FIFA 15

[Ashley]

http://www.squawka.com/comparison-matrix#championship/2013/2014/matthew_upson/93/93/771/0/p|championship/2013/2014/liam_moore/93/93/10688/0/p|championship/2013/2014/wes_morgan/93/93/10686/0/p|championship/2013/2014/marcin_wasilewski/93/93/212/0/p#tackles_won/tackles_lost/total_duels_%/aerial_duels_won/aerial_duels_won_%/fouls_committed/interceptions/blocks#total

 

Comparsion of Upson to Moore, Morgan, Wasilewski

[Buzzell]

It's Ashley, I sincerely hope he doesn't get paid for it, what a joke

I'm sure it's not all down to Ashley. Chill lad.

[ScouseFox]

the thing ashley seemingly isn't getting is that it's not the actual overalls that are massively bothering a lot of people. yeah some of them look a bit low but deal with it, "overalls mean nothing" blah blah blah. it's the comparisons between similar players. how has whoever does the qpr ratings managed to get richard dunne to be a 74? clint hill better than morgan? karl henry as good as drinkwater?! sean wright phillips better than mahrez?! if other players can somehow get ratings like this then why are our players all seemingly so shit? that's what's irking most in this thread. if morgan was a 70 and moore was a 69 but clint hill was a 68 and richard dunne a 67 then not many would be complaining. 

[Ashley]

the thing ashley seemingly isn't getting is that it's not the actual overalls that are massively bothering a lot of people. yeah some of them look a bit low but deal with it, "overalls mean nothing" blah blah blah. it's the comparisons between similar players. how has whoever does the qpr ratings managed to get richard dunne to be a 74? clint hill better than morgan? karl henry as good as drinkwater?! sean wright phillips better than mahrez?! if other players can somehow get ratings like this then why are our players all seemingly so shit? that's what's irking most in this thread. if morgan was a 70 and moore was a 69 but clint hill was a 68 and richard dunne a 67 then not many would be complaining. 

 

 

Fair enough, believe me Scouse I want Leicester to be good on fifa, to be fair I think we are. As others have said previously think it may of even been you.. It takes ages to get to a decent rating them people seem to stay there.. other editors may not pay attention to detail. Knockaert for one has had Sprint Speed lowered, again NOT my doing but I don't think he should be as low as he is...

[ScouseFox]

Fair enough, believe me Scouse I want Leicester to be good on fifa, to be fair I think we are. As others have said previously think it may of even been you.. It takes ages to get to a decent rating them people seem to stay there.. other editors may not pay attention to detail. Knockaert for one has had Sprint Speed lowered, again NOT my doing but I don't think he should be as low as he is...

 

oh yeah i imagine it's a long hard job to look at every aspect of every player, things like the pace of tom hopper or something, i watch us quite a lot and know quite a bit about our players but things like that wouldn't even know where to start . i personally don't play fifa much anymore but if i did i wouldn't even be too fussed if one or two things about our team were out, just the comparisons that would annoy me. i can picture it now being online, matched with qpr and being dominated because rio ferdinand is still seemingly one of the best defenders in the world  

 

i'm sure people will barely even notice an overall once they actually get to play the game, but this is the only talking point so far, so people gonna talk. 

[Ashley]

UPSON:

Marking 72

Slide Tackle 70

Standing Tackle 73

Heading 73

Interceptions 74

 

Moore:

Marking 66

Slide Tackle 69

Standing Tackle 68

Heading 71

Interceptions 69

 

Morgan:

Marking 72

Slide Tackle 67

Standing Tackle 69

Heading 72

Interceptions 71

 

Wasilewski:

Marking 67

Slide Tackle 71

Standing Tackle 69

Heading 79

Interceptions 66

 

 

 

 

 

Gives a comparison, bare in mind tackling goes on tackles won and lost.

[Will1981]

Top Championship Goalkeepers last Season - http://www.squawka.com/football-player-rankings#performance-score#goalkeeper-stats#football-league-championship|season-2013/2014#all-teams#goalkeeper#16#43#30#0#90#03/08/2013#24/05/2014#season#1#all-matches#total#desc#total

 

Top Championship Defenders last Season - http://www.squawka.com/football-player-rankings#performance-score#player-stats#football-league-championship|season-2013/2014#all-teams#defender#16#43#30#0#90#03/08/2013#24/05/2014#season#1#all-matches#total#desc#total

 

Top Championship Midfielders last Season - http://www.squawka.com/football-player-rankings#performance-score#player-stats#football-league-championship|season-2013/2014#all-teams#midfielder#16#43#30#0#90#03/08/2013#24/05/2014#season#1#all-matches#total#desc#total

 

Top Championship Forwards last Season - http://www.squawka.com/football-player-rankings#performance-score#player-stats#football-league-championship|season-2013/2014#all-teams#forward#16#43#30#0#90#03/08/2013#24/05/2014#season#1#all-matches#total#desc#total

[dave_the_fox]

Ash what about danny? Why cant he have the stats (or nearer) to his team of the season card? I understand you dont do UT but a 73/74 is fair for the lad?

http://www.futhead.com/14/players/14304/danny-drinkwater/

[Devonfox1884]

To be honest, I play pretty much all UT, so I'm happy with our player ratings, even though they should be higher.

Schlupp and Bakayogo look like they could be beasts in bronze teams.

Schmeichel was a very OP silver last year, there shouldn't be any change this year. Morgan will be an absolute brute with 91 strength, Ulloa will be decent in the air too. The main gripe I have is with Moore being non-rare, and the fact that vardy's pace is well below what it should be, but that has been said to death.

[Mark_w]

If adebayor is 4* then mahrez deserves to be, watch some of his clips on YouTube, every time he's on the ball he's doing something, even if it is just a step over.

 

Well the good news is, you can do as many step overs as you like with Riyad in FIFA 15.

[Ashley]

Ash what about danny? Why cant he have the stats (or nearer) to his team of the season card? I understand you dont do UT but a 73/74 is fair for the lad?

http://www.futhead.com/14/players/14304/danny-drinkwater/

Can ask the senior producers for you

[Steve_Guppy_Left_Foot]

Does Riyad have any special/high abilities to ride challenges and keep his balance?

[Ashley]

Does Riyad have any special/high abilities to ride challenges and keep his balance?

Agility is 87 on current fifa I believe.

[MrSpaM]

Fair enough, believe me Scouse I want Leicester to be good on fifa, to be fair I think we are. As others have said previously think it may of even been you.. It takes ages to get to a decent rating them people seem to stay there.. other editors may not pay attention to detail. Knockaert for one has had Sprint Speed lowered, again NOT my doing but I don't think he should be as low as he is...

How many other people get a say in it other than you? And how many of them are QPR/burnley/watford fans irl?

[Ashley]

How many other people get a say in it other than you? And how many of them are QPR/burnley fans irl?

Majority of editors or reviewers are fans in real life believe me our network is huge. Obviously each team has their editor.. everyone gets a say.

[MrSpaM]

Majority of editors or reviewers are fans in real life believe me our network is huge. Obviously each team has their editor.. everyone gets a say.

Fair enough, it's just going back to what you said before about Knockys speed being lowered for no apparent reason. Surely if you are the editor for us they should be asking your opinion before changing it? Or is that not how it works? Find it kinda strange that someone else who obviously doesn't see us play week in week out can just change stats willy nilly. Knockys speed didn't get lowered just after watford away last season did it?

[Guest kristianity77]

So does anyone know whether Leicester will have their own specific crowd chants in this game? Notice no end for Liverpool and Man City in the demo but wonder if that applies to all the prem teams?

 

FIFA would be complete for me with a nice "Tw@T, your sh*t ahhhhh" after every opposition goal kick....

[LAprice_]

Ashley, does that mean to say that if the QPR editor wants to give Charlie Austin "90" pace, you can review it and say no? Do you all review eachother? 

 

Just out of interest, does anyone know Lloyd Dyer's pace? I hate to bring back memories, but over the last 7 years his sprint speed as gone: 60, 60, 81, 84, 84, 87, 89 and most recently, 91. This should give a bit of perspective with the Vardy situation. We want Vardy to have 85-90 pace after 1 good season. It took Lloydy 7 years to get there. 

 

This whole system takes time to perfect, that's why it's brilliant that we get weekly updates - Yeah, it's annoying for FUT, but in some cases (Aaron Ramsey for e.g) FIFA will release an updated card. 

 

On Fifa 10, Wayne Rooney was quicker than Lloyd Dyer. They were both slower than Paul Konchesky. 

[Fosse93]

It's Ashley, I sincerely hope he doesn't get paid for it, what a joke

Do you ever have anything positive to say? 

[LCFC FOX]

I would just like to see Kasper, Morgan and Drinkwater be gold

[lgfualol]

Has anything changed for the youth scouting network things on Fifa, Ashley?

 

I'd love to not have to bring 16/17 year olds into the first team all the time. Why isn't there a youth team feature? That would be cool. 

[Ashley]

Ashley, does that mean to say that if the QPR editor wants to give Charlie Austin "90" pace, you can review it and say no? Do you all review eachother? 

 

Just out of interest, does anyone know Lloyd Dyer's pace? I hate to bring back memories, but over the last 7 years his sprint speed as gone: 60, 60, 81, 84, 84, 87, 89 and most recently, 91. This should give a bit of perspective with the Vardy situation. We want Vardy to have 85-90 pace after 1 good season. It took Lloydy 7 years to get there. 

 

This whole system takes time to perfect, that's why it's brilliant that we get weekly updates - Yeah, it's annoying for FUT, but in some cases (Aaron Ramsey for e.g) FIFA will release an updated card. 

 

On Fifa 10, Wayne Rooney was quicker than Lloyd Dyer. They were both slower than Paul Konchesky. 

 

Yes, I can leave feedback on ANY PLAYER within FIFA, its up to Editors then Producers(Who work in EA Offices) to make changes should they feel they need too, believe me the community is getting better due to more stats etc being made available to the public.

 

Has anything changed for the youth scouting network things on Fifa, Ashley?

 

I'd love to not have to bring 16/17 year olds into the first team all the time. Why isn't there a youth team feature? That would be cool. 

 

 

I would like to see the same thing but this isn't my area, i'm sorry I only look after database, player looks etc.

[TimG]

Ashley, Some of these ratings are criminally low in my opinion (especially when compared to those of teams such as QPR, West Brom, Cardiff, Fulham etc) Our ratings still look like those of a Championship team.

 

Why has Nugent had his pace and dribbling downgraded and only got 58 passing?

Surely Drinkwater warrants a higher rating than 70 when he was nominated for championship player of the season last year; 74 would be fair imo. Certainly his passing should be higher than 67 and defending higher than 60.

Vardy should have much higher shooting than 69 I think. Bobby Zamora has 74 shooting, yet last season he scored 4 goals and Vardy scored 16.

Why has Morgan had his defending downgraded. He is one of our best players and has been fantastic in these first four premier league games as well as last season. How is he rated 71 when Onouha is 75 and Jonas Olsson is 76?

 

I would say James, Mahrez, Moore and Schmeichel all should be rated higher as well.

 

I understand its hard for you to make drastic changes but our players seem underrated across the board and I think that is reflected in the number of people on this forum voicing similar complaints to myself.

[Ashley]

Ashley, Some of these ratings are criminally low in my opinion (especially when compared to those of teams such as QPR, West Brom, Cardiff, Fulham etc) Our ratings still look like those of a Championship team.

Why has Nugent had his pace and dribbling downgraded and only got 58 passing?

Surely Drinkwater warrants a higher rating than 70 when he was nominated for championship player of the season last year; 74 would be fair imo. Certainly his passing should be higher than 67 and defending higher than 60.

Vardy should have much higher shooting than 69 I think. Bobby Zamora has 74 shooting, yet last season he scored 4 goals and Vardy scored 16.

Why has Morgan had his defending downgraded. He is one of our best players and has been fantastic in these first four premier league games as well as last season. How is he rated 71 when Onouha is 75 and Jonas Olsson is 76?

I would say James, Mahrez, Moore and Schmeichel all should be rated higher as well.

I understand its hard for you to make drastic changes but our players seem underrated across the board and I think that is reflected in the number of people on this forum voicing similar complaints to myself.

Nugent pace is an 80 was last season. His first touch has been downgraded due to him being in an high category. Overalls mean nothing.. how many more times. I'm sure Vardy finishing is low 70 which is about right.

Morgan defending hasn't be downgraded?

[eunmac]

In fairness to Riyad, it makes sense to analyse the Squawka data in context rather than the whole.

Filtered properly by 90 minutes football time and by 19 games or more and from Jan (given he only played last half of season) this ranks him as the third best midfielder in the championship last year.

 

http://www.squawka.com/football-player-rankings#performance-score#player-stats#football-league-championship|season-2013/2014#all-teams#midfielder#16#43#18#0#90#16/01/2014#24/05/2014#season#1#all-matches#total#desc#90

 

 

And just for fun here is Knocks, Drinkwater, Marhez and Cambiasso data compared for last season:

 

http://www.squawka.com/comparison-matrix#championship/2013/2014/riyad_mahrez/93/93/11509/0/p|championship/2013/2014/anthony_knockaert/93/93/10715/0/p|championship/2013/2014/daniel_drinkwater/93/93/10693/0/p|serie_a/2013/2014/esteban_cambiasso/76/76/2659/0/p#tackles_won/tackles_lost/total_duels_%/aerial_duels_won/fouls_committed/interceptions/successful_passes/goals_scored/total_shots/total_score/assists/chances_created/total_passes/key_passes#avg