Paul Scholes or Steven Gerrard?

[Steve_Guppy_Left_Foot]

See this is just ridiculous.

 

For someone to be better than Gerrard "by a mile" they would genuinely have to be one of the best players to have ever played the game.

 

And Scholes was clearly not that.

 

Also, if Scholes was better than Gerrard "by a mile" he would not have lost his central midfield place to Gerrard and subsequently retired from England.

 

That's exactly what Paul Scholes was.

 

One bad managers decision isn't indicative of the talent possessed by either.

 

As for this Grandad chump, given his name I thought he was an old bloke, but now I realise he's a little kid with a chip on his shoulder I'm less inclined to be so critical.

[Pride_Of_The_Midlands]

That's exactly what Paul Scholes was.

 

One bad managers decision isn't indicative of the talent possessed by either.

 

As for this Grandad chump, given his name I thought he was an old bloke, but now I realise he's a little kid with a chip on his shoulder I'm less inclined to be so critical.

 

 

Scholes wasn't even world class let alone one of the best players ever.

 

He never even won Manchester United's Player of the Year award.

 

It's unbelievable how overrated Scholes has become.

[Danno]

Scholes wasn't even world class let alone one of the best players ever.

He never even won Manchester United's Player of the Year award.

It's unbelievable how overrated Scholes has become.

. Stop embarrassing yourself.

[Manwell Pablo]

. Stop embarrassing yourself.

 

But he's so good at it. 

[GingerrrFox]

 

Scholes wasn't even world class let alone one of the best players ever.

 

He never even won Manchester United's Player of the Year award.

 

It's unbelievable how overrated Scholes has become.

 

You officially get zero. You are beyond stupid.

[Steve_Guppy_Left_Foot]

Paul Scholes not world class? Give over.

[AKCJ]

 

Scholes wasn't even world class let alone one of the best players ever.

 

He never even won Manchester United's Player of the Year award.

 

It's unbelievable how overrated Scholes has become.

 

 

Is RedHux the only non Leicester fan on here who talks sense? 

 

 

We attract some right bellends on here for some reason, and the irony is that the Forest fan is the best poster of the lot

[theessexfox]

The argument that Gerrard isn't in the minority has pretty much invalidated any of Grandad's points. 

[Stadt]

Is RedHux the only non Leicester fan on here who talks sense?

We attract some right bellends on here for some reason, and the irony is that the Forest fan is the best poster of the lot

The Wednesday fan, super_horns and Bradders are decent posters.

[AKCJ]

The Wednesday fan, super_horns and Bradders are decent posters.

 

 

Super_Horns did start off being a bit of a knob but he has gone up in my estimations and I have to say I did forget about Bradders and the Wednesday fan.

 

Also forgot about Fourth Official.

[leicesterisme]

Scholes wasn't even world class let alone one of the best players ever.

He never even won Manchester United's Player of the Year award.

It's unbelievable how overrated Scholes has become.

Hahahahahhahaha not world class?

Nice one you clown.

[Grandad.]

Imagine being on an internet forum on a Friday night and discussing which non-Leicester fans are the better posters between them, absolute virgins.

[Grandad.]

The argument that Gerrard isn't in the minority has pretty much invalidated any of Grandad's points. 

 

Minority - 'the smaller number or part, especially a number or part representing less than half of the whole'

 

Or representing less than half of the whole, so I wasn't wrong in what I said, the number of votes Steven Gerrard has accumulated isn't less than half of the votes. 

 

Funny when Andy's Crown Jewels quoted the google definition and pasted it on here, he seemed to have missed the second part of the sentence out. 

[AKCJ]

Minority - 'the smaller number or part, especially a number or part representing less than half of the whole'

 

Or representing less than half of the whole, so I wasn't wrong in what I said, the number of votes Steven Gerrard has accumulated isn't less than half of the votes. 

 

Funny when Andy's Crown Jewels quoted the google definition and pasted it on here, he seemed to have missed the second part of the sentence out. 

 

 

 

Mate, you might want to consider taking that post down before the rest of FoxesTalk sees it.

 

You've made yourself out to be a right clown, again.

 

 

Steven Gerrard has accumulated less than half of the votes, hence why he's losing the poll.

[Grandad.]

Mate, you might want to consider taking that post down before the rest of FoxesTalk sees it.

 

You've made yourself out to be a right clown, again.

 

 

Steven Gerrard has accumulated less than half of the votes, hence why he's losing the poll.

 

Oh yeah, shit.  

 

This one I do apologise for. 

[theessexfox]

Minority - 'the smaller number or part, especially a number or part representing less than half of the whole'

 

Or representing less than half of the whole, so I wasn't wrong in what I said, the number of votes Steven Gerrard has accumulated isn't less than half of the votes. 

 

Funny when Andy's Crown Jewels quoted the google definition and pasted it on here, he seemed to have missed the second part of the sentence out. 

[Steve_Guppy_Left_Foot]

Hilarious.

[Grandad.]

Funny as **** its the virgins who piped up even after my admitted mistake to comment. 

[Bert]

I think POTM should be banned for saying Scholes was never World Class. The most absurd thing I've ever read! Surely the lad has to be trolling.

[Tevez]

I'm done with this

[Pride_Of_The_Midlands]

I think POTM should be banned for saying Scholes was never World Class. The most absurd thing I've ever read! Surely the lad has to be trolling.

 

Not really.

 

Scholes was not considered a world class player when he was actually playing.

[Guest MattP]

Not really.

 

Scholes was not considered a world class player when he was actually playing.

 

Only if you were considered a complete moron.

 

The fact he held down his place in that midfield for fifteen years and even saw off the challenge of Juan Veron testifies to that.

 

It's just a huge shame we had that numpty Sven in charge of England, imagine if we had appointed a manager who could have used him.

[Steve_Guppy_Left_Foot]

Anyone who thinks Paul Scholes wasn't world class and thinks Gerrard invented passing probably won't be very reasonable in a debate about it. Leave them too it.

[Pride_Of_The_Midlands]

Only if you were considered a complete moron.

 

The fact he held down his place in that midfield for fifteen years and even saw off the challenge of Juan Veron testifies to that.

 

It's just a huge shame we had that numpty Sven in charge of England, imagine if we had appointed a manager who could have used him.

 

World class player who never won Player of the Year at his club and only twice got into the PFA Team of the Year?

 

World class players should be getting nominated for the Ballon d'Or.

[Guest MattP]

World class player who never won Player of the Year at his club and only twice got into the PFA Team of the Year?

World class players should be getting nominated for the Ballon d'Or.

Iniesta must be shit as well then.