davieG Posted 22 August 2004 Posted 22 August 2004 This is not what you think he's worth (£Nil) after the first 4 games but what you think the tribunal will rule as a fair payment. Read the Guidelines below and make a considered guess at the Value they put on him. There could well be an appeal, this vote is only for the original decision. IMPORTANT - You only need to vote on the basic payment, not all the extras, see examples where this figure is highlighted Football League Regulation 60 determines the compensation fee for players out of contact, i.e. 60.1 In determining the compensation fee under regulation 59.5 The Football League Appeals Committee shall take into account the costs set out in regulations 60.2 and 60.3 and any of the criteria st out in regulation 60.4. 60.2 Any costs incurred by eithr club in operating a Football Academy of Centre of Excellence including (without limitation) the cost of providing for students: 60.2.1 living accommodation 60.2.2 training and playing facilities 60.2.3 scouting, coaching, administrative and other staff 60.2.4 education and welfare requirements 60.2.5 playing and training strip and other clothing 60.2.6 medical and first aid facilities 60.2.7 friendly and competitive matches and overseas tours. 60.3 Any other costs incurred by the transferor club directly attributable to the training and development of players including any compensation fee referred to in regulation 60.4.3. 60.4 The criteria are: 60.4.1 the status of the two clubs involved 60.4.2 the age of the player 60.4.3 the amount of any compensation fee paid by the transferor club upon acquiring the registration of the player 60.4.4 the length of time during which the tranferor club held the registration of the player 60.4.5 the terms of the new contract offered to the player by both clubs 60.4.6 the player's playing record in club and international tem appearances 60.4.7 substantiated interest shown by other clubs in acquiring the services of the player. FOOTBALL LEAGUE APPEALS COMMITTEE DECISIONS SEASON 2002/03 Tyrone Mears Manchester City to Preston North End £50,000 + £25,000 after 10 first team appearances + £25,000 after 20 first team appearances + £25,000 after 30 first team appearances + £25,000 after 40 first team appearances + £25,000 after 50 first team appearances + 20% of any future excess Delroy Facey Huddersfield Town to Bolton Wanderers £100,000 + £50,000 after 5 fist team appearances + £50,000 after 10 first team appearances + £50,000 after 15 first team appearances + £50,000 after 20 first team appearances + £50,000 after 25 first team appearances + 15% of any future excess Sean Thornton Tranmere Rovers to Sunderland £225,000 + £50,000 after first team debut + £75,000 after 10 first team appearances + £75,000 after 20 first team appearances + £75,000 after 30 first team appearances + £75,000 after 40 first team appearances + £50,000 after first full International Cap + 15% of any future excess Sol Davis Swindon Town to Luton Town £60,000 +£15,000 after 20 first team appearances + £15,000 after 40 first team appearances + £15,000 after 60 first team appearances + 15% of any future excess FOOTBALL LEAGUE APPEALS COMMITTEE DECISIONS SEASON 2003/2004 James O’Connor Stoke City to West Bromwich Albion £250,000 + £25,000 after 15 first team appearances + £25,000 after 30 first team appearances + £50,000 after a Full International Cap + 10% of any excess
SilverFox Posted 22 August 2004 Posted 22 August 2004 The change in my pocket...let me see...£1.58 Personally I think that is too much!
SilverFox Posted 22 August 2004 Posted 22 August 2004 The change in my pocket...let me see...£1.58Personally I think that is too much! 13955[/snapback] If the hearing decides £250,000 or something close to that does it mean we will have some money left to spend on a midfielder with a bit of backbone! Instead of the spineless crap we have at the moment! I don't care if he is 95, please just someone who can make that killer pass which can put our strikers on goal. When Pompey went up they had Merson, when we went up we had Izzet...someone creative please! Even if they are winding down their career I don't care, just need someone who can produce the goods so we don't have to watch Watford play ever again.
Mark Posted 22 August 2004 Posted 22 August 2004 I'm going for £750,000. He has played for Scotland as well so he's an international player (somehow)
King Kyle lcfc Posted 22 August 2004 Posted 22 August 2004 can i just ask what happens if we cant afford him will forest get him back please god
Guest Daniel Posted 22 August 2004 Posted 22 August 2004 £1,250 i think, dont know why so dont ask.
Mad Dog Posted 22 August 2004 Posted 22 August 2004 can i just ask what happens if we cant afford him will forest get him back please god 14008[/snapback] Can't happen. We have to pay for him even if it's £20,000,000. It won't be over a million though. The biggest tribunal fee in history is £300k or something. They are bullshit.
Sparky Posted 22 August 2004 Posted 22 August 2004 i thinks its gonna be about £500,000 due to being a full scottish international
Ash Posted 22 August 2004 Posted 22 August 2004 £500,000 Full Scottish International Age Prospect for the future
Scow Posted 23 August 2004 Posted 23 August 2004 £600k - Any more than that, and I will be extremely surprised.
Ric Flair Posted 23 August 2004 Posted 23 August 2004 Joe Kinnear wants any money from Gareth Williams' tribunal to go towards his transfer kitty. Kinnear was travelling to London today to find out how much Leicester must pay for the Scottish midfielder. Forest will also discover the fee they will pay Stoke City for Kris Commons at the Football League tribunal. And Kinnear wants the cash to boost his squad, after admitting it is unlikely he would receive any money if Andy Reid was sold. He said: "I will be looking to invest that money and I will be disappointed if I am not allowed to spend it. "We have already turned down an offer of £750,000 for Williams and we will be looking for £3million. "I would think money from any sale of Reidy would go towards servicing the debt. But we are running a tight ship. I have only been able to spend £25,000 since I have been here." The amount Leicester will pay will be governed by how long Williams has been at the City Ground and the wages the Foxes have offered him. Other factors like the money the club got for Jermaine Jenas and David Prutton will also be taken into consideration, as will the fact Williams has played for Scotland. It is a compensation issue rather than any perceived value he might have in the transfer market. Kinnear said: "Hopefully, we will get something like what we think Gareth is worth. "We offered him a king's ransom to stay and they offered more. "I think he is up there on a par with the likes of Prutton and Jenas. "We have got to get someone in to replace him and the chairman is well aware of that and, hopefully, this might give me a bit more leeway." ****in hell!
davieG Posted 23 August 2004 Author Posted 23 August 2004 Joe Kinnear wants any money from Gareth Williams' tribunal to go towards his transfer kitty.Kinnear was travelling to London today to find out how much Leicester must pay for the Scottish midfielder. Forest will also discover the fee they will pay Stoke City for Kris Commons at the Football League tribunal. And Kinnear wants the cash to boost his squad, after admitting it is unlikely he would receive any money if Andy Reid was sold. He said: "I will be looking to invest that money and I will be disappointed if I am not allowed to spend it. "We have already turned down an offer of £750,000 for Williams and we will be looking for £3million. "I would think money from any sale of Reidy would go towards servicing the debt. But we are running a tight ship. I have only been able to spend £25,000 since I have been here." The amount Leicester will pay will be governed by how long Williams has been at the City Ground and the wages the Foxes have offered him. Other factors like the money the club got for Jermaine Jenas and David Prutton will also be taken into consideration, as will the fact Williams has played for Scotland. It is a compensation issue rather than any perceived value he might have in the transfer market. Kinnear said: "Hopefully, we will get something like what we think Gareth is worth. "We offered him a king's ransom to stay and they offered more. "I think he is up there on a par with the likes of Prutton and Jenas. "We have got to get someone in to replace him and the chairman is well aware of that and, hopefully, this might give me a bit more leeway." ****in hell! 14413[/snapback] Well I don't see anywhere in the criteria listed above that the money they received from Prutton and Jenas would have any bearing. I'm als ont aware of any sunstative interest from other clubs. Having said that their is arumour amongst the trees that it has been fixed at £1.2m rising to £1.5m depending on appearances. :w00t:
Steven Posted 23 August 2004 Posted 23 August 2004 ... their is a rumour amongst the trees that it has been fixed at £1.2m rising to £1.5m depending on appearances. :w00t: 14494[/snapback] Send him back. <_<
atree Posted 23 August 2004 Posted 23 August 2004 ... their is a rumour amongst the trees that it has been fixed at £1.2m rising to £1.5m depending on appearances. :w00t: 14494[/snapback] Send him back. <_< 14498[/snapback] that's the joy of it all, you can't, you will be bound to the price (but i think it can go to appeal) what's he got a four year contract? he should come good in about three and a half years then when he's looking for a new one. i've seen the rumour of the price, but that is all it is at the mo, a rumour, don't know with your lot but 99.999% of em are carp
Micky Posted 23 August 2004 Posted 23 August 2004 ... their is a rumour amongst the trees that it has been fixed at £1.2m rising to £1.5m depending on appearances. :w00t: 14494[/snapback] Send him back. <_< 14498[/snapback] that's the joy of it all, you can't, you will be bound to the price (but i think it can go to appeal) what's he got a four year contract? he should come good in about three and a half years then when he's looking for a new one. i've seen the rumour of the price, but that is all it is at the mo, a rumour, don't know with your lot but 99.999% of em are carp 14619[/snapback] "99.999% of em are carp" Whats the fish link! I don't get it!
SilverFox Posted 23 August 2004 Posted 23 August 2004 ... their is a rumour amongst the trees that it has been fixed at £1.2m rising to £1.5m depending on appearances. :w00t: 14494[/snapback] Send him back. <_< 14498[/snapback] that's the joy of it all, you can't, you will be bound to the price (but i think it can go to appeal) what's he got a four year contract? he should come good in about three and a half years then when he's looking for a new one. i've seen the rumour of the price, but that is all it is at the mo, a rumour, don't know with your lot but 99.999% of em are carp 14619[/snapback] "99.999% of em are carp" Whats the fish link! I don't get it! 14677[/snapback] perhaps the rumours are a bit...fishy I'll get my coat
Guest freund Posted 23 August 2004 Posted 23 August 2004 ... their is a rumour amongst the trees that it has been fixed at £1.2m rising to £1.5m depending on appearances. :w00t: 14494[/snapback] Send him back. <_< 14498[/snapback] that's the joy of it all, you can't, you will be bound to the price (but i think it can go to appeal) what's he got a four year contract? he should come good in about three and a half years then when he's looking for a new one. i've seen the rumour of the price, but that is all it is at the mo, a rumour, don't know with your lot but 99.999% of em are carp 14619[/snapback] "99.999% of em are carp" Whats the fish link! I don't get it! 14677[/snapback] perhaps the rumours are a bit...fishy I'll get my coat 14697[/snapback] Cod off...
Micky Posted 24 August 2004 Posted 24 August 2004 Thats not very nice freund. I think eel be abit offended!
atree Posted 24 August 2004 Posted 24 August 2004 that's the tench time i've heard that anymore and i'll bream and bream until i'm sick i'll get my coat we do have a player called perch and guppy scored against us at the weekend
Scow Posted 24 August 2004 Posted 24 August 2004 £600k - Any more than that, and I will be extremely surprised. 14394[/snapback] Have it!
Recommended Posts
Archived
This topic is now archived and is closed to further replies.