urban fox Posted 18 December 2019 Posted 18 December 2019 There have been recent threads asking if Vardy is World class, and there is an excellent case to be made for Ricardo to be put into that bracket too. For what its worth, on current form I would probably put them both into that bracket. I know there is an argument that to be called truly world class, a player has to have done it at that level, but using that yardstick then, Messi is not world class as he has never managed to turn it on at a world cup. Anyway, it got me to thinking, whilst we have had some truly gifted players over the years, how many have we had that could we could claim were the best of the best in their time. I can actually think of only three (Mancini was undoubtedly world class in his prime but we only had him for a handful of games at the end of his playing career so I do not count him) Banks Shilton Lineker When you consider that we potentially have two in our current side think on that. I am sure there are others who some would consider world class and would be interested to hear others opinions
Jimothy Posted 18 December 2019 Posted 18 December 2019 Kante surely comes into that bracket. Would get in any team in the world, and has done for a few years now, including major international tournaments.
Fosse93 Posted 18 December 2019 Posted 18 December 2019 Kante, Vardy, Mahrez and Ricardo are all 'world class' for me. Pretty sure Soyuncu, Ndidi, Maddison and Tielemans will get there as well. Exciting times!
Guest An Sionnach Posted 18 December 2019 Posted 18 December 2019 9 minutes ago, urban fox said: There have been recent threads asking if Vardy is World class, and there is an excellent case to be made for Ricardo to be put into that bracket too. For what its worth, on current form I would probably put them both into that bracket. I know there is an argument that to be called truly world class, a player has to have done it at that level, but using that yardstick then, Messi is not world class as he has never managed to turn it on at a world cup. Anyway, it got me to thinking, whilst we have had some truly gifted players over the years, how many have we had that could we could claim were the best of the best in their time. I can actually think of only three (Mancini was undoubtedly world class in his prime but we only had him for a handful of games at the end of his playing career so I do not count him) Banks Shilton Lineker When you consider that we potentially have two in our current side think on that. I am sure there are others who some would consider world class and would be interested to hear others opinions International football is no yardstick to judge whether a player is world class. Most of it is awful and can even reduce a genius like Messi to mundanity. Consistent brilliance in the Champions League is the best way of telling. The South American championship is of a lower standard but still top class.
bmt Posted 18 December 2019 Posted 18 December 2019 I think Ricardo is amazing but think it's way too soon to say he is World Class, he's only played twice for Portugal this year and 7 times in total. I don't think that's the only yardstick to measure it on but it seems fair in his case and a lot of Leicester fans weren't won over for parts of last season, needs to do it a bit longer for me. I think Ndidi is a better shout.
bmt Posted 18 December 2019 Posted 18 December 2019 For me recent players that are close, and ignoring Cambiasso as he wasn't when he played for us: - Kante - Vardy - Ndidi - Mahrez Honestly think Soyuncu isn't a million miles off but need to judge that at the end of the season. Hopefully him, Ricardo, and maybe Maddison, Tielemans and Chilwell will break into that.
TiffToff88 Posted 18 December 2019 Posted 18 December 2019 2 minutes ago, HighPeakFox said: Treer I give it 3 days before Treer starts a "World Class Leicester Players" thread
SemperEadem Posted 18 December 2019 Posted 18 December 2019 Banks, Shilton, Lineker, Vardy, Cambiasso, Mahrez, Kante and Ricardo
RumbleFox Posted 18 December 2019 Posted 18 December 2019 Kante (for me the best player in his position in the world and the best player we've ever had) Vardy Ricardo Mahrez Lineker Shilton Banks Cambiasso Frank Sinclair x
urban fox Posted 18 December 2019 Author Posted 18 December 2019 OOPS forgot Kante. Definitely is on the list And I agree that we also have a few (wilf, madders soyuncu) that could make it into that bracket too if they continue to develop at their current rates. Not sure about Mahrez, definitely a class act but inconsistent
Dorkingfox Posted 18 December 2019 Posted 18 December 2019 7 minutes ago, An Sionnach said: International football is no yardstick to judge whether a player is world class. Most of it is awful and can even reduce a genius like Messi to mundanity. Consistent brilliance in the Champions League is the best way of telling. The South American championship is of a lower standard but still top class. Frank McLintock Esteban Cambiasso Players near WC in their time. David Gibson Stan Colleymore Keith Weller Auther Rowley Don Revie Dereck Hines Colin Appleton David Nish Frank Worthington Steve Whitworth
theessexfox Posted 18 December 2019 Posted 18 December 2019 14 minutes ago, bmt said: I think Ricardo is amazing but think it's way too soon to say he is World Class, he's only played twice for Portugal this year and 7 times in total. I don't think that's the only yardstick to measure it on but it seems fair in his case and a lot of Leicester fans weren't won over for parts of last season, needs to do it a bit longer for me. I think Ndidi is a better shout. He was fans and players' player of the year last year, I think it's fair to say fans were won over for the last 3/4 of the season. He is incredible and surely has to be a Portugal regular from now on
Finnegan Posted 18 December 2019 Posted 18 December 2019 That I've seen with my own eyes that were truly world class whilst they were here: Riyad, Ngolo, Vardy, probably Ricardo.
sylofox Posted 18 December 2019 Posted 18 December 2019 2 minutes ago, Finnegan said: That I've seen with my own eyes that were truly world class whilst they were here: Riyad, Ngolo, Mahrez, probably Ricardo. Riyad and Mahrez?
Guest An Sionnach Posted 18 December 2019 Posted 18 December 2019 6 minutes ago, Dorkingfox said: Frank McLintock Esteban Cambiasso Players near WC in their time. David Gibson Stan Colleymore Keith Weller Auther Rowley Don Revie Dereck Hines Colin Appleton David Nish Frank Worthington Steve Whitworth Some of these look a bit dodgy but in the early sixties we had Banks, McLintock,Appleton and Gibson of the very highest class. Just a pity that Spurs were even better.
bmt Posted 18 December 2019 Posted 18 December 2019 13 minutes ago, theessexfox said: He was fans and players' player of the year last year, I think it's fair to say fans were won over for the last 3/4 of the season. He is incredible and surely has to be a Portugal regular from now on He was still complained about regularly early doors, which was more my point. I know his form afterwards was very good. I'm not disagreeing with anything you've said, but don't think that makes him world class. For me world class are players that should be considered for World XI squads, not necessarily starting but in the extended squad.
Nick Posted 18 December 2019 Posted 18 December 2019 I scrolled down thins thread at a fair rate but did I really see Wilfred Ndidi’s name mentioned?
Finnegan Posted 18 December 2019 Posted 18 December 2019 15 minutes ago, sylofox said: Riyad and Mahrez? Me being a muppet. Was talking to someone about Riyad whilst typing. So good I named him twice. I did mean Vards however.
filbertway Posted 18 December 2019 Posted 18 December 2019 Kanté Ricardo I'd say Vardy and Mahrez probably fall in the bracket below. Capable of 10/10 performances but can often dish out ineffective performances. Could be down to the fact they're attacking players and less chance to have an influence on every game. Kante and Ricardo are 8/10 every game at least. Always standout players, that for me is world class.
Recommended Posts
Archived
This topic is now archived and is closed to further replies.