Nolucklcfc Posted 27 September 2024 Posted 27 September 2024 12 minutes ago, winteriscoming said: Will be embarrassing if we try again to get Potter. Think that ship has long sailed
Popular Post winteriscoming Posted 27 September 2024 Popular Post Posted 27 September 2024 Just now, Nolucklcfc said: Think that ship has long sailed Good. Imo he’s extremely overrated. 8 2
Paninistickers Posted 27 September 2024 Posted 27 September 2024 1 minute ago, winteriscoming said: Good. Imo he’s extremely overrated. He's a (very good) modern CEO rather than manager/coach. Probably could say the same about Southgate.
Pliskin Posted 27 September 2024 Posted 27 September 2024 17 minutes ago, Wasyls Pec Deck said: I can’t tell from your posts in the last few weeks, but do you not like Steve Cooper? Top of my Christmas list! Might even bring him home to meet the parents! 1
westernpark Posted 27 September 2024 Posted 27 September 2024 1 minute ago, Pliskin said: Top of my Christmas list! Might even bring him home to meet the parents! It’s good to be ambitious.
Dickov22 Posted 27 September 2024 Posted 27 September 2024 Talk of sacking him is too early. Let’s look at what he’s been handed Premier League quality (my opinion, not fact) Hermansen Justin (maybe) Faes (maybe) Skipp Ndidi (if playing DM) Ricardo Mavididi Abdul (maybe) Winks Buonanotte (possibly but Cooper ain’t picking him) It’s quite a small list isn’t it? What’s he supposed to do? Yes: Needs to pick a less defensive midfield at home Yes: Pick Abdul when playing a 39 year old left back But really, not a lot to work with. Give the bloke a chance. 1 3
Bilo Posted 27 September 2024 Posted 27 September 2024 14 minutes ago, The Doctor said: this is true, and ultimately why we've ****ed up so badly by giving it to this gremlin - when you get into the midseason sacking pattern, what you inevitably end up doing is bringing in more and more firefighters and then giving them a permanent job out of decorum when they get survival (see Kelly and Shakespeare for examples). that said, much as potter is a project manager and a builder, I would like to think that the Pontypridd Pulis hasn't managed to completely rip up the roots Enzo left in such a short time. There is a team with good passing intelligence there to unlock again which is a big part of Potters game It makes it tricky because we don't want to give the job to, as you say, a firefighter whose ceiling is scraping 16th or 17th as we'd only be in the same position again 12 months from now. The fact we're reasonably early into the season and the core of Maresca's team is in place means a manager with a possession-based philosophy and the balls to deploy the attacking players properly could be pretty transformative pretty quickly, so long as self-belief isn't completely torpedoed.
Tommy G Posted 27 September 2024 Posted 27 September 2024 22 minutes ago, Paninistickers said: He's a (very good) modern CEO rather than manager/coach. Probably could say the same about Southgate. Potter has never been a CEO of anything, he’s a coach.
Gamble92 Posted 27 September 2024 Posted 27 September 2024 4 minutes ago, Dickov22 said: Talk of sacking him is too early. Let’s look at what he’s been handed Premier League quality (my opinion, not fact) Hermansen Justin (maybe) Faes (maybe) Skipp Ndidi (if playing DM) Ricardo Mavididi Abdul (maybe) Winks Buonanotte (possibly but Cooper ain’t picking him) It’s quite a small list isn’t it? What’s he supposed to do? Yes: Needs to pick a less defensive midfield at home Yes: Pick Abdul when playing a 39 year old left back But really, not a lot to work with. Give the bloke a chance. Hermansen and Skipp I don't think anyone can doubt. Mavididi is showing the class we hoped he would. The rest you can make a case for all not being good enough for the Premier League. Or at least they're here because no other Premier League team wanted them when we were in the Championship. 1
westernpark Posted 27 September 2024 Posted 27 September 2024 5 minutes ago, Dickov22 said: Talk of sacking him is too early. Let’s look at what he’s been handed Premier League quality (my opinion, not fact) Hermansen Justin (maybe) Faes (maybe) Skipp Ndidi (if playing DM) Ricardo Mavididi Abdul (maybe) Winks Buonanotte (possibly but Cooper ain’t picking him) It’s quite a small list isn’t it? What’s he supposed to do? Yes: Needs to pick a less defensive midfield at home Yes: Pick Abdul when playing a 39 year old left back But really, not a lot to work with. Give the bloke a chance. Vestegaard, Vardy.
5waller5 Posted 27 September 2024 Posted 27 September 2024 4 minutes ago, Dickov22 said: Talk of sacking him is too early. Let’s look at what he’s been handed Premier League quality (my opinion, not fact) Hermansen Justin (maybe) Faes (maybe) Skipp Ndidi (if playing DM) Ricardo Mavididi Abdul (maybe) Winks Buonanotte (possibly but Cooper ain’t picking him) It’s quite a small list isn’t it? What’s he supposed to do? Yes: Needs to pick a less defensive midfield at home Yes: Pick Abdul when playing a 39 year old left back But really, not a lot to work with. Give the bloke a chance. You don’t think that: Vardy Eduarde Okoli Versterguard Make that list??
Legend_in_blue Posted 27 September 2024 Posted 27 September 2024 Jury is out on Edouard. He's currently a Palace reject and his performance against Walsall was worse than Nachos worst. Not a great look imo. 2
Dickov22 Posted 27 September 2024 Posted 27 September 2024 (edited) 16 minutes ago, 5waller5 said: You don’t think that: Vardy Eduarde Okoli Versterguard Make that list?? Vardy : No. brilliant goal at palace but doesn’t run channels, can’t hold it up for us. Should be sub only. Obviously a legend. Best ever. But nearly 38 Eduoard: Not after seeing him at Walsall. Hope he proves me wrong Okoli: Not yet. Awful distribution Vestergaard : No chance. Too slow Edited 27 September 2024 by Dickov22
SecretPro Posted 27 September 2024 Posted 27 September 2024 (edited) 15 minutes ago, Dickov22 said: Talk of sacking him is too early. Let’s look at what he’s been handed Premier League quality (my opinion, not fact) Hermansen Justin (maybe) Faes (maybe) Skipp Ndidi (if playing DM) Ricardo Mavididi Abdul (maybe) Winks Buonanotte (possibly but Cooper ain’t picking him) It’s quite a small list isn’t it? What’s he supposed to do? Yes: Needs to pick a less defensive midfield at home Yes: Pick Abdul when playing a 39 year old left back But really, not a lot to work with. Give the bloke a chance. Crazy take that. It's not the quality of the players, it's what you do with them, and much of what Cooper is doing with them is simply wrong. (I don't currently have the time to go into tactical detail but the positional and personel changes he's made have set us back massively). We won the league with an inferior squad in comparrison to perhaps 10 other teams that season. To suggest there isn't much Cooper can do to improve the situation is, without wanting to offend, is ridiculous. If you can tell me what his system is, what his style is, what his tactical aims are then I'd love to know. If we are going down the 'players aren't good enough route', think about how this group of Premier League players didn't have a shot on target against League 2 Walsall until the 78th minute and ask honestly, is that because our players are worse than Walsalls, or is it the way we set them up to play? It can only be the latter. Edited 27 September 2024 by SecretPro 2
Dickov22 Posted 27 September 2024 Posted 27 September 2024 Just now, SecretPro said: Crazy take that. It's not the quality of the players, it's what you do with them, and much of what Cooper is doing with them is simply wrong. (I don't currently have the time to go into tactical detail but the positional and personel changes he's made have set us back massively). We won the league with an inferior squad. To suggest there isn't much Cooper can do to improve the situation is, without wanting to offend, is ridiculous. If you can tell me what his system is, what his style is, what his tactical aims are then I'd love to know. If we are going down the 'players aren't good enough route', think about how this group of Premier League players didn't have a shot on target against League 2 Walsall until the 78th minute and ask honestly, is that because our players are worse than Walsalls, or is it the way we set them up to play? It can only be the latter. Totally agree. We need to see his style of play. But it’s been 5 league games. Not sure anyone could do better with this lot. I was heavily critical of his Walsall first 11. Luke Thomas is not a footballer. Soumare can’t be arsed to be here so why pick him. But… he kept Forest up with a similar ability squad. I just think we should give him more time. 1
Dickov22 Posted 27 September 2024 Posted 27 September 2024 13 minutes ago, westernpark said: Vestegaard, Vardy. Neither (sorry Jamie V)
Muzzy_no7 Posted 27 September 2024 Posted 27 September 2024 8 minutes ago, Dickov22 said: Talk of sacking him is too early. Let’s look at what he’s been handed Premier League quality (my opinion, not fact) Hermansen Justin (maybe) Faes (maybe) Skipp Ndidi (if playing DM) Ricardo Mavididi Abdul (maybe) Winks Buonanotte (possibly but Cooper ain’t picking him) It’s quite a small list isn’t it? What’s he supposed to do? Yes: Needs to pick a less defensive midfield at home Yes: Pick Abdul when playing a 39 year old left back But really, not a lot to work with. Give the bloke a chance. Whilst I kinda get where you’re coming from I look at differently. For me, I find it easier to list clubs who out and out have better squads than us: City, Liverpool, Arsenal, Villa, Chelsea, Spurs, United, Brighton, Newcastle, West Ham, Forest?, Fulham?, Brentford?, B’mouth? -ones in question marks we are either close or you could make a case we match in terms of squads. I would certainly say we have a better squad than Ipswich, Southampton, Wolves, Everton and even Palace
Pliskin Posted 27 September 2024 Posted 27 September 2024 (edited) 14 minutes ago, Dickov22 said: Vardy : No. brilliant goal at palace but doesn’t run channels, can’t hold it up for us. Should be sub only. Obviously a legend. Best ever. But nearly 38 Eduoard: Not after seeing him at Walsall. Hope he proves me wrong Okoli: Not yet. Awful distribution Vestergaard : No chance. Too slow So you’ve asked everyone to give Cooper a chance, but yourself have written off 4 players? Interesting. Edited 27 September 2024 by Pliskin 1
Pliskin Posted 27 September 2024 Posted 27 September 2024 29 minutes ago, Dickov22 said: Talk of sacking him is too early. Let’s look at what he’s been handed Premier League quality (my opinion, not fact) Hermansen Justin (maybe) Faes (maybe) Skipp Ndidi (if playing DM) Ricardo Mavididi Abdul (maybe) Winks Buonanotte (possibly but Cooper ain’t picking him) It’s quite a small list isn’t it? What’s he supposed to do? Yes: Needs to pick a less defensive midfield at home Yes: Pick Abdul when playing a 39 year old left back But really, not a lot to work with. Give the bloke a chance. I’m sorry, but when you actively chose not to attack a 39 year old right footed winger playing at left back, and then say you had to bring your best player off because I’ve was tired, with two minutes left to play, and then say it was a like for like swap, a left footed inverted winger for a right? Your chances run out very quickly….. The long and short of is Cooper hasn’t a clue what he is doing with this squad, he’s already displayed this, so what is the point in carrying on? It will simply go from bad to worse whilst Cooper stays, and he will ultimately get the sack, it’s just a case of when, and hopefully not when it’s too late. And, this squad is actually a lot better than people think, that’s the one positive to take so far. 4
westernpark Posted 27 September 2024 Posted 27 September 2024 14 minutes ago, Dickov22 said: Neither (sorry Jamie V) Have to disagree but that’s fair enough with your assessment. Personally think Vestegaard is more quantifiable as Prem quality than the goat.
Vowels Posted 27 September 2024 Posted 27 September 2024 From a barrel maker to a pottery wheel hogger. You guys ! Get someone like Harry Manager or Tommy Tactician or Marcelo Motivator or Ivan Innovator.
gazzaa2 Posted 27 September 2024 Posted 27 September 2024 He has to go, he's not up to it at this level and he hasn't got the momentum of the fanbase behind him like he had at Forest. October international break is the time to source a replacement. Moyes would be ideal.
adam95581 Posted 27 September 2024 Posted 27 September 2024 50 minutes ago, Dickov22 said: Vardy : No. brilliant goal at palace but doesn’t run channels, can’t hold it up for us. Should be sub only. Obviously a legend. Best ever. But nearly 38 Eduoard: Not after seeing him at Walsall. Hope he proves me wrong Okoli: Not yet. Awful distribution Vestergaard : No chance. Too slow Okoli has been our best defender this season but you’ve got Faes and Justin in there…?
Guest Posted 27 September 2024 Posted 27 September 2024 14 minutes ago, Dickov22 said: Talk of sacking him is too early. Let’s look at what he’s been handed Premier League quality (my opinion, not fact) Hermansen Justin (maybe) Faes (maybe) Skipp Ndidi (if playing DM) Ricardo Mavididi Abdul (maybe) Winks Buonanotte (possibly but Cooper ain’t picking him) It’s quite a small list isn’t it? What’s he supposed to do? Yes: Needs to pick a less defensive midfield at home Yes: Pick Abdul when playing a 39 year old left back But really, not a lot to work with. Give the bloke a chance. Maybe you're right but if that is the case, what is going to change with time? The squad isn't going to be any different until January and possibly not even then, and if the problem is that the players aren't up to standard then surely you would want to get a better coach than Steve Cooper to get them playing above their level. 1
Dickov22 Posted 27 September 2024 Posted 27 September 2024 1 hour ago, Pliskin said: So you’ve asked everyone to give Cooper a chance, but yourself have written off 4 players? Interesting. Haven’t asked anyone to do anything. Just said in my opinion, he doesn’t have a huge amount of Premier League standard players.
Recommended Posts