Finnegan Posted 10 December 2011 Posted 10 December 2011 Surely it has to be rated by someone other than Smuts to be "overrated"? If it's rated at all it's rated too much.
StanSP Posted 10 December 2011 Posted 10 December 2011 Father Ted said Oreo's. Probably first time I've ever agreed with him on something. Good call!
The Doctor Posted 10 December 2011 Posted 10 December 2011 LargeAl - Just **** off. The Beatles may not have been everyone's cup of tea and some of their stuff is shit but they basically changed popular music. Que? I didn't say they didn't (although Elvis was responsible for the major change first - The Beatles just build on that as far as I can tell) - all I mean is they seem to be regarded as this brilliant band when, IMO, they were a good band and nothing more. Therefore they are quite over-rated, note OVER-RATED, not RUBBISH.
Alexikokopops Posted 10 December 2011 Posted 10 December 2011 Que? I didn't say they didn't (although Elvis was responsible for the major change first - The Beatles just build on that as far as I can tell) - all I mean is they seem to be regarded as this brilliant band when, IMO, they were a good band and nothing more. Therefore they are quite over-rated, note OVER-RATED, not RUBBISH. Isn't FoxyPV arguing that they are regarded as a brilliant band not just because of the music but because of everything else they did? And so, if that is the case (which you admit) then maybe they're not so overrated after all? After all, music is so much more to so many people than just people playing some instruments and singing a bit.
The Doctor Posted 10 December 2011 Posted 10 December 2011 Isn't FoxyPV arguing that they are regarded as a brilliant band not just because of the music but because of everything else they did? And so, if that is the case (which you admit) then maybe they're not so overrated after all? After all, music is so much more to so many people than just people playing some instruments and singing a bit. I don't know, you'll have to ask him, but even though they did influence the path modern music has taken that doesn't make them brilliant - Led Zeppelin & Nirvana to name but two greatly influenced the path music took and yet I'd say they were over-rated in that they aren't as good a band as consensus suggests.
ajthefox Posted 10 December 2011 Posted 10 December 2011 Oasis are the best band that have ever played, however they did get their influences from the Beatles Are you mad?
MikeyT Posted 10 December 2011 Posted 10 December 2011 Mongy-music making manfaced minger You have just invented a new tongue twister! Beats red lorry, yellow lorry.
MikeyT Posted 10 December 2011 Posted 10 December 2011 Oasis are the best band that have ever played, however they did get their influences from the Beatles Best band that ever played...really? Ever??? That is a very bold statement. What about Led Zeppelin, The Beatles, The Jimi Hendrix Experience? To name but a mere smidgen.
Finnegan Posted 10 December 2011 Posted 10 December 2011 It's just a shot, people. And aniseed tastes like shit. Brushed my teeth about a thousand times and I can still taste last night.
Fox1651 Posted 10 December 2011 Posted 10 December 2011 Best band that ever played...really? Ever??? That is a very bold statement. What about Led Zeppelin, The Beatles, The Jimi Hendrix Experience? To name but a mere smidgen. Its all about opinions, i went to see Oasis live on their last tour before they split up and IMO they are the best band that has ever played, just my opinion mind you
SystonFox Posted 10 December 2011 Posted 10 December 2011 its all opinions dont take it personally. i love MUSE, Oasis, KASABIAN and The Beatles and they have all taken some flack in this thread. ones i do agree on though are Nando's (even though i love it) Ricky Gervais and X Factor glaringly obvious really
SystonFox Posted 10 December 2011 Posted 10 December 2011 It's just a shot, people. And aniseed tastes like shit. Brushed my teeth about a thousand times and I can still taste last night. also fully agree on this. put the word BOMB after something and people will lap it up
davieG Posted 10 December 2011 Posted 10 December 2011 also fully agree on this. put the word BOMB after something and people will lap it up Shit bomb - get lapping folks
SystonFox Posted 10 December 2011 Posted 10 December 2011 haha like it, but seriously ive been in bars/clubs and they are selling every spirit going with the word BOMB after it. stoooopid
SystonFox Posted 10 December 2011 Posted 10 December 2011 I'd drink a Goldschlager Bomb tbh. Known as "glitterBOMB" ****s the throat!
acooling08 Posted 11 December 2011 Posted 11 December 2011 Yes but they basically invented music as we know it and they were ahead of their time or something or other Haha absolute bollocks. There were many other similar bands around at the time in the UK and USA. The kinks and the Stones being examples. Yes the Beatles are the most popular but 'invented modern music' is going too far. I think the Beatles are the very definition of overated. They had a few decent songs and are hailed as the best band of all time. Laughable really. A beatles song wouldn't make my Top 100.
ozleicester Posted 11 December 2011 Posted 11 December 2011 I assume its been done... but just in case not.. and considering yesterdays result... Nigel Pearson,
SOCCERROO FOX Posted 11 December 2011 Posted 11 December 2011 Trying to function normally off an hours sleep.
Yojoe36 Posted 11 December 2011 Posted 11 December 2011 I assume its been done... but just in case not.. and considering yesterdays result... Nigel Pearson, Oh dear
Finnegan Posted 11 December 2011 Posted 11 December 2011 The show not the soundtrack. Wrong. Try again.
Recommended Posts
Archived
This topic is now archived and is closed to further replies.