elangLCFC Posted 17 June 2015 Posted 17 June 2015 If you could only keep one, who would it be? I'd actually say Huth, got more years in him and think he's more important to us as a side than Esteban, as brilliant as he is.
Wymsey Posted 17 June 2015 Posted 17 June 2015 Either. Both have been great leaders for the ranks (Huth - Defence; Cambiasso - Midfield) that has paid off successfully most recently. However, losing both would be very upsetting to think about.
Bluearmyfox28 Posted 17 June 2015 Posted 17 June 2015 Huth for me. Think we would just get by without Cambiasso to be honest. Should make this a poll!
Charl91 Posted 17 June 2015 Posted 17 June 2015 The questioned basically boils down to... Would you rather be fvkced in midfield or in defence?
foxoffderby Posted 17 June 2015 Posted 17 June 2015 EC never seen a player like him in my life at City. I've been going since 85. Huth is good but I've seen better CB at City. Walsh for example
Littletoe Posted 17 June 2015 Posted 17 June 2015 Love Huth but it has to be Cambiasso. Easy choice really.
Bluearmyfox28 Posted 17 June 2015 Posted 17 June 2015 He's been more effective though? For me it's been Huth making that defence 10x more solid.
shailen Posted 17 June 2015 Posted 17 June 2015 Difficult one. Huth has a lot more years ahead of him, but we could find an adequate replacement. Cambiasso is in a class of his own, and we won't replace someone of his quality, but has less time of his side. My head says Huth but my heart says Cambiasso.
Steve_Guppy_Left_Foot Posted 17 June 2015 Posted 17 June 2015 Haven't we already done this, and with a poll as well?
cc_star Posted 17 June 2015 Posted 17 June 2015 Is this even a question? Huth by a mile, by 10 miles, 100 miles in fact
kingfox Posted 17 June 2015 Posted 17 June 2015 Huth as Cambiasso will definitely leave at some point, whether that be this summer or next summer. Huth on a three year deal, will be more important than Cambiasso on a one year deal.
My Nads Posted 17 June 2015 Posted 17 June 2015 One of the best players of his generation or a better than average defender...?? Hmm...It's a tough one!
My Nads Posted 17 June 2015 Posted 17 June 2015 I guess the best way to look at it, is to think how difficult they are to replace. We could find a few players to replace Huth with some good scouting and a few quid, but Cambiasso's don't grow on trees.
1972 Fox Posted 18 June 2015 Posted 18 June 2015 Both very good players and either would be a big loss to us. But to me Cambiasso stands out as the best player I've ever seen play for us in over 40 years of following City. Please give us one more season Esteban.
weller54 Posted 18 June 2015 Posted 18 June 2015 Cambiasso is as good as gone !...Think he'll end up with one final , lucrative year in the MLS ... Worrying that the Permanent signing of Huth hasn't already been tied up!
ozleicester Posted 18 June 2015 Posted 18 June 2015 IMO, finding a replacement Huth is a much easier task than a replacement Cambiasso, however there is just 1 year left in Cambi compared to a few in Huth, so... bugger it.. im voting Cambiasso!! the man is a genius and the more chances i get to see him play, the happier ill be.
Guest Col city fan Posted 18 June 2015 Posted 18 June 2015 Huth as Cambiasso will definitely leave at some point, whether that be this summer or next summer. Huth on a three year deal, will be more important than Cambiasso on a one year deal. Yep, I agree with this. Any news on either anyone?
Guest Posted 18 June 2015 Posted 18 June 2015 Huth. The reason for our presence in the EPL next season. Sounds more and more like Cambiasso was a 1 year rental - hope he chooses to be loyal to us for the fans sake - they certainly loved him.
Ollie93 Posted 18 June 2015 Posted 18 June 2015 Huth. The reason for our presence in the EPL next season. Sounds more and more like Cambiasso was a 1 year rental - hope he chooses to be loyal to us for the fans sake - they certainly loved him. You not a fan than ?
Guest Posted 18 June 2015 Posted 18 June 2015 You not a fan than ? I don't hero worship the man, no. I hope he stays for those that do.
Recommended Posts
Archived
This topic is now archived and is closed to further replies.