Agree. I firmly believe the majority don't want to sing most of the time now, don't know why exactly, societal changes, seating obviously. The old Main Stand at Filbert St was often silent. The Kop very rarely was. It's that simple, get everyone who wants an atmosphere in the same place. Efforts like this only bring that closer. I think UFS will have a fight on getting rid of the clappers, they are shit undoubtedly, but they are part of the marketing department matchday experience gubbins. But strangely I don't think there would be uproar if they did go, nobody was calling for them when we didn't have them. As @Markyblue said football without atmosphere isn't football and that ain't clappers.