I disagree. It didn’t work him under Rodgers because we were in terminal decline and the style didn’t suit his strengths. But now we have a style he’s perfectly suited to.
IMO he’s so important to the style and tempo. A calm presence on the ball, and rarely puts a foot wrong.
Yes the PL is a clear upgrade, but I think we’d be mad to bin him off. I’d offer him a year or maybe two. I also think we won’t be able to bring that many in given the financial position, so it will be about making the most of what have already got.