The KP is as quiet as a bloody library without the clappers. I actually think we need them with our fan base, of mostly families, to create any sort of atmosphere.
In an ideal world we would have more singing fans, but we don't, and the games this season without the clappers have been so dead its been embarrassing.
I think a quiet stadium is worse for our reputation than the clappers personally.
Goal music on the other hand, I hate and can go!