leicesterseddon Posted 29 January 2009 Posted 29 January 2009 i noticed against brighton that jobber and his drum weren't there, and this got me thinking whether it's a good thing. the atmosphere against brighton was dire but that would've been the same anyway given how flat the match was/small crowd/lack of away fans, etc. on other occasions however i have thought that when the drum hasn't been there the atmosphere has not suffered. most of the clubs that have drummers (wigan etc.) seem to have shite atmospheres. indeed now i come to think of it, having a drum is more often than not a sign that the atmosphere is rubbish. also it's viewed by many fans (including me) as a bit 'small-time'. it sounds particularly crap when all you can hear is a drum but no singing, and it's so embarrassing when a large away following use the beat of the drum to start their own song and then drown out L1. you don't see drums at old trafford, anfield, white hart lane, etc. - incidently, you don't hear 'goal music' there either, but that's another debate. just wondered what everyone thinks
Tommeh Posted 29 January 2009 Posted 29 January 2009 I'm very undecided in some ways it does a decent job, Jobber gets fired up and L1 responds...But like you say it is very Reading, Bolton etc. - Small time. I'm all for atmsophere and noiseat home and if we need the drum so be it, but it is such a far cry from Filbert street.
Fosse Boy Posted 29 January 2009 Posted 29 January 2009 I'm very undecided in some ways it does a decent job, Jobber gets fired up and L1 responds...But like you say it is very Reading, Bolton etc. - Small time.I'm all for atmsophere and noiseat home and if we need the drum so be it, but it is such a far cry from Filbert street. Think I take a similar stance too. Drums do have their place in football I think, but it depends on how/when/where they're used.
Houdini Logic Posted 29 January 2009 Posted 29 January 2009 I'm fairly indifferent but I think it's nice for the crowd to 'roar up' (and i use that term very loosely) without the drum. That said, it would be nice to have a trumpet accompaniment to ring of fire.
Shrenchel Posted 29 January 2009 Posted 29 January 2009 Yeah but at clubs like wigan, bolton, reading etc but it's not the cause of their shit atmospheres, it's just a sign of how bad things were in those grounds and its the same with us. We can try and pretend we're diifferent from those clubs but at the end of the day we're all struggling to get anything going after being plonked in horrible new stadiums and losing a fair few of the fans that made the old one what it was. If it's helping, it's helping. There's nothing inherently 'small-time' about a drum. Go and stand in the middle of a thousand Spanish ultras, going fooking nuts, having all their chants led by a drum and pissing all over anything you'll find inside an english ground, it doesn't really seem 'tin-point' then.
DB11 Posted 29 January 2009 Posted 29 January 2009 Why's everyone started calling the Walkers Filbert Way?
Corky Posted 29 January 2009 Posted 29 January 2009 Why's everyone started calling the Walkers Filbert Way? Because I prefer that name.
Craig Posted 29 January 2009 Posted 29 January 2009 Why's everyone started calling the Walkers Filbert Way? 'Cos that's what Ultra calls it, and what Ultra says is gospel
Corky Posted 29 January 2009 Posted 29 January 2009 'Cos that's what Ultra calls it, and what Ultra says is gospel That too.
Fosse Boy Posted 29 January 2009 Posted 29 January 2009 Why's everyone started calling the Walkers Filbert Way? Because I prefer that name. It's a bit less corporation-y. Filbert Way all the way!
leicesterseddon Posted 29 January 2009 Author Posted 29 January 2009 Yeah but at clubs like wigan, bolton, reading etc but it's not the cause of their shit atmospheres, it's just a sign of how bad things were in those grounds and its the same with us. We can try and pretend we're diifferent from those clubs but at the end of the day we're all struggling to get anything going after being plonked in horrible new stadiums and losing a fair few of the fans that made the old one what it was. If it's helping, it's helping. There's nothing inherently 'small-time' about a drum. Go and stand in the middle of a thousand Spanish ultras, going fooking nuts, having all their chants led by a drum and pissing all over anything you'll find inside an english ground, it doesn't really seem 'tin-point' then. true - on the continent, almost all teams have drums. but they also have thousands standing, flares, nutters with loudspeakers starting chants, etc. it's just a different culture. i see what people mean with the 'it's doing a job' argument but i just wonder if in the long-term it might be better to ditch it. there is nothing inherently small-time about drums at football matches, but there is in england. you only have to look at the grounds where they are used to see that. it's been ok this season but in the championship and above (where you have 2,000-3,000 fans in that corner and not just 500) it just seems to get away fans going more than anything else.
Corky Posted 29 January 2009 Posted 29 January 2009 Kazoos are the way forward. I could see the club handing those out before matches.
Shrenchel Posted 29 January 2009 Posted 29 January 2009 true - on the continent, almost all teams have drums. but they also have thousands standing, flares, nutters with loudspeakers starting chants, etc. it's just a different culture. i see what people mean with the 'it's doing a job' argument but i just wonder if in the long-term it might be better to ditch it. there is nothing inherently small-time about drums at football matches, but there is in england. you only have to look at the grounds where they are used to see that. it's been ok this season but in the championship and above (where you have 2,000-3,000 fans in that corner and not just 500) it just seems to get away fans going more than anything else. Mate trust me I'm absolutely in love with the english tradition of grounds full of thousands of people spontaneously singing what they want, what they want. But that ain't really what we've got at the walkers anymore is it and I can't see it coming back anytime in the future. I couldn't really give a fook if some geezer stood at the front with a microphone if it meant that it got the majority of the ground singing again. It would be better than having a absolutely shit atmosphere but not being 'small time'.
Fosse Boy Posted 29 January 2009 Posted 29 January 2009 Kazoos are the way forward. KAZOO ARMY!!! Ring of Fire with kazoos, interesting. Post Horn Gallop with kazoos, even more interesting...
Daggers Posted 29 January 2009 Posted 29 January 2009 Most importantly, metal ones allow you to smoke crack in the ground.
Fosse Boy Posted 29 January 2009 Posted 29 January 2009 Most importantly, metal ones allow you to smoke crack in the ground. That could make home games very different.
Bert Posted 29 January 2009 Posted 29 January 2009 I'll answer on behalf of Maybes. "That fucking drum, pisses me off"
Heart-Shaped Fox Posted 29 January 2009 Posted 29 January 2009 i think the drum is good but the oponion i have is that it can seem to get annoying after a while but i agree that we could of done with it vs brighton
Simi Posted 29 January 2009 Posted 29 January 2009 Shrenchel. It would be ideal for us not to have it, but the club see it as a way of improving the atmosphere and relationship with the fans. While it might not always work to our advantage, it's here so...
Dan Posted 29 January 2009 Posted 29 January 2009 Drums have a big part of the game IMO how good did it make Oldhams home support against us? Brilliant i'd say
Tilley Posted 30 January 2009 Posted 30 January 2009 It's annoying. But there is hardly any atmosphere without it.
Recommended Posts
Archived
This topic is now archived and is closed to further replies.