To be fair I think guy was mostly talking about Rudkin from an academy perspective which if you look at it objectively and individually it is very possible that Rudkin has done a good job in this respect. The academy is thriving and does have alot of good talent in and has produced some major prem stars since he has been in charge of it e.g. Chilwell, Barnes, KDH etc.
However as director of football he has failed there is no doubt about that