Collymore Posted 2 August 2009 Posted 2 August 2009 Weale - 7 - Didn't have to do a lot. Kicking was excellent Morrison - 7 - looked ok a right back, made some good tackles Hobbs, - 6.5 - schoolboy slip nearly cost us Brown, - 6.5 - 10/10 for positioning 1/10 for distribution Berner, - 7 - Mr Steady Oakley, - 6.5 ok Wellens, - 7 looks good, always looks to use the ball A King, - 6 didn't really notice him too much Dyer, - 6.5 Showed glimpses of last season Howard, - 7 - wins headers and played others in N'Guessan. - 5 - Didn't even know why he was there, shockingly ineffective Subs Fryatt, - 7.5 could have had a hattrick, can't remember a shot on goal before he came on O'Neill, - 6.5 looks promising Adams, - 6.5 great pass near the end that nearly put fryatt in again Gradel - 6.5 - Seems to be wanting to cross too early now, should be encouraged to beat his man every now and then. Should have scored with a free header with first touch.
flanimal Posted 2 August 2009 Posted 2 August 2009 Are you saying rate the players based on radio commentary? I don't understand how to do that, if that's what you mean. But N'Guessan a 2? Doubt it, man.
Collymore Posted 2 August 2009 Author Posted 2 August 2009 Are you saying rate the players based on radio commentary? I don't understand how to do that, if that's what you mean.But N'Guessan a 2? Doubt it, man. I'm not on about real radio, couldn't spell vallavoid or whatever it is...
flanimal Posted 2 August 2009 Posted 2 August 2009 Oh right, thought you meant based on the commentary. I was gonna say man, that's impossible. Well, I wasn't there, so I can't rate anything, but N'Guessan *sounded* better than a 2.
MikeyT Posted 2 August 2009 Posted 2 August 2009 Weale - 7 - Didn't have to do a lot. Kicking was excellentMorrison - 7 - looked ok a right back, made some good tackles Hobbs, - 6.5 - schoolboy slip nearly cost us Brown, - 6.5 - 10/10 for positioning 1/10 for distribution Berner, - 7 - Mr Steady Oakley, - 6.5 ok Wellens, - 7 looks good, always looks to use the ball A King, - 6 didn't really notice him too much Dyer, - 6.5 Showed glimpses of last season Howard, - 7 - wins headers and played others in N'Guessan. - 2 - Didn't even know why he was there, shockingly ineffective Subs Fryatt, - 7.5 could have had a hattrick, can't remember a shot on goal before he came on O'Neill, - 6.5 looks promising Adams, - 6.5 great pass near the end that nearly put fryatt in again Gradel - 6.5 - Seems to be wanting to cross too early now, should be encouraged to beat his man every now and then. Should have scored with a free header with first touch. I would agree with most of that all apart from N'Guessan being 2. Think Wellens looks class. Very impressed with him. And young O'Neill looks a very good prospect and what Weale had to do he did well.
scinnell Posted 2 August 2009 Posted 2 August 2009 Agree with N'Guesson he has the pass but he needs to work on his finishing Dont aggree with fryatt could of had a hattrick couldnt remember him having 3 shots. Gradel should of scored that header just after the break.
scinnell Posted 2 August 2009 Posted 2 August 2009 Also is it just me but i compared Wellens to several other players and i thought he looked abit overweight but i good player!
�лек�андър Тунчев 5 Posted 2 August 2009 Posted 2 August 2009 n guessan 2???? were u even there??? a player who has come from leauge 2 against a defence that delt with messi and co last season??? at the end of the day hes a winger playing out off position, i thought his strength and pace troubled them on occasions! he will be a handfull next year! do you expect him to score 30 goals this year?? come on get behind the lad. apart from that wellens is a quality aqusition he looked a class above the rest of the midfield!!
Collymore Posted 2 August 2009 Author Posted 2 August 2009 n guessan 2???? were u even there??? a player who has come from leauge 2 against a defence that delt with messi and co last season??? at the end of the day hes a winger playing out off position, i thought his strength and pace troubled them on occasions! he will be a handfull next year! do you expect him to score 30 goals this year?? come on get behind the lad. apart from that wellens is a quality aqusition he looked a class above the rest of the midfield!! alright 2 is taking the piss, but he looked no better than DJ
Stuliasz Posted 2 August 2009 Posted 2 August 2009 Weale 7 - did what he had to do with minimum fuss Morrison 6.5 - as above Berner 6.5 - as above Hobbs 6 - same again except gave the ball away in a very dangerous situation, lucky not to be punished Brown 6.5 - got in the way of a lot Oakley 7 - impressed with his set pieces Dyer 6 - average, struggled to beat his man King 6 - anonymous Wellens 6.5 - most good but some very loose/lazy passing at times Howard 7 - worked hard and kept the ball up there better than N'Guessan. N'Guessan 5.5 - haven't been to the other friendlies but based on that, not a good option as a makeshift striker --- Fryatt 7.5 - lively and took his goal well O'Neill 6.5 - impressed with this lad Adams 7 - very energetic, won the ball back on multiple occasions and distributed it well Gradel 6.5 - made a difference having him as an outlet on the right, crossing was better than usual
clazkel Posted 2 August 2009 Posted 2 August 2009 Weale - 7 - Didn't have to do a lot. Kicking was excellentMorrison - 7 - looked ok a right back, made some good tackles Hobbs, - 6.5 - schoolboy slip nearly cost us Brown, - 6.5 - 10/10 for positioning 1/10 for distribution Berner, - 7 - Mr Steady Oakley, - 6.5 ok Wellens, - 7 looks good, always looks to use the ball A King, - 6 didn't really notice him too much Dyer, - 6.5 Showed glimpses of last season Howard, - 7 - wins headers and played others in N'Guessan. - 5 - Didn't even know why he was there, shockingly ineffective Subs Fryatt, - 7.5 could have had a hattrick, can't remember a shot on goal before he came on O'Neill, - 6.5 looks promising Adams, - 6.5 great pass near the end that nearly put fryatt in again Gradel - 6.5 - Seems to be wanting to cross too early now, should be encouraged to beat his man every now and then. Should have scored with a free header with first touch. I'd agree with your comments, apart from N'Guessan, i think as 5 is alittle harsh, as he started quite sharp and made afew decent runs. I totally agree with Brown, his positioning is excellent but his distribution was really poor. I thought Adams deserved a 7.5 as i thought the game changed when he come on as he opens play up
Vlad The Impaler Posted 2 August 2009 Posted 2 August 2009 Weale - 7.5 - Impressed me, looks very assured, good kick on him, fumbled one shot but apart from that good game. Morrison - 7 - Don't know what it is with people on here saying he isn't good enough and won't be able to cope in the championship, he is good enough and will become a very good player. Good, solid game. Hobbs - 6 - Didn't have the best of games, made a mistake or two but didn't do too badly. Brown - 7 - What you would expect, i'd like to see him and Tunch together at some point. Berner - 6 - Average game, did nothing spectaclar, nothing dreadful. Oakley - 6.5 - Got involved when he could made some nice passes. Wellens - 7.5 - Looks very good, a few people asked me who he was after the game, will be an important player, and I think at £1 mil he could be a bargain. King - 5.5 - Couldn't get into the game, would replace with Adams for Swansea, i'm not saying I don't rate him btw, he's one of my favourite players and he has a big future ahead of him, just Adams can make something happen. Dyer - 7 - Good game, took people on, could of crossed abit more early at times though, cause problems. N'Guessan - 4.5 - Didn't have a good game, but potential is clear in him, hope a can acheive it, was offside a bit. Howard - 8 - Man of match for me, won everything, good passes/vision. Taken his offside goal very well. SUBS Gradel - 7 - Caused problems, put some good balls in, seems to have been working on his crossing. O'Neil - 7 - Could be 'our next Mattock', looks good. Adams - 7.5 - Looked lively, thought he was going to start, should start against the swans, seems to improve every time I see him, good game. Fryatt - 7.5 - Didn't look as rusty as I had expected and took his goal well, I would personally start him against swansea. Burns - 5.5 - Looks to have potential and looked as though he wanted to get involved, wasn't on long enough to make a real judgement though in all honesty.
Flynny Posted 2 August 2009 Posted 2 August 2009 First time I've seen Luke O'Neill properly - looked alright! Better than I expected, looks ready to go if need be. Which is good, I missed being right-backs united. Let's get Gilbert back on loan.
Nick Posted 2 August 2009 Posted 2 August 2009 Weale - 7.5 - Impressed me, looks very assured, good kick on him, fumbled one shot but apart from that good game.Morrison - 7 - Don't know what it is with people on here saying he isn't good enough and won't be able to cope in the championship, he is good enough and will become a very good player. Good, solid game. Hobbs - 6 - Didn't have the best of games, made a mistake or two but didn't do too badly. Brown - 7 - What you would expect, i'd like to see him and Tunch together at some point. Berner - 6 - Average game, did nothing spectaclar, nothing dreadful. Oakley - 6.5 - Got involved when he could made some nice passes. Wellens - 7.5 - Looks very good, a few people asked me who he was after the game, will be an important player, and I think at £1 mil he could be a bargain. King - 5.5 - Couldn't get into the game, would replace with Adams for Swansea, i'm not saying I don't rate him btw, he's one of my favourite players and he has a big future ahead of him, just Adams can make something happen. Dyer - 7 - Good game, took people on, could of crossed abit more early at times though, cause problems. N'Guessan - 4.5 - Didn't have a good game, but potential is clear in him, hope a can acheive it, was offside a bit. Howard - 8 - Man of match for me, won everything, good passes/vision. Taken his offside goal very well. SUBS Gradel - 7 - Caused problems, put some good balls in, seems to have been working on his crossing. O'Neil - 7 - Could be 'our next Mattock', looks good. Adams - 7.5 - Looked lively, thought he was going to start, should start against the swans, seems to improve every time I see him, good game. Fryatt - 7.5 - Didn't look as rusty as I had expected and took his goal well, I would personally start him against swansea. Burns - 5.5 - Looks to have potential and looked as though he wanted to get involved, wasn't on long enough to make a real judgement though in all honesty. this tbh - a fair assessment Just got in..... However Howard for me was a 7 nothing wrong nothing special, I must have missed his good play. Spot on with king though - struggled today, gave the ball away 3 times in 10 minutes - the ginger was great, very creative looked like a player with vision, well done Nicky Adams.
iancognito Posted 3 August 2009 Posted 3 August 2009 Weale - 7 - Did everything you'd want, kicked well too Morrison - 6 - Not his best position, Oakley bollocked him twice for not getting forward which was harsh. Hobbs - 6 - 1 slip up nearly cost us but also got a couple of decent blocks in Brown - 7 - Needs to work on giving it to the midfield rather than just getting rid but was very solid & won everything. Berner - 5 - Sluggish and off the pace I thought, unlucky with a first half drive though. Oakley - 6 - Didn't take it by the scruff and one or two dead balls weren't his usual standard. Wellens - 7 - Seemed in control, very good in possession. Dyer - 6 - Energetic but wasn't given enough time on the ball by Vallolololodid. King - 5 - Looked as sluggish as Berner and didn't get on the ball enough. N'Guessan - 6 - Out of position but his pace will be more of a threat when he's out wide. Howard - 8 - Star man. Won everything in the air and was harshly treated by the ref. Jumping for the ball is an offence it seems this season. SUBS Burns - 6 - Showed some neat touches, definitely one for the future. O'Neil - 7 - Very solid, seems to have come on leaps & bounds. Gradel - 7 - Should have scored with a header, crossing was much better. Fryatt - 6 - Obviously behind in terms of fitness but took the goal very well. Adams - 6 - Lacks a burst of pace but didn't let anyone down.
Heart-Shaped Fox Posted 3 August 2009 Posted 3 August 2009 Weale - 7 Morrison - 6 Hobbs - 6 Brown - 6 Berner - 5 Oakley - 6 Wellens - 7 Dyer - 6 King - 5 N'Guessan - 6 Howard - 7 SUBS Burns - 6 O'Neil - 6 Gradel - 5 Fryatt - 7 Adams - 7
milan_foxes Posted 3 August 2009 Posted 3 August 2009 Weale - 8 Morrison - 7 Hobbs - 6 1/2 Brown - 8 Berner - 5 Oakley - 7 Wellens - 8 Dyer - 6 King - 5 N'Guessan - 4 Howard - 8 SUBS Burns - 5 O'Neil - 7 1/2 Gradel - 6 Fryatt - 5 Adams - 6
Recommended Posts
Archived
This topic is now archived and is closed to further replies.