Nod.E Posted 7 August 2007 Posted 7 August 2007 They show the HIGHLIGHTS of the match. If it was that good, they would of showed it, end of. but they didn't. ' end of '
Fez of Mahrez Posted 7 August 2007 Posted 7 August 2007 Can only find clips, but he does actually seem to make a couple of genuine good saves, but then it's not often he does that is it? I can think of more games he seriously let us down in than played well in. Even in the Sunderland game he let in an absolute hoooooooooooooooowler of a goal, almost as bad as the one away at Palace.
Nod.E Posted 7 August 2007 Posted 7 August 2007 ok so last season your saying Logan conceaded more from 20+ yards than Paul Henderson.Im in a good mood so Im actually going to give you a chance to retrace that statement before I go on a rant. ha. Well henderson played more games, so actually he did. But i think the ratio of games to goals conceded from 20+ yards would see Logan logans ratio higher..
Manwell Pablo Posted 7 August 2007 Posted 7 August 2007 I don't think that ball could of trickled any slower. Lobbed from 30 by Mark Nygaard I think thats probabley the ultimate proof that a goal keeper is shit. And that headers should of been delt with better as well he is no where near it!I could go on Andy Grays header against Burnley which he got a strong hand to and pushed into the top corner, Bridges goal for Hull in which he took about 40 seconds to react to. he ships sooo mannyy goals he should save it is UNREAL!
Jimmy Posted 7 August 2007 Posted 7 August 2007 but they didn't. ' end of ' you really are a twat highlights shows and also shows like soccer am LOVE to show brilliant saves its second only to a 40 yard screamer in the replay stakes
Jimmy Posted 7 August 2007 Posted 7 August 2007 ha. Well henderson played more games, so actually he did. But i think the ratio of games to goals conceded from 20+ yards would see Logan logans ratio higher.. with most of them coming in the same once in a life-time type of game against wdenesday, come up with more examples then that game
Manwell Pablo Posted 7 August 2007 Posted 7 August 2007 Even in the Sunderland game he let in an absolute hoooooooooooooooowler of a goal, almost as bad as the one away at Palace. Hysens? It looked dodgey from what I could find but the quality was so poor I didn't want to comment.
mancunianfox Posted 7 August 2007 Posted 7 August 2007 Theres not much a keeper can do about a 25 yard screamer heading for the top corner. The defending was to blame more than anything for not closing them down soon enough and giving them time to shoot.
Nod.E Posted 7 August 2007 Posted 7 August 2007 To big to get of the floor and get to the top corner, where the Sheff Wed screamers went, hardly any keepers would get to those. He had so long to see the shot coming, they were from far, far out, and he just didnt react. A lot of keepers wouldve saved them. ( not all of the goals ) infact most keepers wouldve saved some of them. Infact i couldev saved one of them, and i'm and average 15 year old keeper
Fez of Mahrez Posted 7 August 2007 Posted 7 August 2007 Hysens? It looked dodgey from what I could find but the quality was so poor I didn't want to comment. Connolly in the home game I was on about. Crossed wires maybe, I haven't been concentrating on this thread.
Simi Posted 7 August 2007 Posted 7 August 2007 ha. Well henderson played more games, so actually he did. But i think the ratio of games to goals conceded from 20+ yards would see Logan logans ratio higher.. You think ? You are yet to show any sort of hard statistics to back up this point. Whereas Mablo has provided YouTube clips etc. Slipping away...
l444ry Posted 7 August 2007 Posted 7 August 2007 You can forget all your left-backs, creative midfielders or striker requirements, unless City make the goalkeeping situation a major priority it could be the difference between stork and butter - no play-off place!!!
Nod.E Posted 7 August 2007 Posted 7 August 2007 you really are a twat highlights shows and also shows like soccer am LOVE to show brilliant saves its second only to a 40 yard screamer in the replay stakes Feeling mutual mate ... and i don't think soccer am would show a decent save from the championship... i'm not saying this is the best save ever to be seen on this planet... it was just a good save! Look, trust me, He made a good save, they didnt show it! It happens!
Nod.E Posted 7 August 2007 Posted 7 August 2007 You think ?You are yet to show any sort of hard statistics to back up this point. Whereas Mablo has provided YouTube clips etc. Slipping away... Can't find any. Youtbe doesnt have many from the sheff weds game, well tleast i can't find them. I'm not the best at surfing for results
Jimmy Posted 7 August 2007 Posted 7 August 2007 He had so long to see the shot coming, they were from far, far out, and he just didnt react. A lot of keepers wouldve saved them. ( not all of the goals ) infact most keepers wouldve saved some of them. Infact i couldev saved one of them, and i'm and average 15 year old keeper get real the speed those shots had he had about 1 second of reaction time, Petr Cech would of struggled to save them. its nothing like playing in goal in a kids sunday league games where all you tend to get are scuffed shots
Fez of Mahrez Posted 7 August 2007 Posted 7 August 2007 Has anyone posted Palace's first goal at Selhurst last season yet? Can't really view Youtube links at work. That was one of the worst goals we conceded all season for whatever reason.
Jimmy Posted 7 August 2007 Posted 7 August 2007 Can't find any. Youtbe doesnt have many from the sheff weds game, well tleast i can't find them. I'm not the best at surfing for results stop banging on about the weds game, did you not go to any others, make some more examples to back up your argument
Simi Posted 7 August 2007 Posted 7 August 2007 Can't find any. Youtbe doesnt have many from the sheff weds game, well tleast i can't find them. I'm not the best at surfing for results Exactly, so stop claiming Henderson has a better ratio than Logan, if you have the proof fair enough, but you don't.
Manwell Pablo Posted 7 August 2007 Posted 7 August 2007 Can't find any. Youtbe doesnt have many from the sheff weds game, well tleast i can't find them. I'm not the best at surfing for results They were corking shots that were savable as I said but Henderon wouldn't of got anywhere near them. Where as the ones I showed you are severe goal keeping errors. Yes Fez I've posted that goal on here.
Manwell Pablo Posted 7 August 2007 Posted 7 August 2007 Can't find any. Youtbe doesnt have many from the sheff weds game, well tleast i can't find them. I'm not the best at surfing for results There.
The People's Hero Posted 7 August 2007 Posted 7 August 2007 This is a bit like arguing whether you'd rather have a sh it sandwich or a vomit pie.
Jimmy Posted 7 August 2007 Posted 7 August 2007 not really he is basing his whole opinion of both keepers on 1 game each
Simi Posted 7 August 2007 Posted 7 August 2007 There. That video another prime example how much of a liability McCarthy was. He had no chance with Brunt and Whelans goals
Fez of Mahrez Posted 7 August 2007 Posted 7 August 2007 This is a bit like arguing whether you'd rather have a sh it sandwich or a vomit pie. Exactly. And then buying a pint of Carlsberg for £230,000 and waiting to find out whether it tastes like piss.
Manwell Pablo Posted 7 August 2007 Posted 7 August 2007 That video another prime example how much of a liability McCarthy was.He had no chance with Brunt and Whelans goals 2nd and 4th are savable if your a good keeper I reckon. Whelans is unstoppable.
Recommended Posts
Archived
This topic is now archived and is closed to further replies.