am! (and you may yet have a classic album in you).

The last Morrissey (49 this year) album is top, and the last 3 Fall Albums are brilliant (Mark E Smith is 51 this year - doesn't look a day over 65).

I'd be all for culling Oasis at 40. Or indeed 30 for that matter, but better late than never

Can't do that. Dylan is still producing some good stuff even now and he's like 254.

I DID say there were exceptions to the rule! :rolleyes:

Add to the list of decent 40 plusers:

Neil Young

Johnny Cash (ok, so he's dead now, but he was decent 40+)

The Flaming Lips

Mark Lanegan

Mercury Rev

Portishead

Spiritualized

and many, many blues acts (seems that in this catergory at least, you improve with age!)

No doubt there are more, but what I meant was once great bands like the Rolling Stones and The Cure should really stop embarressing themselves. It saddens me :cry:

Posted
Can't do that. Dylan is still producing some good stuff even now and he's like 254.

You've been reading Q again. Stop it

I DID say there were exceptions to the rule! :rolleyes:

You did, sorry.

And you've quoted some very good examples

Posted

They are ok i guess. few songs i could listen to.

I actually saw them supporting The Rolling Stones at Twickenham a few years ago. They were ok live!

Although couldnt really hear the vocals that well!

But i blame the techies for that! lol

Posted

Have always been great live but they've never really recovered from the death of Rob Collins.

Only their second album failed to deliver and from what I've heard of the new album they've bagged a good un.

I'm slightly biased as I met them on many occasions (if playing them at pool counts for met) when they were in Wales recording the Telling Stories album (they used to love TJ's in Newport) Sadly this was RC's last album :(

Posted

I quite enjoyed the one which is supposed to be Dylan inspired with lots of Harmonica and put on drawly, rough singing.

More the music than the singing though.

The lyrics tend to be fairly uninspired.

Ho-hum.

They aren't awful, don't get me wrong, just agree, they never recovered after RC's death.

Archived

This topic is now archived and is closed to further replies.

  • Recently Browsing   0 members

    • No registered users viewing this page.
×
×
  • Create New...