Guest Col city fan Posted 19 July 2015 Posted 19 July 2015 We've got a thread for the best ever players for City, how about a top ten of the worst players you've seen in a CITY shirt (not just 'the worst players') I'll have a go: 1. Spider Kalac 2. Lee Marshall 3. Brian Carey 4. That ginger haired lad on loan from Man City (Edit....Ryan McGivern) 5. Akinbadbyi 6. Matt Mills 7. Neil Danns 8. Gabor Bori 9. Harry Kane (yes, for us he was dreadful) 10. Paul Reid Amidst many many more...
Charl91 Posted 19 July 2015 Posted 19 July 2015 Neil Danns wasn't that bad! (Matt Mills too, if we're being honest). Both solid mid-table championship players, at the least. Over-hyped and over-priced, and yeah, not fantastic, but I'm certain we've had much worse players than either of them.
NewburyFox Posted 19 July 2015 Posted 19 July 2015 Ryan McGivern has to be up there He was absolutely atrocious, and the oddest thing was that he was a Pearson signing. You'd never expect him to bring in a defender as abysmally bad at defending as McGivern.
Guest Col city fan Posted 19 July 2015 Posted 19 July 2015 Neil Danns wasn't that bad! (Matt Mills too, if we're being honest). Both solid mid-table championship players, at the least. Over-hyped and over-priced, and yeah, not fantastic, but I'm certain we've had much worse players than either of them. Look at the op buddy....players that played the worst for US... Sorry for any confusion.
jimmeh Posted 19 July 2015 Posted 19 July 2015 Danns was the first name on the team sheet for a while
bovril Posted 19 July 2015 Posted 19 July 2015 In my lifetime: Hendo / Logan rotating Neilson, Willis, Carey, McGivern, Sylla, Lewis, L. Marshall, Welsh De Vries, Hammond
bluesbrothers Posted 19 July 2015 Posted 19 July 2015 You're barking if you think Neil Danns makes the top ten worst list. He was average and never showed his Palace form for us, but no way was he awful enough to make this list.It's a tough one for me, but I'd have to have Ryan McGivern in there somewhere. He was abysmal, and it baffles me how he still keeps getting clubs, since every time I see him play, regardless of where, he's always at fault for an opposition goal. Last I saw of him, he was getting torn apart on live TV for Hibernian by Hamilton Academic, which of course added a nice relegation to his CV. He's now at Port Vale, and I assume has become a roaring success overnight.
Big_Nige Posted 19 July 2015 Posted 19 July 2015 Roman Bednar Junior Lewis Lee Marshall Peter Canero Mark De Vries Elvis Hammond Fat Rab Douglas Jason Jarrett Nathan Blake Paul Brooker Could name another 20 from the Adams/Kelly/Levein era too. Depressing bag of shite.
Rhysm Posted 19 July 2015 Posted 19 July 2015 I would say pressman was one of the worst ever in a city shirt so he would go in over kalac. Junior Lewis is a shoe in. Elvis Hammond up front and tony spearing at full back with Alan maybury. In fact if you put that whole Levein team In you probably wouldn't be far off
Wymsey Posted 19 July 2015 Posted 19 July 2015 Momo Sylla Zolt Lzatcho (Sp) Frank Sinclair Conrad Logan Steve Howie
Matt Posted 19 July 2015 Posted 19 July 2015 Momo Sylla Zolt Lzatcho (Sp) Frank Sinclair Conrad Logan Steve Howie
bovril Posted 19 July 2015 Posted 19 July 2015 Momo Sylla Zolt Lzatcho (Sp) Frank Sinclair Conrad Logan Steve Howie I can only assume you didn't see him play.
Wymsey Posted 19 July 2015 Posted 19 July 2015 I can only assume you didn't see him play. That ridiculous half-way own goal always reminds me of him.
Saxondale Posted 19 July 2015 Posted 19 July 2015 Simpson first name on the list. Then basically most of the Levein / mid 2000s lot. Oh and Jesse Lingard when we had him. He might have gone on to improve but, when he was with us, he looked like a 12 year old who had won some TV competition to get a squad number.
ScouseFox Posted 19 July 2015 Posted 19 July 2015 95% of players to play from december 03 to august 08 cba naming them all but they were, in the main, all shit
bovril Posted 19 July 2015 Posted 19 July 2015 That ridiculous half-way own goal always reminds me of him. He was a rock, would tackle anything.
Lcfc_Connor Posted 19 July 2015 Posted 19 July 2015 Zoumanna Bakayogo. I'm sure he only played once but he wasn't very good.
Guest Col city fan Posted 19 July 2015 Posted 19 July 2015 Zoumanna Bakayogo. I'm sure he only played once but he wasn't very good. Another strange signing that one.
Recommended Posts
Archived
This topic is now archived and is closed to further replies.