foxfanazer Posted 16 August 2012 Posted 16 August 2012 I know Bergkamp was an absolute legend but would you class him as a clinical striker. In the time it's taken me to write this I've come to the conclusion that he was
Zingari Posted 16 August 2012 Posted 16 August 2012 Brazilian star Sócrates is a doctor of medicine, how fookin clinical is that ?
Fox92 Posted 16 August 2012 Posted 16 August 2012 Last 20 years is tough, but Ruud van Nistelrooy was one of the first names in my head. I love Dennis Bergkamp, I think he's the best Premier League player ever, but I don't think of him as a clinical finisher. He's more of a magician.
Finnegan Posted 16 August 2012 Posted 16 August 2012 Ruud. Every time. Wasn't ever his biggest fan but the guy had no strength, no real pace, didn't have a great leap. Just always in the right place and a ruthless finisher. Bit like Superpippo (one of my favourite players ever) really. He had an okay turn of pace when he was younger but no great touch or technique and forever in offside or near offside positions but a ghost off the ball and a reliable finisher.
Fox92 Posted 16 August 2012 Posted 16 August 2012 Always remember Van Nistelrooy's hat trick against us in 2003/04, always thought his second was immense; http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=SzKi_n54Z2Y
sdb Posted 16 August 2012 Posted 16 August 2012 RVP first name that came to mind. Romario I guess, Fowler, Shearer, Batistuta, Shevchenko...Emile Always remember Van Nistelrooy's hat trick against us in 2003/04, always thought his second was immense; http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=SzKi_n54Z2Y Oh Frank!
Guest ttfn Posted 16 August 2012 Posted 16 August 2012 van Nistelrooy is my favourite player of the Premier League era, quite possibly just because of his finishing. He also had a great first touch and was unrivaled with his back to goal but his finishing was a class above. Fowler, Shearer, Romario and Owen were all pretty lethal in their day too.
Guest ttfn Posted 16 August 2012 Posted 16 August 2012 Brazilian star Sócrates is a doctor of medicine, how fookin clinical is that ? I can't believe that two people on this thread thought of that!
RobHawk Posted 16 August 2012 Posted 16 August 2012 Tony Cottee!! New where the back of the net was!! Fastest man over 5 yards!!!
Manwell Pablo Posted 16 August 2012 Posted 16 August 2012 Most Clinical Striker ever? Easy, Kenny Deuchar, He was a doctor
fleckneymike Posted 16 August 2012 Posted 16 August 2012 I know I'm repeating myself but NINE HUNDRED AND TWENTY NINE GOALS
Tielemans63 Posted 16 August 2012 Posted 16 August 2012 The great Ferenc Puskas must be up there. HiS record (off the top of my head like). Club record APPS GLS Kispest 177 (187) Budapest Honvéd 181 (187) Real Madrid 262 (242) Total 620 (616) International record Hungary 85 (84) And yes, I was going to post the same FleckneyMike, Romario was unbelievable.
fleckneymike Posted 16 August 2012 Posted 16 August 2012 The great Ferenc Puskas must be up there. HiS record (off the top of my head like). Club record APPS GLS Kispest 177 (187) Budapest Honvéd 181 (187) Real Madrid 262 (242) Total 620 (616) International record Hungary 85 (84) And yes, I was going to post the same FleckneyMike, Romario was unbelievable. If we could go back slightly further then the answer can only be Gerd Muller "Der Bomber" in terms of pure finishing. No one can touch him.
Zingari Posted 16 August 2012 Posted 16 August 2012 Some of these players are ok , but all they do is score goals . Messi and even Lineker was quite masterful in his day
Trav Le Bleu Posted 16 August 2012 Posted 16 August 2012 Jimmy Floyd Hasselbaink. He played on too long and spoiled not only his stats, but how younger people remember him (some geezer who dad said used to be good, but now can't even get to the halway line without use of his buspass.)
Fox92 Posted 16 August 2012 Posted 16 August 2012 251 in 274 for Brian Clough. Wow, fantastic record.
shen Posted 16 August 2012 Posted 16 August 2012 Ruud. Every time. Wasn't ever his biggest fan but the guy had no strength, no real pace, didn't have a great leap. Just always in the right place and a ruthless finisher. That's a bit harsh
fleckneymike Posted 16 August 2012 Posted 16 August 2012 The majority of the Prem players suggested here aren't even close to being the best finishers, they may be good forwards but not finishers. My answer remains Romario but here are some other notable omissions from the lists compiled so far for the last 20 years Jardel had an unbelievable 9 seasons before his fitness completely went. From 96 to 2002 (7 seasons) alone he scored 267 goals in just 274 games. No one has mentioned Crespo either, he was a phenomenal penalty area player. Hugo Sanchez has also been overlooked. Most criminally (though he hung his boots up in 95) is Marco Van Basten
Finnegan Posted 16 August 2012 Posted 16 August 2012 I'm sorry but Ruud van Nistelrooy is absolutely, definitely one of the best finishers of all time. You can't compare different generations of football and expect the stats to be equally impressive, they just aren't. Nor can you overlook the fact that Romario spent a large part of his playing career in weaker leagues in Brazil, the States, etc. Even Jardel spent a majority of his career in a Portuguese league system where most teams were of no match at all for Porto and Sporting or for his own ability. That's not to suggest that they weren't great players, clearly Romario was one of the best of all time, but it does make the point that goal scoring statistics alone do not qualify someone as a good finisher. Obviously they're a very good indicator but there's far more to it than just numbers. Otherwise some fifteen year old Sunday players who probably bag a hattrick every week against fat pubescent "defenders" would be among the greatest strikers of all time. Anyone who's ever seen RVN play knows just how emphatically accurate and unforgiving he was when chances came his way and how miraculously he'd find space to carve them out. Absolutely phenomenal.
Basingstoke Fox Posted 16 August 2012 Posted 16 August 2012 I never saw much of RVN to be honest but my favourite striker / finisher in the premier league is Thierry Henry. Truly majestic when in his prime.
Recommended Posts
Archived
This topic is now archived and is closed to further replies.