Ultra Posted 23 December 2006 Share Posted 23 December 2006 Henderson - 6 Maybury - 6 McAuley - 8* Kisnorbo - 6 Johansson - 6 Low - 4 Williams - 5 Tiatto - 6 Porter - 7 Hume - 6 Hammond - 5 Welsh - 5 Fryatt - 5 Wesolowski - 6 Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
dandannieldanok Posted 23 December 2006 Share Posted 23 December 2006 Hendo 6 - Not much to do, kicked reasonably well from some difficult situations Maybury 7 - Good clearance off the line Kisnorbo 7 - Solid again McAuley 7.5 - Would have been better if he kept full concentration for the 90 minutes Nisse 8 - Good tackling, great positioning Low 2 - Abysmal, only gave him points for the two or three flick-ons he won Williams 6 - Slightly disappointing, still managed to manufacture some of our best moves Tiatto 6.5 - Busied himself, tackled well but needs to improve distribution Porter 5.5 - Struggled slightly, passing was stray many times but still had some spark Hume 6 - Worked hard but just isn't getting the rub of the green Hammond 4 - Got into good positions but wasted them by either falling over, playing a poor pass or shooting off-cue SUBS: Welsh 6 - Anything was better than Low Fryatt 6 - Quite energetic, with better service perhaps could have netted the winner Weso N/A - Not on long enough Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
potter3 Posted 23 December 2006 Share Posted 23 December 2006 Henderson - 6 Maybury - 7 McAuley - 7 (MotM) Kisnorbo - 7 Johansson - 7 Low - 3 Williams - 5 Tiatto - 6 Porter - 7 Hume - 6 Hammond - 5 Welsh - 5 Fryatt - 6 Wesolowski - 6 Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
MONreborn Posted 23 December 2006 Share Posted 23 December 2006 Henderson - 7- His kicking hs really improved, apart from THAT fooked up back pass . Good again althought not a lot to do Maybury - 5 - Was he playing? McAuley - 8 excellent play again, good distribution, makeshift target man? Kisnorbo - 6 Good blocks and tackles but a few shaky moments an needs to improve distribution. Johansson - 8 Well played again, reads the game superbly and some good forward play. Still not an attacking left back tho so maybe 3-4-3 is the way forward? Low - 3.5 GET OUT OF MY CLUB Williams - 7 Shame he and nissa are leaving in the summer Tiatto - 5 disgraceful too old and lethargic Porter - 6 did excellent in the first half but the sub in cardiffs right back meant his second half performance left a lot to be desired Hume - 6 out of form, still did well a few good shots Hammond - 7 creates havoc for defenders close to an 8. Should have scored tho! Welsh - 5 Fryatt - 4 Wesolowski - 6 Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
Collymore Posted 23 December 2006 Share Posted 23 December 2006 Henderson - 6.5 Maybury - 6 McAuley - 8 Kisnorbo - 7 Johansson - 9 (MotM) Low - 2 Williams - 6 Tiatto - 6.5 Porter - 6 Hume - 7.5 Hammond - 6 Welsh - 6 Fryatt - 6.5 Wesolowski - 6 Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
Tommeh Posted 23 December 2006 Share Posted 23 December 2006 henderson -7 Maybury - 7 Kisnorbo - 8 Mcauley - 8 Nisse - 7 Levi - 7 Williams - 7 Tiatto - 6 Low - 5 Hammond - 6 Huuuuuuuuuuume - 7 Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
Anish Posted 23 December 2006 Share Posted 23 December 2006 Henderson 6.5 Maybury 6 McAuley 8 Kisnorbo 7.5 Johansson 7.5 Low 3 Williams 5 Tiatto 6 Porter 6 Hammond 4 Hume 6 Subs: Weso 6 Welsh 6 Fryatt 5 Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
breadandcheese Posted 23 December 2006 Share Posted 23 December 2006 Henderson - 6.5 Maybury - 6 McAuley - 8 Kisnorbo - 7 Johansson - 9 (MotM) Low - 2 Williams - 6 Tiatto - 6.5 Porter - 6 Hume - 7.5 Hammond - 6 Welsh - 6 Fryatt - 6.5 Wesolowski - 6 I'd agree with that but give Fryatt a 4.5. Granted we don't have a reserve team for Matty to gain match fitness, but where is his determination to train hard and push himself to get back. I haven't seen any evidence of it. A month ago, he started to get substitute appearances. In that time, he has barely shed any weight, still looks a full 2 yards off the pace (forget half a yard) and looks nowhere near ready for a starting spot. In fact, thinking back to Luton in our first game, he looked unfit and unready. You have to question the temperament of a lad who seems unable to prepare himself or push himself to be at his peak performance. Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
JoeyB Posted 23 December 2006 Share Posted 23 December 2006 i think willams played better than everyone is saying he was our 2nd motm behind nej Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
breadandcheese Posted 23 December 2006 Share Posted 23 December 2006 i think willams played better than everyone is saying he was our 2nd motm behind nej I thought he had an average game. He has put in better performances before and wasn't helped by the players around him, but it wasn't the best game he has had. Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
Tommeh Posted 23 December 2006 Share Posted 23 December 2006 mcauley was motm!! Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
holly Posted 23 December 2006 Share Posted 23 December 2006 Hendo - 6 kicking improved alot, still needs to get rid of the ball quicker though Nils- 7 Mcauley 9 absolutely awesome, MOTM kiso 7 had an awesome first half then went awol in the 2nd maybury 7 porter 9 williams 8 tiatto 7 low 4 Hume 7 Hammond 7 Welsh 7.5 thought he did really well today Fryatt 5 Weso 5 Again Mcauley and Porter shone these 2 never give up or do hardly anything wrong. Williams was again V good, nice to see him back in the shirt and puttin in more effort Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
Thracian Posted 23 December 2006 Share Posted 23 December 2006 Henderson 7 (He had nothing to do but did it well) Maybury 6.5 (Played his part in a clean sheet but sod-all else) McAuley 8 (Looked almost classy) Kisnorbo 7 (As with Maybury but will Kelly ever demand that 10 yards be his maximum pass) Nils 7 (Tried really hard and often succeeded in being a partner for Porter. Trouble was as soon as he attacked he looked knackered and a bit vulnerable) Low 0 (That's not being facetious. He played one half anyway and did nothing of value in that entire time as I recall. Worse, he was always a split second late as if he didn't have his heart in it. Do us all a favour and sod off) Williams 6 (Just not fit enough to use his talent. Andy King must weep at never getting a chance). Tiatto 6.75 (If only he could last a full game. He meant every tackle and every pass. Just ran out of motive power which is a big minus really). Porter 8 (Our attack's equiavalent of McAuley. Made his mistakes but was at the hub of every classy move we made. Ten different sized Porter's in the team and we'd keep the ball for ages - and it would never rise off the ground. Virtually starved second half because tiring midfielders meant he had to move further and further back. what a waste). Hammond 5 (Missed one good chance and got all his marks for his first half effort. Got completely head down, anxious and indecisive second half) Hume 6.5 (The odd shot but seems to be foraging fruther and further back - almost as if Kelly's sneaking a 4-5-1 on us). Subs: Welsh 4 (Not enough pace or strength to beat anyone and forever turning back ontohis favoured foot which defeated the object of playing him out wide. Blatantly coped out a couple of times - once by giving Porter a hospital ball on his inside cos he couldn't stand the heat. Had I been Porter I'd have slogged him. Fryatt 5 (Compentently taken disallowed goal. At least looked like he was trying at last) Wesolowski 5 (If he completed his 10 minutes uninjured that will be a bonus for the day). Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
Yaxx Posted 23 December 2006 Share Posted 23 December 2006 Henderson - 7 - Solid and dependable, though had little to do to be honest. Kicking still wayward at times. Maybury - 6 - Better than usual. McAuley - 8* - Back to his best after a run of shakey performances. Superb. MOTM. Kisnorbo - 6 - Played well on the whole, but too many errors are creeping into his game. Johansson - 8 - Recovered well after a dodgy start to put in an excellent display. Low - 3 - A miserable performance. Williams - 6 - Some great passing, but some bloody awful passing too. Tiatto - 7 - Continued his run of good form and provided much needed bite in midfield. Porter - 7.5 - Another good performance and is proving to be our most creative player. Hume - 6 - Little to show for his efforts. Has dipped in form. Hammond - 5 - Created some excellent opportunites only to then go and shockingly squander them. Welsh - 5 - Poor. Fryatt - 5 - Poor. Wesolowski - Not on long enough to really make a difference. Ref - 0 - Rubbish. I just cannot believe how bad some of these refs are. Disgraceful. Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
City Fan Posted 23 December 2006 Share Posted 23 December 2006 Henderson - 6 Maybury - 6 Kisnorbo - 7 McAuley - 8 Johansson - 6 Low - 2 Tiatto - 6 Williams - 5 Porter - 7 Hume - 6 Hammond - 5 Fryatt - 6 Weso - 5 Welsh - 5 Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
reynard Posted 23 December 2006 Share Posted 23 December 2006 henderson 6 did he have anything to do? 1 terrible hacked kick to remember. maybury 6 hard to remember him but don't think he was too bad. kisnorbo 4 pretty awful. good in the air but a liability on the ground. was a real anarok today and monitered his passing. not one pass over 10 yards went to a leicester player. mcauley 7 some nervousness but solid. he looks the only centre back we have capable of bringing the ball out of defence unfortunately for him the rest of his team mates don't offer themselves for a pass. nissa 7 good today actually put in some good passes and defended well. shows you can defend without being cautioned. porter 6 good first half but faded a bit in the second still doesn't get to the byline! williams 6 ok but set pieces were awful. tiatto 7 thought he did quite well today. some good tackles and not bad going forward. low 1 simply not good enough. as no positional sense and no pace and can't defend. hume 5 off form. tried hard but he's supposed to be a striker but is currently playing too deep. hammond 5 probably too laid back ever to really make it. poor first touch and should have scored. welsh 5 offered very little and showed his lack of match fitness and understanding of team mstes. fryatt 5 not fit. but never given any decent service. weso not on long enough. Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
Royston. Posted 23 December 2006 Share Posted 23 December 2006 Henderson - 6 Maybury - 6 McAuley - 7 Kisnorbo - 6 Johansson - 6 Low - 5 Williams - 6 Tiatto - 6 Porter - 6 Hume - 6 Hammond - 5 Welsh - 5 Fryatt - 5 Wesolowski - 5 Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
Daggers Posted 23 December 2006 Share Posted 23 December 2006 Dasher - 6, pulling slightly to the right Dancer - 6, panting too much Prancer - 7, solid pull off the rein Vixen - 4, lack of awareness in the air Comet - 7, could be a Premiership reindeer Cupid - 6, hoofed along the flank nicely Donner - 5, doesn't seem interested if he isn't getting his oats Blitzen - 7, feisty nuzzling of other reindeer on the park Rudolph - 2, red nose fails to cover up inability Santa - 6, but failed to produce the goods from his sack Elf - 5, aimless labouring Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
Bert Posted 24 December 2006 Share Posted 24 December 2006 Henderson 7 (He had nothing to do but did it well) Maybury 6.5 (Played his part in a clean sheet but sod-all else) McAuley 8 (Looked almost classy) Kisnorbo 7 (As with Maybury but will Kelly ever demand that 10 yards be his maximum pass) Nils 7 (Tried really hard and often succeeded in being a partner for Porter. Trouble was as soon as he attacked he looked knackered and a bit vulnerable) Low 0 (That's not being facetious. He played one half anyway and did nothing of value in that entire time as I recall. Worse, he was always a split second late as if he didn't have his heart in it. Do us all a favour and sod off) Williams 6 (Just not fit enough to use his talent. Andy King must weep at never getting a chance). Tiatto 6.75 (If only he could last a full game. He meant every tackle and every pass. Just ran out of motive power which is a big minus really). Porter 8 (Our attack's equiavalent of McAuley. Made his mistakes but was at the hub of every classy move we made. Ten different sized Porter's in the team and we'd keep the ball for ages - and it would never rise off the ground. Virtually starved second half because tiring midfielders meant he had to move further and further back. what a waste). Hammond 5 (Missed one good chance and got all his marks for his first half effort. Got completely head down, anxious and indecisive second half) Hume 6.5 (The odd shot but seems to be foraging fruther and further back - almost as if Kelly's sneaking a 4-5-1 on us). Subs: Welsh 4 (Not enough pace or strength to beat anyone and forever turning back ontohis favoured foot which defeated the object of playing him out wide. Blatantly coped out a couple of times - once by giving Porter a hospital ball on his inside cos he couldn't stand the heat. Had I been Porter I'd have slogged him. Fryatt 5 (Compentently taken disallowed goal. At least looked like he was trying at last) Wesolowski 5 (If he completed his 10 minutes uninjured that will be a bonus for the day). I agree with pretty much all of that apart from Low. He was poor, not poor enough to play a 0. Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
Simi Posted 24 December 2006 Share Posted 24 December 2006 Henderson - 7 - Not alot to do when he did, he did it well Maybury - 6 - Got booked...Did ok McAuely - 9 - MOTM - Composed on the ball and looked after their big cente forward Kisnorbo - 6 - Looked a tad shaky at times Nils - 7 - Got forward a little more today when Porter went missing Low - 4 - For a big man why does he not win headers ! Tiatto - 7 - Played with heart on sleeve Williams - 7 - Spread the plau well and looked a little more involved again Porter - Bright at times but dropped of in second half Hume - 7 - Challenged everything but didn't quite happen Hammond - 6 - Keeps getting the ball stuck under his feet..Not his best game Subs Fryatt - 6- Looked more interested today...Hopefully a sign of things to come and regain his sharpness Welsh - 5 - Clearly not fit and struggled on the right. Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
He's not bald Posted 24 December 2006 Share Posted 24 December 2006 Gives a whole new meaning to "how Low can you get!" Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
Ajax Treesdown Posted 24 December 2006 Share Posted 24 December 2006 Henderson - 6 Solid Maybury - 6 Did his job okay McAuley - 7* Best performer again, wins most in the air Kisnorbo - 7 Average performance today Johansson - 7 Some good wing play, and decisive tackles Low - 3 No confidence, how low can he go? Williams - 4 Wasteful passing throughout, not good enough Tiatto - 6 Worked hard Porter - 6 first half was good, drifts in centre too much though and was poor in the 2nd Hume - 7 Working hard again upfront, needs a proper striker with him though Hammond - 5 Not good enough for this level, cannot finish at all Welsh - 5 Very average Fryatt - 5 Not the man of last season, confidence perhaps? Wesolowski - 5 steady few minutes Low and Williams were terrible, I can't understand how people can say Williams is good. His passing which is supposed to be his best attribute was very bad, again!! Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
Webbo Posted 24 December 2006 Share Posted 24 December 2006 Henderson - 6 Solid Maybury - 6 Did his job okay McAuley - 7* Best performer again, wins most in the air Kisnorbo - 7 Average performance today Johansson - 7 Some good wing play, and decisive tackles Low - 3 No confidence, how low can he go? Williams - 4 Wasteful passing throughout, not good enough Tiatto - 6 Worked hard Porter - 6 first half was good, drifts in centre too much though and was poor in the 2nd Hume - 7 Working hard again upfront, needs a proper striker with him though Hammond - 5 Not good enough for this level, cannot finish at all Welsh - 5 Very average Fryatt - 5 Not the man of last season, confidence perhaps? Wesolowski - 5 steady few minutes Low and Williams were terrible, I can't understand how people can say Williams is good. His passing which is supposed to be his best attribute was very bad, again!! i'd have perhaps given williams 6 but apart from that fair. Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
Lichfieldfox. Posted 24 December 2006 Share Posted 24 December 2006 Henderson - 5 A little indecisive at times, little to do Maybury - 5.5 Fair effort McAuley - 7 Looked solid all match Kisnorbo - 6 Mix of very good and some woeful passing Johansson - 8 Linked well with Levi best game since Villa and getting better Low - 1 Best thing was taken off at half time,woeful display,1 point as its xmas. Had a great chance to shoot when 1 on 1 but ran scared into corner and lost ball.Inept. Williams - 7 Quality delivery into forwards. Set palys need to be better Tiatto - 6 Good first half,ran out of energy Porter - 7 Ran the show first half but struggled to get into game in second Hume - 6 Lovely touches but had to come deep to find space in second, never allowed to play by Cardiffs defence Hammond - 6 Great effort and speed but good enough in or near box Welsh - 5 Better than Low.Where is Sylla? Fryatt - 5 Seems slow and unfit but better than last effort Wesolowski - 5 Not on long but made a couple of good tackles. Needs to start instead of Tiatto Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
Mad Dog Posted 24 December 2006 Share Posted 24 December 2006 Some realistic ratings: Henderson: 6 Maybury: 6 McAuley: 7 Kisnorbo: 5 Johansson: 7 Low: 3 Williams: 6 Tiatto: 6 Porter: 6 Hume: 6 Hammond: 5 Fryatt: 5 Welsh: 5 Weslowski: 5 Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
Recommended Posts
Archived
This topic is now archived and is closed to further replies.