Guest ttfn Posted 15 November 2012 Posted 15 November 2012 Rooney's goal is one of the most over-rated goals ever. It's only because it was in a derby game (and by Rooney) that it gets such credit. Great goal, but not one of the best. The occasion is part of what makes a goal great though. Zidane's goal in the 2002 Champions League final was a great goal in its own right, but it only lives on in legend because of the occasion and the audience in front of which it was displayed.
leicesterisme Posted 15 November 2012 Posted 15 November 2012 Brilliant player, why can't we get a player like that, instead we get Danny Fookin Welbeck. Give me Welbeck every single time over Rooney for England!
Guest Posted 15 November 2012 Posted 15 November 2012 He is a hero in Paris. I've seen quite a few of his matches this year for PSG - they are always on the TV. He is quite extraordinary and more than that he's a leader of players on the field.
DB11 Posted 15 November 2012 Posted 15 November 2012 Good technique but not a good goal - there was no goalkeeper to beat! It was no different to when defenders do overhead kicks to clear the ball, it's just this time it ended up in the goal
AyewJoking Posted 15 November 2012 Posted 15 November 2012 It was a bit special. Not many will score an overhead from that far out. Made Hart look even more of a tit
Manwell Pablo Posted 15 November 2012 Posted 15 November 2012 It depends what you mean by over-rated. In terms of what he's actually capable of he's clearly one of the greatest players of all time and I don't think many people would argue that. But people like Maradona, Zidane, Ronaldo, Messi, Figo and the like are consistently superb and have had careers full of plaudits for that reason. Ibra's a bit like Totti, he's clearly got it in him to be an all time legend but he just doesn't have the mental characteristics to have really changed the world with his career. I like to think of him as football's Gavin Henson. Unfair on Totti that, Totti's main problem was/is that he's Roma through and through, he was consistantly superb also just didn't always have the talent or a title winning side around him.
foxfanazer Posted 15 November 2012 Posted 15 November 2012 The occasion is part of what makes a goal great though. Zidane's goal in the 2002 Champions League final was a great goal in its own right, but it only lives on in legend because of the occasion and the audience in front of which it was displayed. Sergio Aguero's goal against QPR last season still gives me shivers now when I see it. Imagine the buzz!
Manwell Pablo Posted 15 November 2012 Posted 15 November 2012 Really? Rooney hit it with his shin, he clearly miskicked it. This, horrrible connection, farce that it was even nominated for best Premier League goal of all time never mind the fact it won it.
purpleronnie Posted 15 November 2012 Posted 15 November 2012 Never understood why people rate rooney's goal so highly and the fact some think it was better than the goal last night strikes of english bias. Rooney barely had to move, not only wasnt it the greatest goal , there have been many better overhead kicks.
Father Ted Posted 15 November 2012 Posted 15 November 2012 'Best goal ever' really? So cringeworthy, hes just another arrogant mercenary.
Bugg Posted 15 November 2012 Posted 15 November 2012 Never understood why people rate rooney's goal so highly and the fact some think it was better than the goal last night strikes of english bias. Rooney barely had to move, not only wasnt it the greatest goal , there have been many better overhead kicks. I actually preferred berbatovs overhead kick in the same season to complete his hat trick against Liverpool. Was far harder to do, teed himself up and picked out the top corner with his 2nd touch.
Parafox Posted 15 November 2012 Posted 15 November 2012 dont see what the big deal is, waghorn can do that with his eyes closed... Dreaming you mean
purpleronnie Posted 15 November 2012 Posted 15 November 2012 I actually preferred berbatovs overhead kick in the same season to complete his hat trick against Liverpool. Was far harder to do, teed himself up and picked out the top corner with his 2nd touch. Absolutely I said that too, far better....the one where he controlled it on his knee then overhead kick, great goal.
Julian Joachim Jr Shabadoo Posted 15 November 2012 Posted 15 November 2012 Outrageous goal but nowhere near the best I've ever seen. Had no goalkeeper to beat for a start But that's because the opportunity was only there as Joe Hart had come out and was close in proximity at the time of the strike. It's totally legitimate - it's not like the keeper was down or slipped or anything It was poor defending and an awful goalkeeping decision by Hart, but I don't think it can be denied as a fantastic goal And when people say "fluke" - can't that be attributed to almost any goal? Ibrahimovic had a chance to strike from what seemed like an unlikely area, he timed the kick perfectly, obviously struck exactly as hard and as accurately as he planned, and got it perfectly on target. Even landed over the line. An incredible goal, and totally deserving - he pulled England to pieces last night
foxfanazer Posted 15 November 2012 Posted 15 November 2012 But that's because the opportunity was only there as Joe Hart had come out and was close in proximity at the time of the strike. It's totally legitimate - it's not like the keeper was down or slipped or anything It was poor defending and an awful goalkeeping decision by Hart, but I don't think it can be denied as a fantastic goal And when people say "fluke" - can't that be attributed to almost any goal? Ibrahimovic had a chance to strike from what seemed like an unlikely area, he timed the kick perfectly, obviously struck exactly as hard and as accurately as he planned, and got it perfectly on target. Even landed over the line. An incredible goal, and totally deserving - he pulled England to pieces last night No mate you've misunderstood me, it was an incredible goal and great awareness but for me it's not even close to the best goal ever. The technique and audacity to even try it was a pleasure to see but he didn't half profit fromJoe hart and an inexperienced back line. Much prefer to see a goal where the keeper is clutching at thin air from a 40 yard rocket or a goal like Knockaert's 2nd against Huddersfield. Oh and on Rooney's goal, overrated just like the player himself. All about the occasion and not the technique. Muzzy's was far better
whoareyaaa Posted 15 November 2012 Posted 15 November 2012 Unbelievable Jeff! I don't recall myself saying 'wooooah' to a goal since Claridges 123st minute winner.
Haydos Posted 15 November 2012 Posted 15 November 2012 Great finish but no chance is it anything like the 'best ever'. It was audacious but he had no keeper to beat and basically just thumped it back over his head. On another note, bicycle kicks that are taken from a cross (Muzzy's, Rooney's, Falcao's) are so much more technically impressive than ones where you've tee'd it up on your knee (Berbatov, Rivaldo). It's obviously not 'easy' but once you've controlled the ball (if you're doing it right) you're volleying a ball that has reached it's highest point of motion and effectively isn't moving.
purpleronnie Posted 15 November 2012 Posted 15 November 2012 Great finish but no chance is it anything like the 'best ever'. It was audacious but he had no keeper to beat and basically just thumped it back over his head. On another note, bicycle kicks that are taken from a cross (Muzzy's, Rooney's, Falcao's) are so much more technically impressive than ones where you've tee'd it up on your knee (Berbatov, Rivaldo). It's obviously not 'easy' but once you've controlled the ball (if you're doing it right) you're volleying a ball that has reached it's highest point of motion and effectively isn't moving. Maybe, I think berbatov's was more difficult technically than rooneys, rooney was unmarked side on to goal, berb was marked with his back to goal, berb had to first control a cross on his knee and still generate the force to place the ball whilst still being marked....both great goals but I think berb's is superior.
Carl the Llama Posted 15 November 2012 Posted 15 November 2012 We're all missing the point here: If the English media don't focus on a speculative overhead kick into an open goal at the end of a friendly, then they might have to discuss what went wrong with England's defensive work in the second half.
Julian Joachim Jr Shabadoo Posted 15 November 2012 Posted 15 November 2012 No mate you've misunderstood me, it was an incredible goal and great awareness but for me it's not even close to the best goal ever. The technique and audacity to even try it was a pleasure to see but he didn't half profit from Joe hart and an inexperienced back line. Much prefer to see a goal where the keeper is clutching at thin air from a 40 yard rocket or a goal like Knockaert's 2nd against Huddersfield. Oh and on Rooney's goal, overrated just like the player himself. All about the occasion and not the technique. Muzzy's was far better Ah sorry, was misunderstood - think I brushed over the comments without reading yours properly Not the "best" goal ever, but definitely one of the most entertaining - much like Tim Howard's 100-yarder last season against Bolton (goal wasn't intended, but a brilliant 5 seconds of entertainment nonetheless)
foxfanazer Posted 15 November 2012 Posted 15 November 2012 Ah sorry, was misunderstood - think I brushed over the comments without reading yours properly Not the "best" goal ever, but definitely one of the most entertaining - much like Tim Howard's 100-yarder last season against Bolton (goal wasn't intended, but a brilliant 5 seconds of entertainment nonetheless) Absolutely
Super_horns Posted 15 November 2012 Posted 15 November 2012 Stunning vision and skill.. He just did that without a seconds thought!
MooseBreath Posted 15 November 2012 Posted 15 November 2012 Joey Gudjohnson's half way line drive was better
Alf Bentley Posted 15 November 2012 Posted 15 November 2012 Good...very good...but better than this one? I don't think so... I tend to prefer really great team goals, in any case (Knockaert to Nugent to net was pretty good last Saturday)
Recommended Posts
Archived
This topic is now archived and is closed to further replies.