Spicer

I think a red is harsh. I understand why it was given, but I think a yellow would of been sufficient. I didn't like either set of players surrounding the ref.

Callum Elder starts for Wigan tonight at LB against Man City. Live on BBC 1.

Thought this deserved its own thread. Ryan Mason forced to retired after suffering a fractured skull against Chelsea last season. Poor guy http://www.bbc.co.uk/sport/football/43045432

Maguire again not close to his man and allows him space

I think Mahrez did kinda get the better off Zinchenko in the cup. Put him 1v1 against him

Kind of Man City to gift us a goal

I honestly expect us to get thrashed.

God I hope not. At least that might be up for doubt with Jones and Smalling playing well together for United.

I checked and you're right. He didn't play in the league, just the cups. But he was part of the title winning squad.

Chillwell, Gray or Amartey.

Be angry at our players for performing like shit. Forget the rest.

Why not? He isn't getting a move. May as well get on with it.

Probably the best time to change things. Kasper Dragovic Maguire Fuchs Albrighton Silva Iborra Chillwell Mahrez Nacho Vardy

I think it can be summed up by in the 90th minute, Seamus Cloeman (who's been injured for many months) running past Fuchs (who's been on the pitch for 10 minutes).

Well James had played well the last few games. Don't get me wrong he was awful today (apart from his shot being cleared of the line) but so were Ndidi, Maguire and all of our regular 1 XI players who have been good.

That was awful. Worst performance this season

Maguire's ball control is pretty shocking today

We are being dominated and cant hold the ball. i think we need silva and Iborra to just keep the ball for more than a pass.

All of our players are having a shocker. Ever since the first goal went in.

I know it is only a loan, but if he does move permanently at some point then I hope we give him a testimonial

He'll only be aloud to go if the money is met. It's good that we've said no to 50 mil. With it being understood that that's not even close to our valuation

An assist off Hamers nuts

I don't think the ref has been awful. They got the Willian one wrong but all the other big decisions I think were right. Why aren't they doing the new penalty system?

Whilst at the match the VAR uses could be improved. In rugby the recordings are shown on the screens for everyone to see, so fans know what is going on

Mahrez captain. Interesting. Very strong side including the bench.