Players who split opinions.

[TJQuik]

46 minutes ago, SK3Blue said:

Faes? I don't rate him at all. 

He's had about three good games for us. Is there anyone truly defending him?

[Daggers]

19 minutes ago, weller54 said:

Ward 

I think most sussed him within a match or two. I was very much in a minority saying he’d come good and would prove himself to be decent. 
 

I look upon this as my Teté-Flair moment. 

[Corky]

Dennis Wise. Some thought he was a twat, others a cvnt.

[splinterdream]

Soumare, or am I the only one that thinks after Rodgers left e began to look like a decent player?

Edited 4 July 2023 by splinterdream

[fox_favourite]

Easy Wellens 

[fox_favourite]

1 hour ago, CollinsLCFC said:

Amartey. 

Only splits from the opinion of everyone around him and the crowd when he passes. 

[fox_favourite]

59 minutes ago, bovril said:

Lloyd Dyer.

Steve Howard.

Wash your mouth out Dyer - is a legend! No argument, end of. So there 

 

Can't remember Steve Howard splitting opinions. He was good for us. 

 

If you're going in that team, I would say Oakley split opinions from the people around me in the stadium in the league one season. 

Edited 4 July 2023 by fox_favourite

[Foxes96]

Kelechi 

 

 

 

But understandable when he can go from the sublime to ridiculous within a single passage of play 😂 

[inckley fox]

16 minutes ago, splinterdream said:

Soumare, or am I the only one that thinks after Rodgers left e began to look like a decent player?

He is actually quite Oldfield-esque (re earlier post). 

[RumbleFox]

18 minutes ago, fox_favourite said:

Easy Wellens 

He only had himself to blame. 

[ronnup]

Kel is a beauty for this

[FoxInTheBox89]

Dimi Gray?

[Daggers]

The Yak. 
 

Some appreciated that he scored goals. Others didn’t understand that his job was to score goals. 

[Guest Mee-9]

Hume. 

 

Mad hatter that had no skill but could just run around. 

[Ashley]

11 minutes ago, Daggers said:

The Yak. 
 

Some appreciated that he scored goals. Others didn’t understand that his job was to score goals. 

This. 

 

Something like 11 in 20 wasn't it? Then again to be loved/considered decent by our fans you need to run around like a cvnt. 

[Danno]

2 minutes ago, Ashley said:

This. 

 

Something like 11 in 20 wasn't it? Then again to be loved/considered decent by our fans you need to run around like a cvnt. 

We were a much better team without him though.. lazy bastard 

[hebangsthedrums]

predates me but I remember my dad saying Tommy Wright divided opinion for a while, was the 92 Play off season that got him mass acceptance.

Also no idea where Izzet comes from - pretty much universally loved

Me & my dad argued over Gary Rowett - I thought he was a decent player in a poor side with a shite manager, dad thought he was shite.

Danny Tiatto - pashun vs headless chicken/donkey

Ryan Goalsmith - a few here (even beyond his famous chearleader) seemed to think he was going to be a worldie - showpony lightweight for me

[bovril]

49 minutes ago, fox_favourite said:

Wash your mouth out Dyer - is a legend! No argument, end of. So there 

 

Can't remember Steve Howard splitting opinions. He was good for us. 

 

If you're going in that team, I would say Oakley split opinions from the people around me in the stadium in the league one season. 

Dyer definitely split opinions. Lots of fans saw him as a headless chicken, while I remember some actually thought he could've done a job in the Premier League.

 

Howard like Fryatt was good in the third division, but blew hot and cold in the Champ. There were plenty of fans that didn't take to him, myself included.

[splinterdream]

40 minutes ago, inckley fox said:

He is actually quite Oldfield-esque (re earlier post). 

I think he'd be a decent player for us if he stays. If we plan on keeping possession, transitioning play through midfield, he'll be decent 

[Dahnsouff]

44 minutes ago, RumbleFox said:

He only had himself to blame. 

[atomicfox]

Paul Gallagher.

[TheStig]

2 hours ago, Ian S said:

Vestergaard

No split of opinions. All agree he is shit

[BillyFOX12]

1 hour ago, weller54 said:

Ward 

I believe he was denied a fair share of matches to display his true potential.

[whoareyaaa]

KDH

[Steve Earle]

Muzzy.

 

For some of a certain generation, the finest player of the MON era & the best AM we’ve ever had.

 

For others, say of my general height, weight & age, a lovable scamp of a midfielder who worked tirelessly for the cause alongside Lennon and, later, Savage and not without skills. But not in same league as say Weller, Draper, McAllister & Maddison.