Rank the players in order from best-worst this season

[Corky]

Howard or King. Not sure.

Yep. Fryatt has scored the goals but I believe Howard is just as important to our team.

King has stepped up to the plate this season, hope he continues to develop.

[Miquel The Work Geordie]

Yeah but I mean, if you include Davies he'll probably be top five on most people's lists.

You include DJ and more or less everyone will have him bottom 3. Is there really a point?

Well, yeah, if the list is meant to include the good as well as the bad, I guess. It's not "players of the season" or anything, although I'm not really sure even maddog knows what this thread's purpose is.

[bluebeau]

Well, yeah, if the list is meant to include the good as well as the bad, I guess. It's not "players of the season" or anything, although I'm not really sure even maddog knows what this thread's purpose is.

Yeah I agree with you. It's virtually impossible to put players in order of merit when some of the best have only played a few games.

Further points - IMO.........

1) Chris Powell not include in top 18, can't agree.

2) Had he not suffered injury, Kisnorbo would have been right up there.

3) Warner has scored high in the games he has played, but can't be placed in the list for such few games.

4) If only!!! Davies had played most of the season, he would have been no.1.

It's all in the eye of the beholder!

[Ultra]

1. Fryatt

2. Tunchev

3. Hobbs

4. Howard

5. Gilbert

6. Martin

7. King

8. Oakley

9. Mattock

10. Davies

11. Dyer

12. Morrison

13. Berner

14. Gradel

15. Cleverley

16. Powell

17. Dickov

18. Hayles

19. Adams

[Mr Happy]

1) Howard

2) Oakley and King

4) Hobbs

5) Fryatt

6) Tunchev

7) Berner

8) Gradel

9) Gilbert

10) Henderson and Martin - Injuries hampered both their progress, I would like to have seen who would have been No.1 if both were fit

12) Morrison

13) Dyer - Should be higher but recent performances have been dire

14) Powell - Again if he had played a few more games he would be higher

15) Mattock

16) Hayles

17) Dickov

Edworthy, Adams, DJ, Brown, Cleverly, Davies, Warner, Stockdale, Bunn etc these players have made their own contributions to our season but can't be fairly rated because they have just not played enough games for city this season to be, IMO, included in this list.

[billyfox1]

1. Tunchev

2. Howard

3. Fryatt

4. Davies

5. Hobbs

6. King

7. Morrison

8. Dyer

9. Oakley

10. Cleverly

11. Berner

12. Gilbert

13. Powell

14. Mattock

15. Gradel

16. Martin

17. Hayles

18. Dickov

19. Adams

[lefox]

Joint 1st. Hobbs, Tunchev, Davies, Howard, King, Fryatt, Oakley, Dyer, Cleverley, Powell, Martin, Gilbert, Morrison, Mattock, Gradel, Berner, Hayles,

18. Ball boys

19. Any opposing player whos scored an own goal or given a dodgy back pass etc

20. Tea Lady

21. Kit Man

22. Youth squad

23. Me

24. Thracian

25. Marketing manager

26. Milan

27. Bill Anderson

28. Dickov

[ThorpeAstleyFox]

1. Howard

2. Tunchev

3. Hobbs

4. Fryatt

5. Oakley

6. Gilbert

7. Cleverley

8. Dyer

9. King

10. Martin

11. Morrison

12. Berner

13. Gradel

14. Mattock

15. Powell

16. Adams

17. Campbell

18. Dickov

I have only included the players who have made at least 10 appearences (I think!).

[The Doctor]

1. Tunchev

2. Fryatt

3. Davies

4. Howard

5. Dyer

6. Hobbs

7. King

8. Berner

9. Morrison

10. Cleverley

11.Powell

12.Gilbert

13. Gradel

14. Mattock

15. Oakley

16. Martin

17. Adams

18. Hayles

19,000,000. Dickov

[pooleyLCFC]

1. Tunchev

2. Davies

3. Howard

4. King

5. Hobbs

6. Fryatt

7. Oakley

8. Berner

9. Powell

10. Martin

11.Morrison

12.Gilbert

13. Dyer

14. Dickov

15. Gradel

16. Cleverly

17. Adams

18. Mattock

19. Hayles

i think this is spot on but swap adams and mattock and drop dickov a few places