I'd give him the cup, but with level of players we had, 5th place was an under-achievement , we should've at least finished 3rd. Don't forget we were second place for the majority of those two seasons.
Conference leauge semi-final doesn't really count. We we're better 90% of the team we should've been in the finals but we played like shit towards the end of the tournament.
Rodgers was the villain from the beginning most of us were blind to see it until it was too late.
Cooper is just the same making look like he has good results despite the players we when in reality it's just the opposite.