There has been talk from our fans about a decline in our ability to recruit effectively since Rodgers has come in but is this accurate ?
I would argue that since the summer of 2016 we have had a mixed bag in terms of success in the market but on the whole its been positive. The 2018/19 was an example of how good our recruitment can be as Soyuncu,Maddison,Perreira,Evans, and Tielemans in the January window were all excellent signings, but since the departure of Walsh, I would argue that windows like 2018/19 have been the exception rather than the rule. Lets analyse how many successful signings we've made since winning the title in 2016.
successful signings 2016/17
Ndidi
successful signings 2017/18
Maguire
Iheanacho
successful signings 2018/19
Soyuncu
Pereirra
Evans
Maddison
Tielemans
successful signings 2019/20
Justin
(Tielemans on a permanent)
successful signings 2020/21
fofana
castagne
Appreciate that what constitutes a successful signing is subjective, but by looking at this it becomes obvious that since Rodgers came in, we've reverted to our usual success rate of one or usually two players that would prove to be a success, so I think it would be unfair to solely blame Rodgers, and whoever would have come in after we sacked Puel was always going to have a decline in terms of the success rate of signings.
P.S
Didn't include the summer signings of 2021/22 as the jury is still out on Soumare, but Lookman and Daka in particular are looking good !