ousefox Posted 28 February 2010 Posted 28 February 2010 Quality game so far. The league cup has been surpsingly good this year.
Dylan Posted 28 February 2010 Posted 28 February 2010 Refs been poor! Vidic- clear sending off, but not given a yellow! Collins and Downing- if Vidic never got even a yellow for a lastman challenge, how in hell do they get a yellow. NO CONSISTENCY AT ALL. No surprise though, Man U always get the decision
Samilktray Posted 28 February 2010 Author Posted 28 February 2010 Refs been poor! Vidic- clear sending off, but not given a yellow!Collins and Downing- if Vidic never got even a yellow for a lastman challenge, how in hell do they get a yellow. NO CONSISTENCY AT ALL. No surprise though, Man U always get the decision Calm down its only Villa.
lildave3 Posted 28 February 2010 Posted 28 February 2010 :laugh: I absolutely adore DavieG. His cycnism and miserableness is always top notch
davieG Posted 28 February 2010 Posted 28 February 2010 :laugh:I absolutely adore DavieG. His cycnism and miserableness is always top notch Glad to be of service. You'd be surprised to know I'm actually enjoying the game and crap refereeing has become part and parcel of it. I rarely comment on the actual football because that's there to savour. Cynic is my birthname
Uncle Albert Posted 28 February 2010 Posted 28 February 2010 This is tasty. What German game you watching?
Uncle Albert Posted 28 February 2010 Posted 28 February 2010 What a header and what a player Wayne Rooney is.. best in the world at the minute.
Simi Posted 28 February 2010 Posted 28 February 2010 How cringeworthy are the Carling ads down the side of the pitch? "Fletcher > Maradonna"
lildave3 Posted 28 February 2010 Posted 28 February 2010 Valencia is absolutely brilliant. Some of the deliveries he puts in are top notch.
davieG Posted 28 February 2010 Posted 28 February 2010 Just for ld3 - they wouldn't have won if Vidic had been rightly red carded. I doubt we'll hear much from Fergie about poor/inconsistent/anti-ManU refereeing anytime soon.
dandannieldanok Posted 28 February 2010 Posted 28 February 2010 Man Utd deserved the win, although Vidic should have been sent off. Apart from the first 20 minutes, Villa were dire.
Dylan Posted 28 February 2010 Posted 28 February 2010 Vidic being sent off would've had a huge impact for me. If the ref made the correct decision (and it wasnt a hard decision), United would've played near enough the whole match with 10 men, without their best defender. This definately would of have made an impact in favour of Villa, as Agbonlahor's strength and pace would've teared United to shreds without Vidic. People will say it was because it was the 4th minute, but whether its 1st or last minute, denying a goalscoring opportunity is a STRAIGHT RED CARD. Like someone said earlier, i bet Fergie isn't gonna complain about Phil Dowd now. Big teams get the decisions too much
Corky Posted 28 February 2010 Posted 28 February 2010 Only saw the second half, Man Utd looked the better side and deservedly won. Shame for MON, would've liked to have seen him win this cup again.
dandannieldanok Posted 28 February 2010 Posted 28 February 2010 Vidic being sent off would've had a huge impact for me. We'll never know. I personally don't think it would have made a tremendous difference, especially if you take into consideration Man Utd's recent performance at Villa Park with 10 men.
Dylan Posted 28 February 2010 Posted 28 February 2010 We'll never know. I personally don't think it would have made a tremendous difference, especially if you take into consideration Man Utd's recent performance at Villa Park with 10 men. But then it was Nani sent off after around 30mins. This would've been Vidic for the whole game. Nani's a good player, but can be replaced. Vidic can not imo, as Man Utd's only defensive sub would've been Brown, who is no match for Vidic.
leicesterfox86 Posted 1 March 2010 Posted 1 March 2010 We'll never know. I personally don't think it would have made a tremendous difference, especially if you take into consideration Man Utd's recent performance at Villa Park with 10 men. Would have made a huge difference. 1-0 up against ten men, no matter who you are playing, you are going to fancy your chances.
Recommended Posts
Archived
This topic is now archived and is closed to further replies.