It's whether he can turn it around or not. At Liverpool he really lost the plot in his last year or so in charge, even though the owners gave him every chance to turn it around. At Celtic when things started to go wrong he was earmarking his exit strategy and came here. Was his eye off the ball when he was linked with the United job recently?
But let's face it our league form in the first half of this season is how it was in the second half of the previous two seasons. Therefore, maybe with players coming back we can mirror those seasons in reverse. He's a feast or famine manager.
The concern with Rodgers is he's had his peak here. A lot of managers these days seem to do well in 2-3 year cycles rather than 5-7. Rodgers is someone who has personality flaws (like Mourinho).