Although Smith didn't quite get us over the line sadly then he stil had an almost impossible job on his hands by the time he was appointed (which was way too late and after the two horror shows v Villa and Bournemouth when the inept Sadler and Stowell were left in charge).
So I'd counter-argue what youi said in part by saying that Smith's game plan and defensive team selection away at Newcastle in the penultimate game nearly came off and was pretty brave, tactically speaking - and was the polar opposite of how we were inexplicably so pathetic defensively in the away game before it at Fulham, a game that everybody thought was the most winnable from all the remaining fixtures under Smith I think!
Yes we rode our luck throughout in that game at Newcastle, the Toon were not at their best and we nearly did 'nick it' at the end had Castagne put away his injury time chance past Pope. Despite the draw against Everton then I also thought we looked pretty fluent in that 'six pointer' at home before that - and had Maddison not fluffed his pen.then we'd have stayed up of course, as others have said in this post too. We got lucky at Newcastle but then were unlucky in so far the final fixtures suiting escapologists Everton - but I guess we should have wrapped things up by then in various missed golden opportunity ways. In a way it felt like our relegation was 'meant to be' sadly.....