Stuliasz Posted 20 December 2014 Share Posted 20 December 2014 Please vote in the survey and then discuss in the thread. Visit this page Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
Col city fan Posted 20 December 2014 Share Posted 20 December 2014 I'm assuming Cambiasso gets the customary 8? Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
Guest ttfn Posted 20 December 2014 Share Posted 20 December 2014 Hamer 6 Simpson 5 Morgan 6 Wasyl 8 Konchesky 2 - because It's Christmas Mahrez 6 Cambiasso 5 King 6 Drinkwater 5 Schlupp 5 Vardy 5 Subs: Ulloa 5 Nugent 6.5 Knockaert 3 Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
Stuliasz Posted 20 December 2014 Author Share Posted 20 December 2014 I'm assuming Cambiasso gets the customary 8? Cambiasso's last 10 ratings: 7.13 6.11 6.33 5.93 6.38 5.05 5.19 4.29 4.91 5.70 Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
cc_star Posted 20 December 2014 Share Posted 20 December 2014 Mahrez woeful Schlupp at LW embarrassing Cambiasso completely awful Vardy dire Everyone else their usual steady but not good enough Nugent our MotM for actually trying to score Pearson, nice to see him on the touchline for 90mins, should have made those subs at HT, because there was no chance of us scoring and every chance of going 2-0 down by which point it was too late He should never play Vardy on his own, or Schlupp at LW ever again Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
lgfualol Posted 20 December 2014 Share Posted 20 December 2014 Is a 5 too generous or Most got 5. Konch got 1 for being shit. Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
Carl the Llama Posted 20 December 2014 Share Posted 20 December 2014 Hamer 6Simpson 6Morgan 6Wasyl 6Konchesky 1Mahrez 6Cambiasso 6King 6Drinkwater 6Schlupp 3Vardy 4Subs:Ulloa 5Nugent 6Knockaert 5 Pearson: 5 Ref: 7 West Ham: 6 Pearson IN Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
eastendfox Posted 20 December 2014 Share Posted 20 December 2014 Hamer 6 - not much to do apart from goals he couldn't do anything about, commands his box well though Simpson 6 - did fine Morgan 6 - solid enough Was 7 - seemed to win most things he went for Konchesky 2 - cost us big time Mahrez 3 - really poor for most of game Cambiasso 5 - not at his best today King 5 - tidy and good defensively, not so much going forward Drinkwater 6 - best I've seen if him this season, drive us forward well Schlupp 6 - looked a threat Vardy 5 - didn't make much impression Subs all 5, had their moments, Nugent and Ulloa could both have scored Pearson 6 - picked a decent side, took the right players off Ref 5 - some odd decisions not least Ulloa booking West Ham 6 - solid but not special, only 2 shots on target, and had less possession than us - a first for us away this season? But ultimately not quite good enough at back or front Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
ADK Posted 20 December 2014 Share Posted 20 December 2014 Hamer 7 Konchesky 3 Wasilevski 7 Morgan 6 Simpson 6 Schlupp 7 Cambiasso 6 King 7 Drinkwater 7 Mahrez 7 Vardy 5 Ulloa 6 Nugent 7 Knockaert 6 Pearson 6 Ref 6 West Ham 7 Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
Rasmic123 Posted 20 December 2014 Share Posted 20 December 2014 Hamer - 5 Simpson - 4 Wes - 4 Was - 4 Konch - 4 (apart from that terrible mistake he actually was pretty decent) Mahrez - 5 Cambiasso - 5 Drinky - 6 (probably our best player) King - 4 (needs to be dropped) Schlupp - 6 Vardy - 6 Pearson - 6 (thought the starting lineup was good and had it not been for Konch we would have probably got something out of the game. subs were right as well. Ref - 1 ****in awful and ruined the game West Ham - 6 Decent but we could have got something out of the game, their defence was shoddy Next game, we need to drop Simpson and King for De Laet and Knocky, King does **** all and Simpson is just so ineffective, we're not scoring goals and we're conceding them regardless so we may as well have someone who is good at getting forward on like de laet Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
peterthefox Posted 20 December 2014 Share Posted 20 December 2014 Morgan should try and keep his play simple, every game he gives the ball away in poor areas, when he could have played it simple and put the ball out. Instead he tries to turn or worse still he tries to beat his man and ends up putting the team in trouble. Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
Bamba's Babes Posted 20 December 2014 Share Posted 20 December 2014 10 - 9 - 8 - 7 - Hamer, Referee, WHU 6 - Simpson 5 - Was, Morgan, Pearson 4 - Cambiasso, Drinkwater, King, Mahrez, Schlupp, Vardy, Nugent 3 - Knockeart 2 - Ulloa 1 - Konchesky Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
Dan LCFC Posted 20 December 2014 Share Posted 20 December 2014 Back five all get fives barring Konchesky who gets a three. Cambiasso gets a six. Drinkwater & King were both passengers and get fours. Schlupp was dreadful, 3. Mahrez I thought was our main threat again without really doing enough, 6. Vardy gets a four. Not good enough for this league. Subs get 4/5. Pearson gets 4, thumbs up for how he set us up, thumbs down for his lack of alternative to going behind. He did try - but why do we hoof the ball? Why do we play into their hands? Ref gets 4 which is the best we've had for a while. West Ham get a 6. Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
Bettsj2 Posted 20 December 2014 Share Posted 20 December 2014 Hamer 6 - No chance with either goal. Nothing else to note. Simpson 6 - Solid but nothing more. Wes 4 - Shits his pants whenever he gets the ball. Prefer him to be dropped when Upson is fit. Was 6 - Solid Konch 3 - Just fvck off Cambiasso 3 - Thought he was absolute dogshit King 5 - Worked hard but not forward effect Drinky 5 - See King Schlupp 4 - Just stop playing him please Mahrez 3 - Did fvck all. Vardy 2 - Looks like he did in his first season Subs:- Ulloa 5 - His booking was ridiculous and kept him away from any battles at all Knocky 4 - Offered nothing really Nugent 7 - Must start instead of Vardy. Only player that looks threatening Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
narboroughblue Posted 20 December 2014 Share Posted 20 December 2014 Lots of 5's for me. Thought Schlupp looked better at left back, hard to comment on midfield as our defence lumped it to little old Vardy who did nothing. Was an advocate of 4 5 1 but after today I don't know what to think we don't press enough so give opposition too much time. They were a threat and other than final 10 mins we didn't look like having a shot let alone testing the keeper. Both full backs were poor, Konchesky for obvious reasons and Simpson as he looks scared and can't take a throw in. Disappointing. Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
MooseBreath Posted 20 December 2014 Share Posted 20 December 2014 Doing this on my phone the numbers only go up to five when my phone is upright. Usually I have to turn my phone sideways to give players a six or above. Didn't have to bother today. Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
SamW Posted 20 December 2014 Share Posted 20 December 2014 Manager: 6 Hamer 7 (Didn't have a lot to do but coped well. No chance with either goal) Simpson 6 (Never really troubled) Wasilewski 6 (Solid at the back, did well to deny Carroll at 0-0) Morgan 6 (An improvement on recent games) Konchesky 4 (What was he doing for the first goal? Awful pass) Mahrez 6 (Tried hard but reluctant to shoot) Cambiasso 6 (Our most consistent player in recent weeks) King 6 (Worked hard for the team again, harshly booked) Drinkwater 6 (Started brightly but faded as the game went on) Schlupp 5 (Created little. Needs a spell on the sidelines) Vardy 6 (Tried hard but looking short on confidence) SUBS:Ulloa 7 (Forced a good save out of Adrian) Nugent 7 (Kicked the team into life when he came on)Knockaert 5 (Created little) West Ham: Above average, 6 (Gifted the first goal by Konchesky, good finish from Downing but created little else) Referee: Very poor, 3 (Sodding useless. Gave everything West Ham's way, even after two of their players had taken Ulloa out) Pearson: Stay Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
theessexfox Posted 20 December 2014 Share Posted 20 December 2014 Hamer - 6 - Didn't have to do much and did nothing wrong for the goals Simpson - 6 - Decent Wes - 5 - Bullied Was - 5 - Bullied Konch - 2 - Mahrez - 6 - Flashes of brilliance, didn't release it early enough around the box King - 5 - Hardly involved Cambiasso - 5 - Hardly involved Drinkwater - 5 - Hardly involved Schlupp - 6 - Dribbled quite well, some poor choices of ball Vardy - 5 - Not his fault but bullied Pearson - 6 - Right triple change Ulloa - 6 - Looked dangerous Nugent - 6 - Made chances for himself but needed to finish them Knockaert - 6 - Some okay bits West Ham - 6 - Very effective lumpers, powerful side Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
Corky Posted 20 December 2014 Share Posted 20 December 2014 I'm assuming Cambiasso gets the customary 8? This is getting really dull now. People judge him on what they see, not you. You have a different view to people. Why is it so wrong that people rate Cambiasso highly and not Vardy? Or Drinkwater? I don't hear anyone say "well I assume Mahrez gets his usual 9". This selective rubbish on Cambiasso is tedious. If he plays well, people will say so. If he doesn't then they will say so too. Generally he's been rated quite highly compared to the rest because he's been better than the rest, albeit in a poor side. If Drinkwater kept getting higher marks for being the best of a poor set would you complain? Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
Corky Posted 20 December 2014 Share Posted 20 December 2014 Anyway: Hamer- 5 (No chance with the goals, didn't have to do much commanding of his box, kicking was ok) Simpson- 5 (Not much better than De Laet really) Wasyl- 5 (Cut out through balls, given no chance of stopping Carroll for the goal) Morgan- 5 (Similar to Wasyl, not convinced he is comfortable with Hamer) Konchesky- 2 (Wow. Appalling back pass, barely completed a forward pass and played a simple clearance across his own box under no pressure. I like him but today he was just all over the place) Mahrez- 6 (Ran a lot, cut inside without end product too often but always wanted the ball and never hid) Cambiasso- 5 (Tried to keep it simple without much success) Drinkwater- 6 (Decent effort to get forward and keep the play moving. Improvement) King- 5 (Not anonymous but not too effective either) Schlupp- 5 (Got stuck in but needs to work on distribution) Vardy- 4 (Ran around as usual, poor service but looks a shadow of last season. Frustration probably led to yellow for foul on Song) Ulloa- 4 (Ok in parts, ponderous at others) Nugent- 6 (Looked quite lively, good run with awful finish, played with more purpose than normal) Knocky- 5 (Usual energy but little end product) Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
The Doctor Posted 20 December 2014 Share Posted 20 December 2014 5's and 6's all round for being painfully average, except Paul Konchesky, who gets a 1 for lacing his boots up properly and Wasyl, who gets a 7 for being pretty much the only one to put himself into the game. Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
Guest ttfn Posted 20 December 2014 Share Posted 20 December 2014 Some really harsh ratings for Wasyl here imo. He didn't put a foot wrong all game. Ref was a total joker, again. Every time Song hit the floor it was a free kick. The Ulloa booking was obscene. And then he jumped the shark when Ulloa was grabbed by Kouyate on the edge of the penalty area and had his ankles taken out by another West Ham defender. Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
Ealing Fox Posted 20 December 2014 Share Posted 20 December 2014 Manager: 6 - He picked the team that most of us would have chosen, they seemed motivated, the substitutions made sense, but it was just one big struggle. In retrospect he should have picked Ulloa not Vardy against that defence. Hamer 6 - Didn't do anything spectacular, but never really at fault Simpson 5 - A steady game Wasilewski 6 - Just about our best player today. It would have been worse without him Morgan 5 - Better than of recent games, but not back to his best and looking a bit nervous Konchesky 3 - I guess we won't be seeing him for a while after today. A strange game with a dreadful mistake, and again kicking the ball out of play needlessly, otherwise not dreadful... Mahrez 5 - It didn't quite come off for him today Cambiasso 5 - Tried to find the right pass, but again not his day King 5 - Worked very hard and made a difference Drinkwater 5 - Very gradually getting better closer to his best, but not quite there yet Schlupp 5 - Looked much better at left back than left wing Vardy 6 - Trying to do the impossible against four defenders much bigger than him Ulloa 6 - Looked better when he came on.... Nugent 6 - ...and looked better when he came onKnockaert 5 - reasonable substitute appearance West Ham - Looked pretty good, and full of confidence. They also looked like they could step up a gear if needed Referee - Gave everything West Ham's way. I was sat with the West Ham fans and they were all laughing, thinking it was hilarious - that just about says it all... Pearson - Stay Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
Leicesterpool Posted 21 December 2014 Share Posted 21 December 2014 Danny Drinkwater looked probably the best player on the pitch never did anything wrong yesterday, most his passes found his man. Gave him a six I couldn't really give anybody higher than six, Konchesky got lowest I've ever gave a player a two, you could say he may have cost us the game. We we're doing alright before that goal went in. On West Ham as I said on the other thread, they didn't actually create that many chances as I said they didn't to get into second gear to win. Probably the easiest three points they'll get this year, but they did look good and I can see them perhaps getting at least a europa league place this. Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
Fox92 Posted 21 December 2014 Share Posted 21 December 2014 Hamer 6Simpson 6Morgan 6Was 6Konchesky 2Mahrez 6Cambiasso 6King 5Drinkwater 5Schlupp 4Vardy 5 - gave everything again but he's got no chance playing alone Referee - poor as usual. Nigel - wrong team again. Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
Recommended Posts
Archived
This topic is now archived and is closed to further replies.