Jimmy Posted 24 October 2006 Posted 24 October 2006 after tonights game which of the 2 deserves the spot at QPR?
filbertway Posted 24 October 2006 Posted 24 October 2006 Logan for me, he's still the better of the two.
Tommeh Posted 24 October 2006 Posted 24 October 2006 Went for Henderson tonight he was unbelievable!! Ain't bothered either way though if Logans in its cool. Win Win situation but a nightmatre for RK
lildave3 Posted 24 October 2006 Posted 24 October 2006 Henderson played brillaint tonight, but i still say Conrad is the better keeper.
Coxy Posted 24 October 2006 Posted 24 October 2006 Play Hendo, but if he's not having a stunner again go back to Logan. He's still the better overall.
Bert Posted 24 October 2006 Posted 24 October 2006 Logan. I know Hendo was awesome tonight but I'm sure Logan was only dropped because he is now our number 1 and this is the cup. We haven't lost *touches wood* with Logan in goal and just because Hendo had a blinder tonight he shouldn't not play Logan, it may well be harsh on Hendo, but what i've just said is the harsh reality about it all.
Ultra Posted 24 October 2006 Posted 24 October 2006 Logan must have been ill or injured. I can't imagine RK would have dropped him. He's been more consistent than Henderson this season and should still be the first choice keeper when fit.
Thracian Posted 24 October 2006 Posted 24 October 2006 Logan. Henderson's shown himself to be an excellent shot stopper, as he did once more tonight. But he should have bawled for the ball that Low cleared just before cleaning the bloke out completely if necessary and he's nothing like as good with his kicking and distribution. We have to start playing our best side some day and Logan would be part of that.
Bert Posted 24 October 2006 Posted 24 October 2006 Logan was ahving shots took at him ni the warm up.
lookwhaticando Posted 25 October 2006 Posted 25 October 2006 Logan must have been ill or injured. I can't imagine RK would have dropped him. He's been more consistent than Henderson this season and should still be the first choice keeper when fit. Nah - just our policy of giving the second choice keeper a run out in the League Cup. That's how Henderson got into the first team to begin with last season, he played in the cup. Henderon again being second choice was chosen for the cup. Just keeps them ticking over, I guess. Normal service should resume at QPR.
dandannieldanok Posted 25 October 2006 Posted 25 October 2006 I don't see how we can drop Hendo after last night. If RK does drop him, I would be very surprised!
TAFKA Castroneves Posted 25 October 2006 Posted 25 October 2006 Hendo, it would be unfair to drop him after that performance. But i'm sure Conrad would get his chance again somewhere down the line.
Leicester Lass Posted 25 October 2006 Posted 25 October 2006 Logan has got to keep the shirt, Henderson still looks nervy on crosses to me and his kicking gives possession away more often than not. Fair play to him for last night, he put in a cracking performance but for me Logan is still the better keeper.
holly Posted 25 October 2006 Posted 25 October 2006 Hendo did a fantastic job tonight even his kickin has improved but i still feel nervous when the ball comes near him and i dont when logan plays so i say logan
Yaxx Posted 25 October 2006 Posted 25 October 2006 I must admit I was surprised to see Henderson in the starting line up last night. He did a magnificent job, but I have ot agree with Tharacian in that he should have given Low a shout and claimed the ball at the end. Still, nonethemore for that, he had his best game for the club. However, Logan has proved to be the more consistant and I think he should have the nod against QPR. A good sign when the keepers have to compete for a place though!
Ric Flair Posted 25 October 2006 Posted 25 October 2006 I don't see how we can drop Hendo after last night. If RK does drop him, I would be very surprised! How can you drop Logan after the way he's been playing though? Won us the game at Hereford, was practically unbeatable at Birmingham and made some amazing saves in his other games. Logan got his chance because Henderson was inconsistent. Henderson has come back in as Kelly always rests his No. 1 keeper in the Carling Cup. Henderson did very well last night, but first half he flapped at some crosses and we were lucky not to be 2-0 down in the first 15 mins and that probably would have been game over. Logan still shades it for me, but he'll have to keep up his impressive displays as hendo is a sublime shot stopper.
Joe. Posted 25 October 2006 Posted 25 October 2006 I think it's very hard but Logan hasn't put a foot wrong yet really. he deserves his place and like others have said, overall he is the better keeper.
Libertine Posted 25 October 2006 Posted 25 October 2006 I think I'm in love with Paul Henderson at the moment, but I'd still go with the Logmeistergeneral.
Swedging Posted 25 October 2006 Posted 25 October 2006 Logan. He's just much better tactically and communicates far more (he's always suggesting moves for the defence when they're facing him), he catches crosses and his kicking is better. Although Hendo seems to have improved his kicking a lot.
MONreborn Posted 25 October 2006 Posted 25 October 2006 Where does Rab Douglas fit in to this I think that it does not matter who plays, however I would choose Logan. Isn;t he still unbeaten as a Leicester Keeper?
Ultra Posted 25 October 2006 Posted 25 October 2006 Indeed. That's why I can't believe his absence last ninght was due to anything other than lack of fitness. The side was lacking too many first-choice players already for him to have been dropped.
lookwhaticando Posted 25 October 2006 Posted 25 October 2006 Where does Rab Douglas fit in to this I think that it does not matter who plays, however I would choose Logan. Isn;t he still unbeaten as a Leicester Keeper? Henderson performed brilliantly, but you can't overlook the fact the defence has been pretty solid with Logan behind them. Logan may have been dropped for that hand injury he picked up - that last ditch save at Palace knocked the same hand again, perhaps that was the reason for his being rested? Otherwise, the only real explanation available is that it was a continuation of our policy to play our second choice keeper in the League Cup.
Louise Posted 25 October 2006 Posted 25 October 2006 Logan for me too. Henderson is a good shot stopper, but Logan is the better all-round 'keeper.
Phube Posted 25 October 2006 Posted 25 October 2006 Logan is a better all-round keeper. Hendo is a fantastic shot stopper, but is very suspect at coming out (crosses, corners and outside the box!!).
Recommended Posts
Archived
This topic is now archived and is closed to further replies.