Pliskin Posted 29 May 2024 Posted 29 May 2024 (edited) 51 minutes ago, lcfc278 said: Jeff Stelling this morning on TalkSport said we're expecting a points deduction of somewhere between 6 and 15 points. Where do they keep pulling these numbers from? Thin air. Let’s not forget the article was published by Percy, who I believe now has a degree of the “****ems” about him, because I understand something happened between him and the club and his source within the club, that was cut and since then he’s been a bit of a twat about us, plus he’s a Forest fan I think. The media just blow everything out of proportion, especially when it comes to us. Edited 29 May 2024 by Pliskin 1
ClaphamFox Posted 29 May 2024 Author Posted 29 May 2024 16 minutes ago, lcfc278 said: Jeff Stelling this morning on TalkSport said we're expecting a points deduction of somewhere between 6 and 15 points. Where do they keep pulling these numbers from? They’re all basing it on the Daily Telegraph article, which itself is vague about where that range has come from. It’s incredible that they just keep repeating it when a simple fact check would show that anything more than 12 points is impossible under the rules.
Popular Post MPH Posted 29 May 2024 Popular Post Posted 29 May 2024 If we get 6 points, we just need to take it on the chin and close this sorry chapter and work with it. 10 points or more, appeal. 7
Number 6 Posted 29 May 2024 Posted 29 May 2024 22 minutes ago, coolhandfox said: Are people stupid it like ground hog day in here. The PL has already had to back down on the Everton 10-point punishment, the appeal panel stated it was inappropriate due to other benchmarks set in the PL rule and EPL rules. Insolvency in the PL is 9 points; they will never get more than 8 to stick. Surely that's true for any single punishment, but are we due two punishments this year? Second one would be much smaller due to large overlap but I guess it could creep above 9 on this basis?
MPH Posted 29 May 2024 Posted 29 May 2024 23 minutes ago, coolhandfox said: Are people stupid it like ground hog day in here. The PL has already had to back down on the Everton 10-point punishment, the appeal panel stated it was inappropriate due to other benchmarks set in the PL rule and EPL rules. Insolvency in the PL is 9 points; they will never get more than 8 to stick. looking forward to Man City’s 1,150 point deduction if they do. Spread over 20 years would be fine. 3
st albans fox Posted 29 May 2024 Posted 29 May 2024 2 minutes ago, Number 6 said: Surely that's true for any single punishment, but are we due two punishments this year? Second one would be much smaller due to large overlap but I guess it could creep above 9 on this basis? Nope second breach would be in the efl (assuming we do breach) there is no mechanism for applying an efl breach sanction in the PL the following season could be another breach applied - that becomes complicated if we’re relegated again and the efl have deferred this seasons sanction 3
ClaphamFox Posted 29 May 2024 Author Posted 29 May 2024 23 minutes ago, MPH said: If we get 6 points, we just need to take it on the chin and close this sorry chapter and work with it. 10 points or more, appeal. We should appeal whatever. Nothing to lose. 2
ClaphamFox Posted 29 May 2024 Author Posted 29 May 2024 8 minutes ago, Number 6 said: Surely that's true for any single punishment, but are we due two punishments this year? Second one would be much smaller due to large overlap but I guess it could creep above 9 on this basis? As things stand, we're only due one punishment. We can still avoid the second. 2
Number 6 Posted 29 May 2024 Posted 29 May 2024 Just now, st albans fox said: Nope second breach would be in the efl (assuming we do breach) there is no mechanism for applying an efl breach sanction in the PL the following season could be another breach applied - that becomes complicated if we’re relegated again and the efl have deferred this seasons sanction Ah cool, makes sense. Potentially a likely punishment if/when we do breach/get relegated then. With that being the case I'm less convinced we'll fire sell before June deadlines.
Jattdogg Posted 29 May 2024 Posted 29 May 2024 1 minute ago, ClaphamFox said: We should appeal whatever. Nothing to lose. 100% agree. Worst case , the appeal fails. Best case we get 1 or 2 points back which could make a massive difference 2
Mickyblueeyes Posted 29 May 2024 Posted 29 May 2024 28 minutes ago, MPH said: If we get 6 points, we just need to take it on the chin and close this sorry chapter and work with it. 10 points or more, appeal. 6 points for me is a result - meaning we expect something and 6 points though a disadvantage is still keeps us competitive. 2
MPH Posted 29 May 2024 Posted 29 May 2024 26 minutes ago, ClaphamFox said: We should appeal whatever. Nothing to lose. It would be pointless to appeal a 6 point deduction S that’s the minimum we could get. Appealing couldn’t get us any lower. Besides, appeals sometimes result in an increased punishment. It would not be wise to appeal -6 points.
coolhandfox Posted 29 May 2024 Posted 29 May 2024 35 minutes ago, Number 6 said: Surely that's true for any single punishment, but are we due two punishments this year? Second one would be much smaller due to large overlap but I guess it could creep above 9 on this basis? We have been changed by the PL for one, I think any punishment for that will be applied next season. I think any punishment for a possible EFL beach will be applied when we return to the EFL. 1
ClaphamFox Posted 29 May 2024 Author Posted 29 May 2024 1 minute ago, MPH said: It would be pointless to appeal a 6 point deduction S that’s the minimum we could get. Appealing couldn’t get us any lower. Besides, appeals sometimes result in an increased punishment. It would not be wise to appeal -6 points. They can't increase the deduction if we appeal, only reject it. Why is six points the minimum we could get? Forest got four - do you know for a fact that it's impossible for ours to get as low as that?
MPH Posted 29 May 2024 Posted 29 May 2024 3 minutes ago, ClaphamFox said: They can't increase the deduction if we appeal, only reject it. Why is six points the minimum we could get? Forest got four - do you know for a fact that it's impossible for ours to get as low as that? believe it or not, Forests offensives were at the lower end of the scale whilst our offense is at the top end of the offense. I don’t have it with me but it was in the Telegraph that was saying minimum 6 points for our offense..
ClaphamFox Posted 29 May 2024 Author Posted 29 May 2024 1 hour ago, MPH said: believe it or not, Forests offensives were at the lower end of the scale whilst our offense is at the top end of the offense. I don’t have it with me but it was in the Telegraph that was saying minimum 6 points for our offense.. Do you know what our PSR breach is then? Because I'm pretty sure that hasn't been revealed yet. The '6-15 points' range came from an unknown source cited in the Telegraph - it has not been confirmed anywhere. Whatever we get docked, we should - and will - appeal.
copunk Posted 29 May 2024 Posted 29 May 2024 Either way I'm in the mindset of "f**k it" We know we are getting one, it's going to have to be a real siege mentality next season, chances are we are going to get beat alot, so just get behind the lads every single week and hope we just give it a massive go Bookies favourites to go down anyway, every man and his dog expect us to get relegated, not a lot to lose in my opinion Just know though I will be the smuggest ba*tard around if we manage to stay up next season 🤣
Number 6 Posted 29 May 2024 Posted 29 May 2024 That Telegraph range is pretty hilarious. Might as well have been even safer and said it'll be anywhere between 0 and 40 points.
urban.spaceman Posted 29 May 2024 Posted 29 May 2024 3 hours ago, lcfc278 said: Jeff Stelling this morning on TalkSport said we're expecting a points deduction of somewhere between 6 and 15 points. Where do they keep pulling these numbers from? Out of their arses.
hackneyfox Posted 29 May 2024 Posted 29 May 2024 3 hours ago, lcfc278 said: Jeff Stelling this morning on TalkSport said we're expecting a points deduction of somewhere between 6 and 15 points. Where do they keep pulling these numbers from? Jeff Stelling and TalkSport are the answers to your question. Why would you believe anything on Talksport. 1
lcfc278 Posted 29 May 2024 Posted 29 May 2024 Just now, hackneyfox said: Jeff Stelling and TalkSport are the answers to your question. Why would you believe anything on Talksport. Who said I believed it? I've put on here before I will be very surprised if it's more than 6 and that it couldn't be 10 or more as that's what you get for administration. I was purely stating that I don't know why or where they pull these ridiculous numbers from and why they don't get called out on it. 1
MPH Posted 29 May 2024 Posted 29 May 2024 1 hour ago, ClaphamFox said: Do you know what our PSR breach is then? Because I'm pretty sure that hasn't been revealed yet. The '6-15 points' range came from an unknown source cited in the Telegraph - it has not been confirmed anywhere. Whatever we get docked, we should - and will - appeal. 1 hour ago, Number 6 said: That Telegraph range is pretty hilarious. Might as well have been even safer and said it'll be anywhere between 0 and 40 points. if it was the Sun or the Express quoting an unnamed source, I’d be very skeptical… I don’t often consider the Telegraph a paper to make things up, even if they do have a political bias interpretation sometimes..
purpleronnie Posted 29 May 2024 Posted 29 May 2024 1 minute ago, MPH said: if it was the Sun or the Express quoting an unnamed source, I’d be very skeptical… I don’t often consider the Telegraph a paper to make things up, even if they do have a political bias interpretation sometimes.. sometimes?
MPH Posted 29 May 2024 Posted 29 May 2024 (edited) 21 minutes ago, purpleronnie said: sometimes? you’re right But not wanting to turn this thread into another political discussion thread! Edited 29 May 2024 by MPH
Stevosevic Posted 29 May 2024 Posted 29 May 2024 Surely we can’t get docked more than -9 for Administration
Recommended Posts