MBK Posted 31 October 2006 Posted 31 October 2006 well played...very enjoyable to listen to on the stoke commentary. My only rating barber - 0
Harpenden Fox Posted 31 October 2006 Posted 31 October 2006 look forward to hearing whether Sylla was any good from those who attended. If he's half decent he does at least give us something of an option on the right
MBK Posted 31 October 2006 Author Posted 31 October 2006 look forward to hearing whether Sylla was any good from those who attended. If he's half decent he does at least give us something of an option on the right think kelly s trying to get him into dead ball type of player...villa corner etc...show he s being chosen for this purpouse.
cisono Posted 31 October 2006 Posted 31 October 2006 If Barber's commentary is anything to go by, it seems that McCarthy had another solid game, in spite of nose/eye socket/mask
coale39 Posted 31 October 2006 Posted 31 October 2006 Logan 5 Kenton 6.5 McCarthy 7.5 Stearman6.5 Nils 7 Tiatto 7 Hughes 6 Johnson 6 Sylla 5 HUMMMME 7.5 Hammand 6
Tommeh Posted 31 October 2006 Posted 31 October 2006 Logan 6 - saves good but kicking poor at times, although to be fair he had about 1 backpass to him every 3 minutes! Stearman 8 - attacked well and looked dolid throughout, back to his best hopefully McCarthy 7 Kenton 7 Nils 7 (the defence did very well and all looked comfortable throughout, but for a slightly fortuetous goal they'd have had a clean sheet. Not bad against a team who have hit 5 in ther previous game. Hughes 8 MOTM - huge improvement, picked the ball up from deep and looked to get attacks started. Seemed to take more responsibility too, and scored the vital goal Johnson 7 - showed the fight and determinstion that he's lacked since coming here, also kept the ball much better. Much improved keep it up Sylla 6 - seriously lacking movenment and rarely shows for the ball won the ball back well and put some tackles in though Tiatto 7 - showed fight and passion from start to finish Hammond 5 Huuuuuuuuuuuuuuume 8 Subs Fryatt 7 - good to see him back was much more effective than Hammond. Expect him to start v sheff wed.
coale39 Posted 31 October 2006 Posted 31 October 2006 You didn't like Logan's performance then... Nope. For the first goal I think he thought it was going out but it creeped in and kicking poor. First time ive seen him play as well..... i think Hughes did alright but i think he went missing for long periods.
Mark Posted 31 October 2006 Posted 31 October 2006 Logan 6 Stearman 6 McCarthy 8 Kenton 6 Johansson 6 Tiatto 7 Hughes 5 Johnson 5 Sylla 5 Hume 7 Hammond 4 Fryatt - 5 I thought we were pretty poor tonight, we looked devoid of any attacking play until Stoke scored. The midfield apart from Tiatto was completely non existent throughout the entire 90 minutes, again. Mind you, decent result
cisono Posted 31 October 2006 Posted 31 October 2006 i think Hughes did alright but i think he went missing for long periods. Where was he? (You mean from watching the match or from the commentary? Don't think it's possible to tell from Barber's partial rendition of the match)
coale39 Posted 31 October 2006 Posted 31 October 2006 Remember Skills running with the ball in the first half? He just kept running to there corner then lose the ball. Make me chuckle.
coale39 Posted 31 October 2006 Posted 31 October 2006 Where was he? (You mean from watching the match or from the commentary? Don't think it's possible to tell from Barber's partial rendition of the match) Hehe! From watching the match!
Simi Posted 31 October 2006 Posted 31 October 2006 Logan - 6 Stearman-7 Kenton-7 McCarthy-7.5 Nils-6 Tiatto-8 Hughes-7 Johnson-6 Syllla-6 Huuuuuumme-7 Hammond-6 Subs Fryatt-5 good result
3pts4awin Posted 31 October 2006 Posted 31 October 2006 Logan 6 did ok, kicking wasn't great Stearman 7 McCarthy 7.5 led by example Kenton 6.5 quite solid, one mistake, very good singing Johansson 7 showed some really good stuff of late Tiatto 7 probably the best ive ever seen him, 3 quality driving shots, unlucky Hughes 5 apart from the good goal, this man looks like a pub player after a heavy night Johnson 6.5 worked hard, wanted it Sylla 5 shows signs of quality, but lets himself down trying to be maradona Hume 8 easily the best player on the pitch Hammond 5 did ok, doesnt force himself on the game though Fryatt - 5 looked unwell challenging for the ball
Swedging Posted 31 October 2006 Posted 31 October 2006 Logan - 7 Although caught out, still talks so well to the rest of the team Stearman-7 - getting back to his best. Almost playing as a midfielder a lot of the time Kenton-7 - generally solid McCarthy-7 - tried to pass it today. May it long continue Nils-7 - better in the first half when he showed some of his touches of skill going forward. Reverted back to hoofing in the second Tiatto-8 - After everything. Was it 3 or 4 shots on target tonight, as well? Hughes-7 - A goal! Played pretty well after a lay off. Johnson-7 One of his better matches. Oraginised the team well, I thought. Syllla- 7 At times our most dangerous player. Did his spell of grafting and defending too. Huuuuuumme-6 A goal! But other than that, almost nothing came off from him Hammond-5 Looked ineffectual - perhaps worried about Fryatt taking his place Subs Fryatt-6 Pushed harder. not really on the same wavelength as everyone else yet.
Bert Posted 31 October 2006 Posted 31 October 2006 Logan 6 Stearman 7 McCarthy 8 Motm - Awesome. Kenton 6 Nils 7 Sylla 6 Tiatto 7 best performance this season. Hughes 7 Johnson 6 Hume 7 Hammond 6 Fryatt 5
AyewJoking Posted 31 October 2006 Posted 31 October 2006 Imagine if it was Henderson facing all those backpasses. Mind you, our outfield players probably wouldnt have passed it back to him anyway.
coale39 Posted 31 October 2006 Posted 31 October 2006 Logan - 7 Although caught out, still talks so well to the rest of the team Stearman-7 - getting back to his best. Almost playing as a midfielder a lot of the time Kenton-7 - generally solid McCarthy-7 - tried to pass it today. May it long continue Nils-7 - better in the first half when he showed some of his touches of skill going forward. Reverted back to hoofing in the second Tiatto-8 - After everything. Was it 3 or 4 shots on target tonight, as well? Hughes-7 - A goal! Played pretty well after a lay off. Johnson-7 One of his better matches. Oraginised the team well, I thought. Syllla- 7 At times our most dangerous player. Did his spell of grafting and defending too. Huuuuuumme-6 A goal! But other than that, almost nothing came off from him Hammond-5 Looked ineffectual - perhaps worried about Fryatt taking his place Subs Fryatt-6 Pushed harder. not really on the same wavelength as everyone else yet. Sylla - 7 is a insult to the other players that got 7.
3pts4awin Posted 31 October 2006 Posted 31 October 2006 Sylla - 7 is a insult to the other players that got 7. agreed. that said, he is better than he was a year ago.
coale39 Posted 31 October 2006 Posted 31 October 2006 agreed. that said, he is better than he was a year ago. I dont think he was mate. When he first came here he got by players. He also didn't give the ball away all the time.
dan_84 Posted 31 October 2006 Posted 31 October 2006 Logan 6. made a couple of brave saves but kicking was poor, for god sake play a short ball!! Stearman 6.5. early on had a touch of a rapist but slowly improved and had a decent game Kenton 6.5. tough going for him against the arial threat of their attack but done well McCarthy 7. again tough going, but as per usual wore his heart on his sleeve and put his body on the line Niise 7. Kept the ugliest git in the world (luke chadwick) very quiet, helped going forward aswell Sylla 6. wasnt bad, at least he tried and worked hard for the cause done nothing spectacular Johnson 5. runs around like robbie savage but in slow motion and without being effective Hughes 6.5. thought he was crap until he scored then seemed to spark into action Tiatto 8. MOM for me. he was everywhere, endless running and effort was unlucky that his 3 efforts on goal were straight at the keeper Hammond 4. Looked like a player who knew he was going to be out the team now fryatt is fit. done nothing. Huuuuume 7.5. quality again, got absolutly battered all game by their defence but never gave up running, jumping and just being huuuuuume!! Sub Fryatt 6. a couple of nice touches and looked a bit more of a threat after he came on. done more in 20 mins than hammond done in 70
Swedging Posted 31 October 2006 Posted 31 October 2006 Sylla - 7 is a insult to the other players that got 7. We all see it a different way, I guess. I thought that most of the match he delivered the most dangerous balls either into the box or across in front of goal.
Guest Gist Posted 31 October 2006 Posted 31 October 2006 Remember Skills running with the ball in the first half? He just kept running to there corner then lose the ball. Make me chuckle. Yeah I seen that, it made me laugh too.
Ultra Posted 31 October 2006 Posted 31 October 2006 Logan - 6. Stearman - 6. Kenton - 6. McCarthy - 7. Johansson - 6. Sylla - 5. Johnson - 5 Hughes - 6. Tiatto - 8* Hume - 7 Hammond - 5 Fryatt - 6
Milky Posted 31 October 2006 Posted 31 October 2006 Logan 6 Stearman 7 McCarthy 7 - The heading of McCarthy was pretty poor most of the time though, he must have put a stoke player through 4 times or so. Perhaps it was the mask, but 7 is fair cus he was soild for the most part. Kenton 6 - He was all over the stoke strikeforce like a randy octopus! struggled with the height. Nils 7 Sylla 6 Tiatto 7 1/2 - great to see a midfield player actually drive forward with the ball! Hughes 7 - ok he was non existent for 90 mins, but that 2 seconds for the goal has given us 3 points Johnson 6 - headless chicken Hume 7 Hammond 5 - when you know fryatt is on the bench and back from injury, you really should run till you're sick to keep your place. lazy. Fryatt 6 - showed nice touch
Recommended Posts
Archived
This topic is now archived and is closed to further replies.