Yes, no one really understands them in depth in reality.
The amount of things that are and aren’t included is silly. A bit of creative accounting and you’re around them simply undermines the entire thing.
Then you have Man City with 115 odd charges, covering
54 charges of financial reporting,
14 charges of manager and player pay
12 charges of UEFA and PSR compliance
35 for non cooperation
These stem between 2009 through to 2017/2018, so would have potentially impacted not just us, but the butterfly effect of them financially doping so to speak outside of the rules could start a massive chain of events for legal challenges left, right and centre. I mean, how many teams have missed Champions League money in that period due to them finishing higher? You can’t even begin to put a an estimation on the consequential losses that this has caused to the wider football community if they are found guilty.
It won’t just be about stripping them of titles and docking points, then relegating them.
It is a litigation nightmare waiting to happen if the are found guilty, as by not dealing with it swiftly and it dragging on for years it could be one of the biggest legal cases of all time. If the Premier League and UEFA have any sense, they’ll have agreed a solution and outcome to this.
It’s a multi billion legal war waiting to happen in reality.
If they find them innocent (which at this point may be the lesser of two evils), then ourselves, Forest, Everton etc can then go after them for impacting our ability to grow for owner investment. Not that I believe we’d have bothered.
Can you imagine the fall out if they are found guilty?
Titles stripped and goes to the team in 2nd place.
2011/12 - Aguuuerrro. Title goes to Man U.
2013/14 - Gerrard slip. Title goes to Liverpool.
2017/18 - Title goes to Man U.
Teams that missed Champions League (worth £50 - £100m per season)
2011 - Tottenham
2012 - Newcastle
2013 - Tottenham
2014 - Everton
2015 - Tottenham
2016 - Man U
2017 - Arsenal
2018 - Chelsea
Then the relegated teams from the league each year. This is where it gets really messy.
09 - Hull, Burnley, Portsmouth
10 - Birmingham, Blackpool, West Ham
11 - Bolton, Blackburn, Wolves
12 - Wigan, Reading, QPR
13 - Norwich, Fulham, Cardiff
14 - Hull, Burnley, QPR
15 - Newcastle, Norwich, Villa
16 - Hull, Middlesbrough, Sunderland
17 - Swansea, Stoke, West Brom
Some of those have never recovered from that, how do you put a price on it?
Ultimately it then seems incredibly harsh to hammer ourselves, Everton and Forest for earlier periods when in reality, this should have been dealt with first.
The cynical person might say until now, PSR deductions haven’t relegated a team. I wonder if the Premier League / EFL want that on them if we go down, with this mess all up in the air. We ourselves could issue a massive legal war over this.
Can you imagine how Trump would be handling all of this if he owned a club in the Premier League. People would be getting sued for multi billion dollars based on defamation of character alone. Never mind the impact of what it’s could potentially have done.
This is even before you throw in the impact of what Chelsea have done as well. Albeit they’re complying and self reported a lot of the stuff they found, so are likely just to be hit with massive fines.