Player ratings for the season

[foxfanazer]

I know the season isn't quite over but let's face it, the next two games aren't going to change much. So what are you rating out players from 1 to 10.  1 being Faes and 10 being prime Mahrez

 

 

Mads Hermandsen- 7  (8 pre injury) 

Jakub Stolarczyk- 6

Danny Ward- 2 just because 

 

Conor Coady- 5

Woyo Coulibaly- N/A

Wout Faes- 2 and that's generous. Appalling footballer

Jannik Vestegaard- 3 see above

James Justin- 2 see above. Gutted as I liked him

Viktor Kristiansen- 3 dreadful 

Caleb Okoli- 6 should've got more game time

Ricky P- 6 

Luke thomas- 6 surprisingly okay

 

 

Facundo Buanonotte- 6.5 had some big moments, should've had more game time

 

Bobby Reid- 4 worked hard but so limited 

Bilal El Khanouss- 8 standout player 

Monga- 6 promising but barely played

Ndidi- 4 his time is up here

Skipp- 3 absolute nothing player

Winks- 2 little rat. Get rid

Soumare- 3 just another rubbish footballer

 

 

Jordan Ayew- 4 scored some goals but he feels like a hindrance 

Patson Daka- 2 woeful 

Jamie Vardy- 6 time has caught up with him but still scored the majority of our goals

Édouard- 1 and that 1 goes to Rudkin

Kasey Mcateer- 5 not his level

Mavididi- 6 should've played more 

 

Cooper- 3

RVN- 2

 

Fans- 3

 

Rudkin- 0

Top- 0

 

[RowlattsFox]

Far too much effort to just say "everyone was shit"  

 

Hard to score anyone over a 6, even the like of Bilal and mads. 

[foxfanazer]

Just now, RowlattsFox said:

Far too much effort to just say "everyone was shit"  

 

Hard to score anyone over a 6, even the like of Bilal and mads. 

I felt sorry for Bilal. I don't think he could believe what he'd walked in to. Definitely think he was the standout though purely on the basis he wasn't shit

[urban.spaceman]

Alex Smithies - 10/10

[StanSP]

Whilst Faes has been a car crash, if he's getting a 2 then Ward has to get 1.

 

If we're talking crashes, Ward is a multi car pile up closing a road for a week. 

[fazzyfox]

I’d agree with that pretty much. The hard thing with Justin is he’s less unlikeable than many others for his effort but his concentration, positioning and decision making gift wrapped goals for the opposition week in week out to the extent that we’d concede less goals by fielding 10 men. Kristenson was ineffective but not quite as costly in terms of individual errors so 2 & 3 is about right.

[Raj]

Everyone was shit.

A couple were REALLY shit.

A couple were JUST ABOUT shit.

 

But 99% were shit.

 

Oh the Managers were shit too, but RVN is extra shit!

 

Rudkin is a cvnt too👍🏾

[Finnegan]

22 minutes ago, Raj said:

Everyone was shit.

A couple were REALLY shit.

A couple were JUST ABOUT shit.

 

But 99% were shit.

 

Oh the Managers were shit too, but RVN is extra shit!

 

Rudkin is a cvnt too👍🏾

 

I'm amazed they've still not hired you for the Mercury. 

 

[DJW1]

I only saw Édouard "in action" against Bournemouth, when he came on as sub for 10-15 mins. If I remember righty, his only contributions were to give away a foul, then get easily shrugged off the ball by his marker and finally fall over when clean through on goal. Based on that I would give him -3.

[honeybradger]

Bobby Reid 4 and Skipp 3 is generous. Maybe if the numbers are the number of good touches they've had this season.

[foxfanazer]

7 minutes ago, honeybradger said:

Bobby Reid 4 and Skipp 3 is generous. Maybe if the numbers are the number of good touches they've had this season.

I think Reid had 2 decent games and as I said at least looked like he was trying. Just not a very good player. Both probably could've been marked down 1 more

[turkish14]

 

My ratings for the season 
 

 

Mads Hermandsen 6

Facundo Buanonotte- 6

Bilal El Khanouss- 6

Monga- 6 

 

 

Jamie Vardy- 5

Luke thomas- 5

 

Caleb Okoli- 4

Ricky P- 4

Conor Coady- 4

Mavididi- 4

 

 

Jakub Stolarczyk 3

Ndidi- 3
james Justin 3

Soumare- 3 

Jordan Ayew- 3

Kasey Mcateer- 3

 

Woyo Coulibaly- 2

Wout Faes- 2

Jannik Vestegaard- 2

Viktor Kristiansen- 2

Bobby Reid- 2

Skipp- 2

Winks- 2 

 Daka- 2 

 

Édouard- 1 

Danny Ward- 1

 

 

[Winstonthedog]

3 hours ago, Raj said:

Everyone was shit.

A couple were REALLY shit.

A couple were JUST ABOUT shit.

 

But 99% were shit.

 

Oh the Managers were shit too, but RVN is extra shit!

 

Rudkin is a cvnt too👍🏾

So to sum it up the clubs full of shit 

[ShepshedFox1884]

My ratings 

7: 

El Khannous 

Hermansen 

 

6: 

Buonnanotte 

Stolarzcyk 

5:

Vardy 

Thomas 

Fatawu + Ricardo (in there small spells) 

 

4: 

Soumare

Mcateer 

Ndidi 

 

3: 

Coady 

Coulibaly 

Justin 

Okoli 
Winks 

Ayew 

Skipp

 

2: 

Faes 

Vestergaard 

BDCR 

Kristiansen 

Daka 

 

1: 

Edouard 

 

-10: 

Ward 

[LCFCCKEANO]

For me based on their ability vs performance, as if we actually just went off performance it’d be 2-4’s for everyone-

Hermansen- 6

Stolarczyk- 7

Ward-0

Pereira-6

Justin-3

Faes-2

Vestegaard-3

Okoli-5

Coady-4

Thomas-6

Kristiansen-4

Winks-3

Skipp-3

Soumare-3

Ndidi-4

Fatawu-8

Mavididi-5

BEK-7

Buonanotte-8 for Cooper, 4 for Ruud, 6

Ayew-4

BDCR-3

McAteer-5

Vardy-4

Daka-2

Edouard- dead

 

POTS- Iversen

Again not saying for example Stolarczyk is better than Mads, saying he has overperformed to his perceived ability more

 

 

[Kinowe Soorie]

Rodgers signings still stinking out the place 

[Xen]

Hermansen / BEK the only ones I'd say have been 'good' on the whole. Which says a lot when a keeper who's kept ONE clean sheet is one of your best players. 

Couple others have shown positive intent and in this disaster of a season have been moderately OK, and I wouldn't be disappointed for them to stick around. Ricardo, Thomas, Stolarcyzk, Okoli, McAteer, Mavididi 

Feels harsh to lump the academy players in with the rest of the squad, and can't really judge 15 year olds on bit-part appearances at the end of a season.

Fatawu looked decent before injury, Buonanotte was OK but on loan, Coulibaly basically hasn't played.

 

Vardy is Vardy.

 

Rest are crap.

[funkyrobot]

On 12/05/2025 at 13:35, foxfanazer said:

I know the season isn't quite over but let's face it, the next two games aren't going to change much. So what are you rating out players from 1 to 10.  1 being Faes and 10 being prime Mahrez

 

 

Mads Hermandsen- 7  (8 pre injury) 

Jakub Stolarczyk- 6

Danny Ward- 2 just because 

 

Conor Coady- 5

Woyo Coulibaly- N/A

Wout Faes- 2 and that's generous. Appalling footballer

Jannik Vestegaard- 3 see above

James Justin- 2 see above. Gutted as I liked him

Viktor Kristiansen- 3 dreadful 

Caleb Okoli- 6 should've got more game time

Ricky P- 6 

Luke thomas- 6 surprisingly okay

 

 

Facundo Buanonotte- 6.5 had some big moments, should've had more game time

 

Bobby Reid- 4 worked hard but so limited 

Bilal El Khanouss- 8 standout player 

Monga- 6 promising but barely played

Ndidi- 4 his time is up here

Skipp- 3 absolute nothing player

Winks- 2 little rat. Get rid

Soumare- 3 just another rubbish footballer

 

 

Jordan Ayew- 4 scored some goals but he feels like a hindrance 

Patson Daka- 2 woeful 

Jamie Vardy- 6 time has caught up with him but still scored the majority of our goals

Édouard- 1 and that 1 goes to Rudkin

Kasey Mcateer- 5 not his level

Mavididi- 6 should've played more 

 

Cooper- 3

RVN- 2

 

Fans- 3

 

Rudkin- 0

Top- 0

 

Absolutely no way BDCR has earned a 4. I haven’t looked at the rest of your scores properly but 4-10 for someone who bar a couple of tap ins has contributed little in attack or defence throughout the season is remarkable. 

[funkyrobot]

18 hours ago, foxfanazer said:

I think Reid had 2 decent games and as I said at least looked like he was trying. Just not a very good player. Both probably could've been marked down 1 more

Remind me what those decent games were then. Maybe a couple of decent moments but games?? I don’t remember anything bar a couple of accidental shanked assists and a couple of tap ins. 

[foxfanazer]

12 minutes ago, funkyrobot said:

Remind me what those decent games were then. Maybe a couple of decent moments but games?? I don’t remember anything bar a couple of accidental shanked assists and a couple of tap ins. 

That was them

[foxfanazer]

16 minutes ago, funkyrobot said:

Absolutely no way BDCR has earned a 4. I haven’t looked at the rest of your scores properly but 4-10 for someone who bar a couple of tap ins has contributed little in attack or defence throughout the season is remarkable. 

I just don't think he was as drastically bad as the likes of Justin, Faes etc. but absolutely fine with him being a 3

[BillyFOX12]

Mads pre-injury was a 9. Anyone remember the first game against Arsenal? He singlehandedly kept it 2-2 until overtime, I believe it was a PL record game for most attempts on goal.