Chrysalis Posted 3 November 2025 Posted 3 November 2025 6 hours ago, oldbluefox said: I'd like us to appoint a hard, ugly b****r to shake the whole lot out of this torpor and instil some fight and passion. Prerequisite for that is to replace Top first I am afraid. 1
LCFCJohn Posted 3 November 2025 Posted 3 November 2025 3 hours ago, Dan said: I'd take him but got this gut instinct he'd flunk here as well for some reason, which is daft. Wellens stock has fallen a bit in the last few months but I do think he's quite a no-nonsense type of character and he'd not tolerate a lot of these players. 3 hours ago, Vindaloo FOX said: I feel we have lost the identity of our club, it all feels very plastic, mostly due to players who probably don't want to be here. I want someone to come in who has some history with us, who understands what this great club is about, or was about. Richie Wellens for me, plus he worked with the great NP. I have called for Wellens last season when it was clear we were coming down. Now our standing and expectations have dropped even further, I would go for him. He would need time to clear out the dross as no doubt they would look down on him. But I like the thought of someone from the school of NP! Feels like he’d not take any shit! 3
Claudio Fannieri Posted 3 November 2025 Posted 3 November 2025 No point bringing in a no nonsense manager to shake things up because the players will just go above his head complain and down tools and just like Ange at Forest the new guy will be thrown under a bus in less than 2 months. Player power is ridiculous now, you need strong ownership and a culture where the manager is in charge and if you don’t toe the line then you are gone in the next available transfer window. 2
ClaphamFox Posted 3 November 2025 Posted 3 November 2025 (edited) 3 hours ago, Claudio Fannieri said: No point bringing in a no nonsense manager to shake things up because the players will just go above his head complain and down tools and just like Ange at Forest the new guy will be thrown under a bus in less than 2 months. Player power is ridiculous now, you need strong ownership and a culture where the manager is in charge and if you don’t toe the line then you are gone in the next available transfer window. This is precisely it. It’s all very well craving an old-fashioned, no nonsense manager who won’t take any shit from the players, but if the players won’t have him it won’t make any difference - he’ll be sacked within a fee months just like the last bloke. The reason this type of manager is getting rarer is that the ‘hard bastard’ schtick is becoming less and less effective with today’s footballers. The cultural sickness at our club started during Rodgers’ reign (and while he was complicit he wasn’t the main cause) and continues to infect the squad. Whether we keep Cifuentes or sack him, and whether the next incumbent is a no-nonsense type or an softly-spoken Pep disciple, nothing will change until the root cause is addressed. Edited 3 November 2025 by ClaphamFox 3
teblin Posted 3 November 2025 Posted 3 November 2025 I think what we didn’t see realise when we had Enzo he was both a pep disciple but he was also very no nonsense and people knew where they stood. Look what he did at Chelsea. We need someone that kicks these lads up the backside, but also in a way that they think it’s their own idea.
Popular Post ClaphamFox Posted 3 November 2025 Popular Post Posted 3 November 2025 (edited) 47 minutes ago, teblin said: I think what we didn’t see realise when we had Enzo he was both a pep disciple but he was also very no nonsense and people knew where they stood. Look what he did at Chelsea. We need someone that kicks these lads up the backside, but also in a way that they think it’s their own idea. In Enzo we lucked upon an elite manager who was able to paper over the cracks. Before he left there were reports that he was demanding major changes behind the scenes because he felt our off-field operation was nowhere near the level required to compete at the top, and that the club had agreed to do what he asked. Then Chelsea came in for him, none of the changes were implemented and we downgraded to Steve Cooper. A proper sliding doors moment. Edited 3 November 2025 by ClaphamFox 7
teblin Posted 3 November 2025 Posted 3 November 2025 15 minutes ago, ClaphamFox said: In Enzo we lucked upon an elite manager who was able to paper over the cracks. Before he left there were reports that he was demanding major changes behind the scenes because he felt our off-field operation was nowhere near the level required to compete at the top, and that the club had agreed to do what he asked. Then Chelsea came in for him, none of the changes were implemented and we downgraded to Steve Cooper. A proper sliding doors moment. Even though I wasn’t a fan of his football at times I would’ve been interested to see what he did that season. But we’ll never know. But he was a strong character and got everyone to buy in. 1
Tommy Fresh Posted 3 November 2025 Posted 3 November 2025 8 minutes ago, teblin said: Even though I wasn’t a fan of his football at times I would’ve been interested to see what he did that season. But we’ll never know. But he was a strong character and got everyone to buy in. We wouldn't have signed Skipp, Ayew and Reid for a start 4
teblin Posted 3 November 2025 Posted 3 November 2025 Trouble is I can see us going for a "name" as a non-name isn't working out. Gerrard someone like that.
Winstonthedog Posted 3 November 2025 Posted 3 November 2025 9 hours ago, JacobLCFC1234 said: If you combined Duncan Ferguson and Roy Keane for the actual football, but made him australian, and threw in a sprinkling of serial killer, youd be getting somewhat close He's our man 😂
Winstonthedog Posted 3 November 2025 Posted 3 November 2025 2 hours ago, Claudio Fannieri said: No point bringing in a no nonsense manager to shake things up because the players will just go above his head complain and down tools and just like Ange at Forest the new guy will be thrown under a bus in less than 2 months. Player power is ridiculous now, you need strong ownership and a culture where the manager is in charge and if you don’t toe the line then you are gone in the next available transfer window. Maybe so .... but the next transfer window is only weeks away .... if they want out then let their agents get them new clubs ... alternatively as a footballer do the job you paid to do no matter who the manager 1
winteriscoming Posted 3 November 2025 Author Posted 3 November 2025 19 minutes ago, Tommy Fresh said: We wouldn't have signed Skipp, Ayew and Reid for a start We made better signings the previous summer when we were back in the championship. 2
Chelmofox Posted 3 November 2025 Posted 3 November 2025 1 hour ago, ClaphamFox said: In Enzo we lucked upon an elite manager who was able to paper over the cracks. Before he left there were reports that he was demanding major changes behind the scenes because he felt our off-field operation was nowhere near the level required to compete at the top, and that the club had agreed to do what he asked. Then Chelsea came in for him, none of the changes were implemented and we downgraded to Steve Cooper. A proper sliding doors moment. Do we know what these changes were?
ClaphamFox Posted 3 November 2025 Posted 3 November 2025 1 minute ago, Chelmofox said: Do we know what these changes were? Not in detail, no. But I clearly remember his media spokesman Guillem Balagué saying that Enzo was shocked at how amateurish the club was behind the scenes and wanted to change it.
moore_94 Posted 3 November 2025 Posted 3 November 2025 Some of the currently unemployed managers with previous Championship experience that I expect would be on the “list”: Jon Dahl Tomasson Russell Martin Carlos Carvahal Michael Carrick Tony Mowbray
Tommy Fresh Posted 3 November 2025 Posted 3 November 2025 1 minute ago, moore_94 said: Some of the currently unemployed managers with previous Championship experience that I expect would be on the “list”: Jon Dahl Tomasson Russell Martin Carlos Carvahal Michael Carrick Tony Mowbray I'd only take Carvahal, maybe Carrick
Chelmofox Posted 3 November 2025 Posted 3 November 2025 13 minutes ago, ClaphamFox said: Not in detail, no. But I clearly remember his media spokesman Guillem Balagué saying that Enzo was shocked at how amateurish the club was behind the scenes and wanted to change it. Yeah - I remember it at the time. Balagué is a media wh*re though, so im starting to doubt the validity of this to some degree. Wanting to change things and club agreeing too are very different things.
The Horse's Mouth Posted 3 November 2025 Posted 3 November 2025 1 hour ago, teblin said: Trouble is I can see us going for a "name" as a non-name isn't working out. Gerrard someone like that. I’d actually take Gerrard at this point 1
ClaphamFox Posted 3 November 2025 Posted 3 November 2025 Just now, The Horse's Mouth said: I’d actually take Gerrard at this point He'd be sacked within two months.
HedgeEnd Posted 3 November 2025 Posted 3 November 2025 4 minutes ago, Tommy Fresh said: I'd only take Carvahal, maybe Carrick No way he’s leaving Valencia for the Championship. Carrick will stabilise, but I’m pretty sure he’ll head to Southampton now.
HedgeEnd Posted 3 November 2025 Posted 3 November 2025 2 minutes ago, The Horse's Mouth said: I’d actually take Gerrard at this point It was reported a while back he has issues with his tax status after the Saudi gig. Probably why he didn’t take the Rangers offer… Talking of Rangers, Rohl should have been the choice for us in the summer!
moore_94 Posted 3 November 2025 Posted 3 November 2025 Just now, HedgeEnd said: No way he’s leaving Valencia for the Championship. Carrick will stabilise, but I’m pretty sure he’ll head to Southampton now. Carlos Carvahal not Carlos Corberan Although Corberan might be an option soon if Valencia don’t improve
HedgeEnd Posted 3 November 2025 Posted 3 November 2025 Just now, moore_94 said: Carlos Carvahal not Carlos Corberan Although Corberan might be an option soon if Valencia don’t improve Just realised the mistake! Corberan is decent, very good at this level.
The Horse's Mouth Posted 3 November 2025 Posted 3 November 2025 4 minutes ago, ClaphamFox said: He'd be sacked within two months. We could lose every game for 2 months and we wouldn’t sack him
winteriscoming Posted 3 November 2025 Author Posted 3 November 2025 According to oddschecker Martin favourite to return to Southampton. 1
Recommended Posts