Benjaldinho Posted 1 September 2012 Posted 1 September 2012 Take your allegiances with the foxes out of the equation....which do you think is the better player? ! I'm a big fan of Tom Ince as a player.He's got talent, flair and works hard....however that being said I can't say he's out and out better than Marshall. Ben's a quality player with loads of potential. Think I prefer Marshall .. the boy never seems to put a foot wrong!! Your guys opinions......
Jimmy Posted 1 September 2012 Posted 1 September 2012 Tom Ince is the more hyped because of his dad and he's a left winger which England doesn't produce many of, I'd have Ince here in a second but I'd take Marshall over him
Mark_w Posted 1 September 2012 Posted 1 September 2012 Couldn't give a fair opinion, we don't see Ince week in week out, and we've only been watching Marshall for half a season to be fair.
Benjaldinho Posted 1 September 2012 Author Posted 1 September 2012 So that being said could Future England team line up with Marshall down the right and Ince on the left SenIors I mean not u21
ADK Posted 1 September 2012 Posted 1 September 2012 Ince is alot better than Marshall imo although it is abit unfair as Ince looks like he could play at alot higher than this level.
m00nie Posted 1 September 2012 Posted 1 September 2012 Take your allegiances with the foxes out of the equation....which do you think is the better player? ! I'm a big fan of Tom Ince as a player.He's got talent, flair and works hard....however that being said I can't say he's out and out better than Marshall. Ben's a quality player with loads of potential. Think I prefer Marshall .. the boy never seems to put a foot wrong!! Your guys opinions...... BM put some poor corners in today... also few times it looked like we could whip a ball out wide for him but he took to long getting forward so think hes still got a bit of room for improvement not really seen much of TI before today so couldnt really pick , somehow fluked him into my dream team and he has notched up quite a few points so far so he must be doing something though..
Bert Posted 1 September 2012 Posted 1 September 2012 What ince has over Marshall is the one thing defenders hate, pace. Otherwise two fantastic young prospects.
foxesfan1989 Posted 1 September 2012 Posted 1 September 2012 Ince gets more goals, and gets more headlines because of who his dad is. He is probably ahead because of the goals, but both have a big future in the Prem.
Haydos Posted 1 September 2012 Posted 1 September 2012 Haven't seen too much of Ince. Looked like being able to come up with something special today though. Always involved, in the right places at the right time, pacey, skillful. Think Ince would probably edge it but I think Marshall has a bright future here as well.
cc_star Posted 1 September 2012 Posted 1 September 2012 What ince has over Marshall is the one thing defenders hate, pace. Otherwise two fantastic young prospects. Certainly does. On the flip side, how's his 30 yard screamers
Kitchandro Posted 1 September 2012 Posted 1 September 2012 On todays evidence , it would be Marshall. They're two very different wingers, Ince has pace and will skin players, whereas Marshall's a bit more Beckham/Guppy-esque and relies on his crossing and when he gets the chance, shooting. I just think if you've got the ability to dribble past players or do them for pace it really can make a match-winning difference (as long as you've got an end product of course). So normally, Ince is the kind of winger I prefer in this league.
ADK Posted 1 September 2012 Posted 1 September 2012 Ince is the best single player in the championship imo. Very impressed.
Guest Bilo Posted 1 September 2012 Posted 1 September 2012 On today's evidence, Marshall. Ince could barely get a look in at times and was well and truly countered by Moore. Marshall's trickery and crossing terrified Blackpool today and he deserved his goal. However, you have to judge them over a much longer period. There will equally be games where Ince rips defences to shreds and Marshall is ineffective, they're both young after all and it's a long old season.
Tielemans63 Posted 1 September 2012 Posted 1 September 2012 Ince impressed me today, I thought his movement was excellent and even though we mostly handled him quite well he was pulling the defence here and there as we tried to track him. Let's be honest, he got in behind us 3 or 4 times and should've nailed that chance before half time. Blackpool really seemed to fear Ben and I was surprised by how much they stood off him. I think he'll be a Prem player by next season - hopefully with us. I think Ince will be too. They're both excellent prospects - there's not much in it from what I've seen.
Captain... Posted 1 September 2012 Posted 1 September 2012 Just watched the highlights, Ince is much faster, but in the first half Marshall was immense, I can see Ince developing to be like Lloyd Dyer on this performance, fast attacking but wasteful in front of goal, probably better than Dyer, maybe Shaun Wright Phillips, Marshall will be more of a Giggs, he has a lot more on his game than pace.
Libertine Dream Posted 1 September 2012 Posted 1 September 2012 Rather just have both. Theyre different players, Ince is quick whereas Marshall has to be a little more skilful to get past a man. Marshall strikes a ball slightly better but everyones scared of Ince. Both will be subject to PL attention in January
Miquel The Work Geordie Posted 2 September 2012 Posted 2 September 2012 Ince is the best single player in the championship imo. Behave, he's good but not the best in the league.
Believe! Posted 2 September 2012 Posted 2 September 2012 Ince is dyer with an end product and two feet Marshall is gallagher with the ability to put a foot in, as well as offer a more direct approach.
AKCJ Posted 2 September 2012 Posted 2 September 2012 Ince is dyer with an end product and two feet Marshall is gallagher with the ability to put a foot in, as well as offer a more direct approach. Nail on head.
Callabinho Posted 2 September 2012 Posted 2 September 2012 Tom has pace to burn, and likes a step over, Ben likes to whip a ball in at the first opportunity! Over time Ben will become the better player!
ThurnbyLodgeFox Posted 2 September 2012 Posted 2 September 2012 Marshall all day long, for the face he's our player
DANGEROUS TIGER Posted 2 September 2012 Posted 2 September 2012 I couldn't pick one above the other. Both got quality.
Recommended Posts
Archived
This topic is now archived and is closed to further replies.