The People's Hero Posted 11 July 2019 Posted 11 July 2019 1 minute ago, Kopic said: There goes Roy's match fee. Wonder if they'll suspend him for the final. I can understand his reaction, but it was a bit disgusting. Hope no young players go on to emulate it. If you're given, you're out (review aside).
David Guiza Posted 11 July 2019 Posted 11 July 2019 Wow. Getting wrongfully dimissed when on 85 and in sublime form in a World Cup semi-final has got to be awful to take.
Nick Posted 11 July 2019 Posted 11 July 2019 Just now, UniFox21 said: Oh **** off was that given The hesitation of the umpire too it all felt wrong..... Bloody Barstow taking up the review!
The People's Hero Posted 11 July 2019 Posted 11 July 2019 Reckon Bairstow might have gone for a long walk round the boundary a few times when Roy was on his way back!
yorkie1999 Posted 11 July 2019 Posted 11 July 2019 I think they need to sort out var in the cricket as well! 70 year old deaf bloke gives out a snick.
UniFox21 Posted 11 July 2019 Posted 11 July 2019 4 minutes ago, Swan Lesta said: The hesitation of the umpire too it all felt wrong..... Bloody Barstow taking up the review! The hesitation from the umpire said it all, if he isn't convinced he should either be given the option to review or not give it.
RowlattsFox Posted 11 July 2019 Posted 11 July 2019 Don't blame Roy reaction at all, it wasn't even close. Should just be a fine but even that would be harsh considering how bad the decision was. Yes Bairstow wasted a review but that doesn't excuse terrible umpiring. Shows if you appeal for anything there's a chance it could go your way.
Guest Manini Posted 11 July 2019 Posted 11 July 2019 Rubbish, no way Roy should be left out of the final, he’s the in form man. He’s a professional sportsman who’s just been totally done over by the umpire and his batting partner? It’s not a toss up down the Park it’s the pinnacle of sport. We have this weird mentality of “honour” and “ethics” around our national sports teams and I bet it’s cost us no end of international success in the past. It’s not like he’s cheated is it? He’s just had a barney after being given out.
Kopic Posted 11 July 2019 Posted 11 July 2019 4 minutes ago, Manini said: Rubbish, no way Roy should be left out of the final, he’s the in form man. He’s a professional sportsman who’s just been totally done over by the umpire and his batting partner? It’s not a toss up down the Park it’s the pinnacle of sport. We have this weird mentality of “honour” and “ethics” around our national sports teams and I bet it’s cost us no end of international success in the past. It’s not like he’s cheated is it? He’s just had a barney after being given out. Who's suggested dropping him? I took @The People's Hero's comment as referring to the ICC suspending him, which can and does happen for such actions, other than that I havent seen anything that could be construed as wanting England to drop him.
Guest Manini Posted 11 July 2019 Posted 11 July 2019 9 minutes ago, Kopic said: Who's suggested dropping him? I took @The People's Hero's comment as referring to the ICC suspending him, which can and does happen for such actions, other than that I havent seen anything that could be construed as wanting England to drop him. Yeah sorry I took it a bit out of context, but on the BBC live feed there’s been a couple of texts come in suggesting to drop him as it’s unbefitting of the shirt (whatever that means) - more of a general rant in that case rather than referencing anybody in particular.
TheSomersetFox Posted 11 July 2019 Posted 11 July 2019 Dire bit of umpiring. Bit of common sense if you’re not sure it’s out would surely have been giving it not out as the Aussies have the option of a review if they’re certain it’s gone. Ultimately the blame has to lie with that daft Bairstow review though. Looking like it wont cost us at all however. Supreme performance
AKCJ Posted 11 July 2019 Posted 11 July 2019 2 minutes ago, Kopic said: Who's suggested dropping him? I took @The People's Hero's comment as referring to the ICC suspending him, which can and does happen for such actions, other than that I havent seen anything that could be construed as wanting England to drop him. I wouldn't want to be the ICC official that tells Roy he can't play in the final because Dharmasena can't see.
StanSP Posted 11 July 2019 Author Posted 11 July 2019 What happened with Roy and his reaction? Had to go out for work so missed it!
trabuch Posted 11 July 2019 Posted 11 July 2019 2 minutes ago, StanSP said: What happened with Roy and his reaction? Had to go out for work so missed it! It looked to me like he wanted a review but forgot we didn't have one. Then that turned into him not walking off. Nothing really.
ScouseFox Posted 11 July 2019 Posted 11 July 2019 2 minutes ago, StanSP said: What happened with Roy and his reaction? Had to go out for work so missed it! literally nothing. he stood in the middle for about 30 seconds looking annoying because he missed the ball by about a yard. then was told he had to go cos he’d been given out, so he went. he still looked annoyed. not sure what the fuss is about, was he meant to smile as he left?
marko Posted 11 July 2019 Posted 11 July 2019 3 minutes ago, StanSP said: What happened with Roy and his reaction? Had to go out for work so missed it! Given out caught down the leg-side despite missing it by a bus ride. No review as Bairstow wasted it and stood his ground while arguing with umpires.
David Guiza Posted 11 July 2019 Posted 11 July 2019 Behrendorff reminds me of how every player used to look on old FIFA/Sports console games.
Chiltern Fox Posted 11 July 2019 Posted 11 July 2019 Great show by England. Indian rockstars take note. This is how you chase a total in the earlier 200's.
StanSP Posted 11 July 2019 Author Posted 11 July 2019 15 minutes ago, trabuch said: It looked to me like he wanted a review but forgot we didn't have one. Then that turned into him not walking off. Nothing really. 15 minutes ago, ScouseFox said: literally nothing. he stood in the middle for about 30 seconds looking annoying because he missed the ball by about a yard. then was told he had to go cos he’d been given out, so he went. he still looked annoyed. not sure what the fuss is about, was he meant to smile as he left? 14 minutes ago, marko said: Given out caught down the leg-side despite missing it by a bus ride. No review as Bairstow wasted it and stood his ground while arguing with umpires. Oh Some comments here made it sound like he'd gone crazy at the umpire!
trabuch Posted 11 July 2019 Posted 11 July 2019 Superb performance. The highlight was Roy totally dismantling Smith - oh how we laughed!.
Recommended Posts
Archived
This topic is now archived and is closed to further replies.