filbertway Posted 9 October 2022 Posted 9 October 2022 Just now, Manley Farrington-Brown said: You sound like you're interviewing him for a job. Im trying removing my bias from the questions
lcfc sheff Posted 9 October 2022 Posted 9 October 2022 1 hour ago, filbertway said: 99% of his game was good, but clearly a few errors have led to goals. But he's not the only one, they didn't lead directly to goals. There was plenty of opportunity for multiple players to prevent goals Team just didn’t play the second half, think we thought we’d already won it the way we were playing
cropstonfox Posted 9 October 2022 Posted 9 October 2022 James Justin costs at least one goal per game so he is not alone. 1
Guest Bob Hazels shorts Posted 9 October 2022 Posted 9 October 2022 1 hour ago, filbertway said: I thought you were setting up a joke with your first line. Can you explain what you mean by this? "You're as good as your last game?" How would you use this information to inform your decision making? Didn't think it needed explaining but i'll try if you're struggling It was in response to an excitable..... 'Totally written off after a month. Amazing'. The point being he was ok against a very poor Forest side but wasn't great against Bournemouth. Seems reasonable to judge a player on their last game.. He hasn't been written off but are you not allowed to point this out without fear of offending? He'll come good hopefully but he wasn't yesterday
Guest Basildon Fox Posted 10 October 2022 Posted 10 October 2022 14 hours ago, Bob Hazels shorts said: Didn't think it needed explaining but i'll try if you're struggling It was in response to an excitable..... 'Totally written off after a month. Amazing'. The point being he was ok against a very poor Forest side but wasn't great against Bournemouth. Seems reasonable to judge a player on their last game.. He hasn't been written off but are you not allowed to point this out without fear of offending? He'll come good hopefully but he wasn't yesterday Of course you can look at it from another point of view. What happens when we play better teams when this carthorse plays like he did against Bournemouth? I see posts that we shouldn't write him off yet, there is a good player there blah blah. I have yet to see it. Slow, ponderous and positioning woeful. Going to be a very long season.
Gazza M Posted 10 October 2022 Posted 10 October 2022 Is he playing on his weaker side to accommodate Evans?
Deeg67 Posted 10 October 2022 Posted 10 October 2022 21 hours ago, StanSP said: Totally written off after a month. Amazing. It's not writing a player off to comment on how he played (badly, in this case) in one match. 1
phoneticerror Posted 10 October 2022 Posted 10 October 2022 (edited) 16 hours ago, lcfc sheff said: Team just didn’t play the second half, think we thought we’d already won it the way we were playing Seems to be a regular occurrence. The amount of times we’ve conceded and lost matches after substitutions and tactic changes is astounding. Every other club in the league just have to press second half, especially the final 20 minutes and they can fold us like tissue paper. I’ve not watched back, but from where I was sat I’d have thought Amartey was more at fault than Faes? That’s another regular bloody occurrence. Edited 10 October 2022 by phoneticerror 1
Guest Basildon Fox Posted 10 October 2022 Posted 10 October 2022 So we have paid £15m for a Soyuncu alike. What was the point? Why not play Soyuncu instead if he is no better? Unbelievable! Absolute waste of money and we could have used the £15m to get rid of the manager and his haphazard coaching team instead.
Tommy Fresh Posted 10 October 2022 Posted 10 October 2022 Weird that the folk occupying this thread slagging him off aren't doing the same with Evans 2
StanSP Posted 10 October 2022 Posted 10 October 2022 6 minutes ago, Tommy Fresh said: Weird that the folk occupying this thread slagging him off aren't doing the same with Evans Just watched the highlights again. For Bournemouth's 2nd goal, he starts running towards other players for no apparent reason. If he holds his position, Christie doesn't have an easy chance to tap in. Total lapse in discipline and concentration. The other Bournemouth player he ran towards, was already covered. I don't get where he was running to. 1
Guest Basildon Fox Posted 10 October 2022 Posted 10 October 2022 15 minutes ago, Tommy Fresh said: Weird that the folk occupying this thread slagging him off aren't doing the same with Evans Evans can get to **** too. is that better? Still doesn't change the fact he has been absolute shite so far.
Tommy Fresh Posted 10 October 2022 Posted 10 October 2022 (edited) 2 minutes ago, Zaphod Beeblebrox said: Evans can get to **** too. is that better? Still doesn't change the fact he has been absolute shite so far. Faes hasn't been shite the entire time has he though, I'd also like people to be fair and not criticise one player when others are as culpable. Evans for the most part seems to get off very lightly. Edited 10 October 2022 by Tommy Fresh
Guest Basildon Fox Posted 10 October 2022 Posted 10 October 2022 (edited) 2 minutes ago, Tommy Fresh said: Faes hasn't been shite the entire time has he though, I'd also like people to be fair and not criticise one player when others are as culpable Yes he has. He has looked out of his depth against Spurs as soon as Son came on (like the rest of the defence) and was lucky not to gift Forest 2 goals on Monday. Both of the goals were his fault on Saturday. You can argue with me about it if you want but it will not change the facts. I am as fair as anyone else but he is not good enough and repeat again, we already have a similar player not even making the squad in Soyuncu. What was the point in buying him? Edited 10 October 2022 by Zaphod Beeblebrox
Tommy Fresh Posted 10 October 2022 Posted 10 October 2022 1 minute ago, Zaphod Beeblebrox said: Yes he has. He has looked out of his depth against Spurs as soon as Son came on (like the rest of the defence) and was lucky not to gift Forest 2 goals on Monday. Both of the goals were his fault on Saturday. You can argue with me about it if you want but it will not change the facts. I am as fair as anyone else but he is not good enough and repeat again, we already have a similar player not even making the squad in Soyuncu. What was the point in buying him? I'd rather we were playing Soyuncu as well, but Rodgers is to proud to do so. Not denying he hasn't made mistakes but you're making out like he's a competition winner, if you were as fair as anyone you'd of remarked (prior to it being pointed out) on how poor the very experienced Evans has been rather than just the lad signed from abroad.
Matt_Lcfc Posted 10 October 2022 Posted 10 October 2022 (edited) I think this lad will be fine. He undoubtedly had a poor game on Saturday, but I see something in him, cannot see him setting the world alight, but I reckon that he will be solid enough. I agree with the sentiment though. I doubt he’ll be any better than Soyuncu which proposes the question as to why Rodgers has isolated him. It’s actually farcical when you think about him. I have no doubt that Soyuncu will leave and join a side like Atletico Madrid / Inter and prove himself. Edited 10 October 2022 by Matt_Lcfc
Clarkey123 Posted 10 October 2022 Posted 10 October 2022 I still think it’s amazing how Brendan was allowed to spunk £15 mil on vestergaard and not have him in the squad whilst simultaneously diminishing any resale value Cags has. Cags must have literally told him to **** off in training.
Guest Col city fan Posted 10 October 2022 Posted 10 October 2022 (edited) 3 hours ago, Tommy Fresh said: Weird that the folk occupying this thread slagging him off aren't doing the same with Evans Gotta agree with you this time TF Evans is miles past his best and is as accountable as anyone else for our rank defensive displays. He must have been a really good defender in his prime but alas, his time has come and gone. Isnt this another error of judgement on the part of the club though? Having to rely so heavily on Evans to play so often? Edited 10 October 2022 by Col city fan
Tommy Fresh Posted 10 October 2022 Posted 10 October 2022 1 hour ago, Col city fan said: Gotta agree with you this time TF Evans is miles past his best and is as accountable as anyone else for our rank defensive displays. He must have been a really good defender in his prime but alas, his time has come and gone. Isnt this another error of judgement on the part of the club though? Having to rely so heavily on Evans to play so often? You'd imagine Fofana was possibly the succession plan, albeit not a very good one as it was obvious he wouldn't be here that long.
Kierzz Posted 11 October 2022 Posted 11 October 2022 3 minutes ago, StanSP said: From the Forest game. From Bournemouth game: Tackles aren't necessarily a good attribute for a CB as it can highlight that they had to dive in when out of position. Maldini averaged 0.5 tackles a game over his career and he wasn't bad....that's almost half his season average (19) in one game! 1
StanSP Posted 11 October 2022 Posted 11 October 2022 Just now, Kierzz said: Tackles aren't necessarily a good attribute for a CB as it can highlight that they had to dive in when out of position. Maldini averaged 0.5 tackles a game over his career and he wasn't bad....that's almost half his season average (19) in one game! I see what you mean, but tackling being a good trait for a defender is never a bad thing. It could also mean a player us running towards them and they get a tackle in, therefore stopping them go past. Maldini had the likes of Gattuso and Seedorf ahead of him, and Nesta and Cafu next to him!! 1
Happy Fox Posted 14 October 2022 Posted 14 October 2022 We haven’t had a Percy player article in a while maybe he’s gets full scoop for Rodgers sacking tomorrow night hopefully!
when_you're_smiling Posted 14 October 2022 Posted 14 October 2022 He’s in The Guardian too. https://www.theguardian.com/football/2022/oct/14/leicester-wout-faes-chelsea-david-luiz-english-football
Recommended Posts