teblin Posted 30 March 2008 Posted 30 March 2008 I thought howard showed why we signed him. great in the air held the ball up brought people into play. Shame he didn't have dj along side him as he would've had the pace to get on to some of the flicks.
reynard Posted 30 March 2008 Posted 30 March 2008 [bell 7.5 (Proper footballer. Positive. Showed an ability to beat his man and picked out a man with his crosses instead of just hitting them over hopefully. My kind of player). let's see what he can do over more than 1 half. He wasn't too great in the first was he really? Seem to remember you enthusing about zolt after 1 match. He was playing against a team at his level. next week is the big test. zolt 1 (Made very little impact in the short time he had to mainly close people down). Sorry But this is a ridiculous rating. He did close people down but was only on for 5 mins. Surely not worth a rating at all. But I guess you just don't like the guy!
Jimmy Posted 30 March 2008 Posted 30 March 2008 Sorry But this is a ridiculous rating. He did close people down but was only on for 5 mins. Surely not worth a rating at all. But I guess you just don't like the guy! of course he doesn't he's keeping his new academy obsession out of the 1st team picture
Narborough Bod Posted 30 March 2008 Posted 30 March 2008 My ratings are totally different to most people's.I can't believe Kisnorbo and McAuley have got such high ratings today. Normally I'm full of praise for these two but I thought today they were both defensively poor. Same for Stearman as well. We looked a shambles at times with marking etc and I just didn't like it. And I must have missed something with Weso Thought Kisnorno, McCauley and Henderson looked as if they had never played together, serious lack of communication. To me, to you... At least the RB / RW combo looked good going forward, let's hope it's not another 1 match wonder when a new player comes in.
Dames Posted 30 March 2008 Posted 30 March 2008 Henderson: 7 Did all that was necessary with complete competence. A clean sheet is always praiseworthy. Stearman 7.5: A hand in the goal and another excellent all round contribution. Kisnorbo 6.5 (Solid if largely untested at the back. If only we'd stop letting him take free kicks) McAuley 6.5 (Another who made a steady contribution to a clean sheet) Mattock 6.5 (One particularly good sortie forward and a solid general display). Bell 7.5 (Proper footballer. Positive. Showed an ability to beat his man and picked out a man with his crosses instead of just hitting them over hopefully. Played a part in the goal too. My kind of player if he can keep it up.). Hendrie 8 (Vital goal, brilliantly taken. Played himself to a standstill. Always looking for a telling pass) Oakley 7 (Busy and constructive) Weso 7.5 (Lacked a little sharpness but his prompting and support did so much to establish our ascendancy. Made the tackle that led to the goal.) Howard 8 (Won everything in the air and laid the ball off intelligently to various support players. Close to a goal himself and a real handful for S****horpe) Fryatt 6.5 (You have to mean it with headers from five yards. Deserves credit for getting into golscoring positions but simply failed to take some good chances). Subs: Clemence 0 (Should never have been introduced and had a negative impact for the short time he was there) Bruno 6.5 (Help restore our stability and helped thwart such belated threat as Sunthorpe posed, which wasn't a lot). Zsolt 1 (Made very little impact in the short time he had to mainly close people down). That was pretty fair right up untill the last rating. Really? Cmon.
Thracian Posted 31 March 2008 Posted 31 March 2008 of course he doesn't he's keeping his new academy obsession out of the 1st team picture First Kaebi, now Laczko. What is it about foreign imports that gets people wanting them in the team no matter what they do? Don't make out I'm biased. Look back to my reaction to Laczko's first game against Coventry. I was as thrilled by his performance as anyone. But even then the signs were there. He took up good positions but never looked like he had the determination to finish. I thought it was new arrival nerves but what has there been since? If any ex-Academy player had come into the first team and performed similarly there isn't a soul on here would have been calling for his continued inclusion. Not one. Laczko has much to learn to make him an English League footballer but while that's the place Holloway sees as right for the Academy graduates to finish their education that doesn't seem to apply so readily for Laczko. Presumably because Holloway wants to make his mind up about the bloke. But is our first team really the place for such experimentation? Laczko did play once in the reserves. I expected him to be running at people all night, causing havoc and getting endless shots in. But it wasn't the case. He did okay but just looked like another player in the team. Others caught the eye far more often. When he does shine, in any match, I'll be more than pleased to acknowledge it.
Thracian Posted 31 March 2008 Posted 31 March 2008 That was pretty fair right up untill the last rating.Really? Cmon. He can have an N/A if you prefer.
Dr The Singh Posted 1 April 2008 Posted 1 April 2008 henderson 4 Never dominanted the box, kicking was crap mattock 6 ok. steady and some good crosses but some junk ones as well. Mccauley 5 Made simple mistakes, passing was crap kisnorbo 4 Similar to mccauley. usual poor free kicks. Stearman 6 Steady weso 6 Steady but not match fit oakley 6 another ok performance which improved towards the end. hendrie 7 Scored a good goal, steady bell 7 Steady and always looked for a pass and made some good moves Howard 5.5 Movement was poor, but his passing when he got the ball was crisp fryatt 6 Got into good areas, but missed too many good opportunities sbs clemence n/a lazcko n/a bruno 6.5 Steady performance, made some good passes
davieG Posted 1 April 2008 Posted 1 April 2008 henderson 4 Never dominanted the box, kicking was crapmattock 6 ok. steady and some good crosses but some junk ones as well. Mccauley 5 Made simple mistakes, passing was crap kisnorbo 4 Similar to mccauley. usual poor free kicks. Stearman 6 Steady weso 6 Steady but not match fit oakley 6 another ok performance which improved towards the end. hendrie 7 Scored a good goal, steady bell 7 Steady and always looked for a pass and made some good moves Howard 5.5 Movement was poor, but his passing when he got the ball was crisp fryatt 6 Got into good areas, but missed too many good opportunities sbs clemence n/a lazcko n/a bruno 6.5 Steady performance, made some good passes What! Where you even there!!!!
Recommended Posts
Archived
This topic is now archived and is closed to further replies.