Finnegan Posted 2 January 2007 Posted 2 January 2007 Easy enough question - I'm reading through the player rating's thread and Danny Cadamarteri seems to have had a very mixed reaction. So, as good, bad or ugly as he may have been - is he any better, or worse, in your opinion that Momo or Josh Low? And would he be preferable to Hughes pushed wide?
AyewJoking Posted 2 January 2007 Posted 2 January 2007 Cadamarteri until we decide he is useless too.
Leicester Lass Posted 2 January 2007 Posted 2 January 2007 Still Hughes for me, Danny Cadamarteri is nowhere near match fit and looked as rubbish as the rest of them yesterday.
morris1234 Posted 2 January 2007 Posted 2 January 2007 now youve showed all possible right mids i feel suicidal!! they are shocking!! we need ifill from sheff u
Simon Posted 2 January 2007 Posted 2 January 2007 Cadamarteri for me. God I cant believe I'm saying this...
Finnegan Posted 2 January 2007 Author Posted 2 January 2007 I'm probably going to get a stoning from Thracian for not putting Max Gradel on there.
Ultra Posted 2 January 2007 Posted 2 January 2007 Too right! Looking at the options available I wondered why his name was missing..
Thracian Posted 2 January 2007 Posted 2 January 2007 Andy King. 4-3-3. The rest aren't any sort of sensible option. If I had to stick with 4-4-2 I'd play the genuinely two footed Porter on the right and Tiatto on the left. And I'd let them interchange. Both naturally help in midfield anyway.
Finnegan Posted 2 January 2007 Author Posted 2 January 2007 To be honest, I was just putting realistic and likely options up there. The fact we've just pulled in Cadamarteri up from trial and slapped him on the right suggests to me Kelly has no intention of playing Gradel or King this season. Thus I don't see the point in discussing it here. I'm not asking what the ideal situation is, or what you'd do were YOU manager. We've had thousands of threads like that and thousands of "the youth team > the first team" discussions and I get the picture, you like the young'uns. But I'm asking, out of the likely, realistic right-wing options available to one mister Robert Kelly as of today, whom would you most like to see in the position.
Thracian Posted 2 January 2007 Posted 2 January 2007 To be honest, I was just putting realistic and likely options up there. The fact we've just pulled in Cadamarteri up from trial and slapped him on the right suggests to me Kelly has no intention of playing Gradel or King this season. Thus I don't see the point in discussing it here. I'm not asking what the ideal situation is, or what you'd do were YOU manager. We've had thousands of threads like that and thousands of "the youth team > the first team" discussions and I get the picture, you like the young'uns. But I'm asking, out of the likely, realistic right-wing options available to one mister Robert Kelly as of today, whom would you most like to see in the position. The point of discussing it is that if Kelly doesn't get sacked and if Kelly doesn't find someone who can get into the penalty box from midfield then, without Mandaric's money (and that's not arrived yet) we are likely to get relegated. And we'll get relegated because we won't score enough goals. King is the main option because I wouldn't be surprised if Gradel's farmed out somewhere in January.
potter3 Posted 2 January 2007 Posted 2 January 2007 I'm surprised there's only one vote for Sylla, he wasn't that bad earlier when he did get a couple of games. Saying that I didn't vote for him
The Stig Posted 2 January 2007 Posted 2 January 2007 I'm going to be asking this again in a week or so in the Foxestalk 11
A fox for life Posted 2 January 2007 Posted 2 January 2007 thats such a shit choice. if thats all we have to offer in that position we seriously need to buy players.
Tommeh Posted 2 January 2007 Posted 2 January 2007 Gradel I've heard great reports on him and looks a very good player. Out of the choices though I went for hughes as hes the only one with a bit of quality
Wils Posted 2 January 2007 Posted 2 January 2007 Lets throw Momo in again,see if he can proove us wrong.
Joe. Posted 2 January 2007 Posted 2 January 2007 At the moment Cadamarteri. Sylla's injured I'm not even going to describe Low Hughes is pathetic as a right winger Cadamarteri impressed me yesterday.
The People's Hero Posted 2 January 2007 Posted 2 January 2007 Sylla is the man easy. Best of a bad bunch. Have always thought he's had a BIT of a raw deal. Not much of one... he is quite lazy... but still, he's far more effective than the others. The only caveat is that where a 'narrow' approach suits... Hughes should play the role.
lcfc_jme Posted 2 January 2007 Posted 2 January 2007 Shocking choices really for the right wing, but based on what's there I'd go for Stephen Hughes. Danny Cad to back him up. Keep Sylla incase the said two players fail miserably. Shoot Josh Low.
Finnegan Posted 2 January 2007 Author Posted 2 January 2007 Elvis for me. Fair play, I did forget Elvis. I thought he was much better as a winger than a forward.
renards Posted 2 January 2007 Posted 2 January 2007 Hughes, the less of the evils but very light weight Cadamarteri was warming up just in front of me, having a laugh with all including Welsh Built like a weight lifter, not a footballer- very muscle bound and rigid his neck is wider than his head,
Joe. Posted 2 January 2007 Posted 2 January 2007 Hughes, the less of the evils but very light weight Cadamarteri was warming up just in front of me, having a laugh with all including Welsh Built like a weight lifter, not a footballer- very muscle bound and rigid his neck is wider than his head, He reminds me of Levi
Strokes Posted 2 January 2007 Posted 2 January 2007 Fair play, I did forget Elvis. I thought he was much better as a winger than a forward. His pace is an awesome asset to us, we just cannot afford his lack of intelligence up front. Given a run in the team at right mid, he could fulfil his potential.
Eastern Fox Posted 2 January 2007 Posted 2 January 2007 Who voted for Josh Low? Even Kelly thinks he's shit now.
Recommended Posts
Archived
This topic is now archived and is closed to further replies.