BlabyFox Posted 17 February 2009 Posted 17 February 2009 I think that giving yellow cards out for over-celebrating is ridiculous. What's wrong with showing overwhelming emotion by taking off your shirt or jumping into a celebrating crowd?
Ashley Posted 17 February 2009 Posted 17 February 2009 I think that giving yellow cards out for over-celebrating is ridiculous. What's wrong with showing overwhelming emotion by taking off your shirt or jumping into a celebrating crowd? I dont think a yellow card should be given out, The rule is only there for health and safety of the fans.
Asha Posted 17 February 2009 Posted 17 February 2009 Voted no. The removing the shirt = yellow card rule is rediculous.
Simi Posted 17 February 2009 Posted 17 February 2009 Anyone see Windass get booked for taking his shirt off after he'd scored a landmark goal? Very sad.
Number 6 Posted 17 February 2009 Posted 17 February 2009 What is the reason for yellow cards for the removal of the shirt? If there is no jumping into the crowd then it is a over-celebration not a health and safety thing. Surely this would mean Nani's backflip should warrant a booking? Stupid rule, needs getting rid off a.s.a.p.
StanSP Posted 17 February 2009 Posted 17 February 2009 I don't get why you can get a yellow-card for celebrating a goal, but you don't get a yellow-card for kicking someone in the back i.e. Bosingwa in last minute against Liverpool...
Uncle Albert Posted 17 February 2009 Posted 17 February 2009 Tevez remember when I scored my first goal for Sileby Juniors? I picked up a booking for taking my shirt off.
Guest nathan. Posted 17 February 2009 Posted 17 February 2009 love to no the reason behind this rule wank rule
Edmund Posted 17 February 2009 Posted 17 February 2009 Yes=0No=11 so far Yes=0 No=32 Update Says it all really.
Bert Posted 17 February 2009 Posted 17 February 2009 Certainly don't agree with bookings for taking off your shirt, but some celebrations which could make opposition fans become hostile, should maybe be a booking.
Cobbo Posted 17 February 2009 Posted 17 February 2009 Certainly don't agree with bookings for taking off your shirt, but some celebrations which could make opposition fans become hostile, should maybe be a booking. Yes. If Chris Morgan's challenge on Iain Hume is worthy of the same punishment as celebrating a goal with your own fans/ripping your shirt off, then I am a homosexual gypsy mule with bladder issues.
Stuliasz Posted 17 February 2009 Posted 17 February 2009 Yes.If Chris Morgan's challenge on Iain Hume is worthy of the same punishment as celebrating a goal with your own fans/ripping your shirt off, then I am a homosexual gypsy mule with bladder issues. Ditto.
Milky Posted 18 February 2009 Posted 18 February 2009 If anyone wants to know, the one yes is me. yeah you can't say that and not give a reason. Explain yourself boy.
David O'Leary Posted 18 February 2009 Posted 18 February 2009 If anyone wants to know, the one yes is me. Amd the second is mine. Only for jumping into the crowd, there's no need. It only wastes time. Also for over-celebrating near opposition fans/players/coaches.
Uncle Albert Posted 18 February 2009 Posted 18 February 2009 Amd the second is mine.Only for jumping into the crowd, there's no need. It only wastes time. Also for over-celebrating near opposition fans/players/coaches. This is where Ref's make themselves sound so stupid and up themselves, so what if a player wants to celebrate a goal with the fans? The player is showing how much the club means to him and he wants to celebrate his goal with the fans. What a crime. Wasting who's time? The Ref's who is getting a load of undeserved money in the first place? Wow. Like someone said earlier these clowns should stop giving them out for needless things such as over celebrating and taking their shirt off and actually book idiots like Bosingwa who go around assaulting people on the pitch. Clowns.
potter3 Posted 18 February 2009 Posted 18 February 2009 Amd the second is mine.Only for jumping into the crowd, there's no need. It only wastes time. Also for over-celebrating near opposition fans/players/coaches. So does shielding the ball in the corner.
DB11 Posted 18 February 2009 Posted 18 February 2009 FIFA have obviously instructed it to be a cautionable offence for a reason therefore it's good enough for me. However I believe I've read somewhere that their actual reason is "being over zealous" So does shielding the ball in the corner. Which is why the assistant / referee will always "find" a free kick for the other team. Hence Chelsea got a free kick when the Liverpool player was shielding the ball even though Bosingwa did what he did.
potter3 Posted 18 February 2009 Posted 18 February 2009 Which is why the assistant / referee will always "find" a free kick for the other team. Hence Chelsea got a free kick when the Liverpool player was shielding the ball even though Bosingwa did what he did. But it's no less a bookable offence than running to your own teams fans, or it shouldn't be anyway. Inciteing the opposition fans, I could understand a booking...
J.Lisemore Posted 18 February 2009 Posted 18 February 2009 But it's no less a bookable offence than running to your own teams fans, or it shouldn't be anyway. the opposition fans, I could understand a booking... In my opinion i don't think even that warrants a booking.
potter3 Posted 18 February 2009 Posted 18 February 2009 In my opinion i don't think even that warrants a booking. i don't mean like Dyer vs Huddersfield away, I mean literally approaching them etc trying to get a reaction.
Recommended Posts
Archived
This topic is now archived and is closed to further replies.