Gary Eatfood Posted 17 December 2016 Posted 17 December 2016 20 minutes ago, Drygon said: Personally speaking, I'd like to say it was absolutely deserved. It was dangerous play. It irrelevent if you get the ball, if the tackle endangers your opponent, which Vardys did, it has to be a red card. The ref doesn't really have much choice when someone jump in two footed with no part of your body on the ground. There's no intent though from Vardy, and the only reason he made the challenge was a poor pass. I think you're mental. Never a red. If that's a red then the game is becoming farcical.
Frank43 Posted 17 December 2016 Posted 17 December 2016 The referee missed the arm-hook which put Vardy in the air. I couldn't see his position on YouTube but he should have had the angle to see it.
kingfox Posted 17 December 2016 Posted 17 December 2016 14 minutes ago, Izzy Muzzett said: This thread will keep City fan Lee busy until Christmas Just waiting for his 50 paragraphed explanation.
Buzzell Posted 17 December 2016 Posted 17 December 2016 Looks like Johnson pushed him into the tackle. He did win the ball though and Diouf made a meal out of it.
Guest Col city fan Posted 17 December 2016 Posted 17 December 2016 24 minutes ago, Drygon said: Personally speaking, I'd like to say it was absolutely deserved. It was dangerous play. It irrelevent if you get the ball, if the tackle endangers your opponent, which Vardys did, it has to be a red card. The ref doesn't really have much choice when someone jump in two footed with no part of your body on the ground. There's no intent though from Vardy, and the only reason he made the challenge was a poor pass. You really need to stop posting if you actually believe this.
Twitcher Posted 17 December 2016 Posted 17 December 2016 19 minutes ago, funkyrobot said: Totally wrong. Looks like we've got another keyboard Craig pawson on our hands guys! Are you saying it will defo be rescinded then?
dedlock Posted 17 December 2016 Posted 17 December 2016 It appeared harsh, one when the ref should have applied more common sense. The lad who went down had earlier escaped a card for simulation in our penalty area.
Izzy Posted 17 December 2016 Posted 17 December 2016 Just now, kingfox said: Just waiting for his 50 paragraphed explanation. He's busy drafting his response as we speak. Putting his tin hat on and getting the supplies in ready to settle down for a long evening of mass debate
Always Next Year Posted 17 December 2016 Posted 17 December 2016 10 minutes ago, Gary Eatfood said: I think you're mental. Never a red. If that's a red then the game is becoming farcical. Never a red not even a yellow, being held back, got to the ball first never touched the player cheating bastard.
Webbo Posted 17 December 2016 Posted 17 December 2016 At first viewing it looked liked Johnson pulled him back which made him slide into their player.From different angles it looked far worse. Having seen it a few times I think it was a yellow at worst.
funkyrobot Posted 17 December 2016 Posted 17 December 2016 1 minute ago, Twitcher said: Are you saying it will defo be rescinded then? I wouldn't ever say definitely with the FA after ibrahimovic got away with an elbow that was as clear as drinky's
Barky Posted 17 December 2016 Posted 17 December 2016 Totally fair challenge, no foul. Not even close to a red.
pSinatra Posted 17 December 2016 Posted 17 December 2016 These are the type of tackles that deserve a red........if you don't play for Man Utd & you're not scared of Mourinho
HighPeakFox Posted 17 December 2016 Posted 17 December 2016 Proof positive that Mark Hughes is a berk..........even Garth Crooks agrees it was never a red.
Alf Bentley Posted 17 December 2016 Posted 17 December 2016 Their player (Diouf?) should get a ban for simulation. From those replays, it looks like Vardy probably didn't even touch him, yet he was rolling around "in agony", then lying there holding his leg. If he hadn't done that, would the ref have reached for his red card?
1966fox Posted 17 December 2016 Posted 17 December 2016 30 minutes ago, Drygon said: Personally speaking, I'd like to say it was absolutely deserved. It was dangerous play. It irrelevent if you get the ball, if the tackle endangers your opponent, which Vardys did, it has to be a red card. The ref doesn't really have much choice when someone jump in two footed with no part of your body on the ground. There's no intent though from Vardy, and the only reason he made the challenge was a poor pass. He was pulled back, his feet were on the ground and he got the ball, Could just as easily have be a foul for us. Maybe the ref could remember not sending Rojo off last week!!
Buzzell Posted 17 December 2016 Posted 17 December 2016 3 minutes ago, pSinatra said: These are the type of tackles that deserve a red........if you don't play for Man Utd & you're not scared of Mourinho That first one is horrendous. Deffo should be banned for that!
Webbo Posted 17 December 2016 Posted 17 December 2016 Although the ref was pathetic, I think it was an honest mistake.
adam Posted 17 December 2016 Posted 17 December 2016 It's a stupid challenge though. No need for it. We all know how soft these refs are these days so you don't wanna encourage them. The clown couldn't get his card out quick enough.
BoyJones Posted 17 December 2016 Posted 17 December 2016 Anybody who thinks that's a red has never played football. Absolutely disgraceful decision, the world has gone mad trying to be so PC. It it was basically a nothing tackle, the opposition should be ashamed of themselves and take up netball.
thebartonfox Posted 17 December 2016 Posted 17 December 2016 2 minutes ago, Webbo said: Although the ref was pathetic, I think it was an honest mistake. Agreed. I don't think it was a red, but you can see why it was given. I hope it will be rescinded, and think it should be, but wouldn't be surprised if it wasn't. The problem seemed that he didn't have complete conviction in the decision himself, and then proceeded to lose his head giving decisions and cards against us at every possible opportunity. It was as if he was trying to prove to that he wasn't trying to level things up, but instead he just let everything get out of hand.
1966fox Posted 17 December 2016 Posted 17 December 2016 15 minutes ago, Twitcher said: Are you saying it will defo be rescinded then? It should be, not sure it will be, the FA support their refs right or wrong. Even some of the Stokies are saying it wasn't a red
orangecity23 Posted 17 December 2016 Posted 17 December 2016 Same ref sent off Konchesky for being headbutted by Alan Hutton 2 seasons ago. Search "Pawson" and you'll find plenty of stuff on the forum slagging him off for previous games - funny how its always the same refs isn't it, Moss, Madley, Pawson, and not Anthony Taylor, or Clattenburg, or Michael Oliver making these mistakes all the time. It's almost as if some of these refs are fooking terrible, and shouldn't be trusted with running a bath, let alone a football game.
davieG Posted 17 December 2016 Posted 17 December 2016 Howard Webb says Craig Pawson should not be allowed to referee Liverpool vs Manchester City after controversial Jamie Vardy red card http://www.telegraph.co.uk/football/2016/12/17/howard-webb-calls-craig-pawson-stripped-new-years-eve-game-liverpool/
foxes_rule1978 Posted 17 December 2016 Posted 17 December 2016 Just now, davieG said: Howard Webb says Craig Pawson should not be allowed to referee Liverpool vs Manchester City after controversial Jamie Vardy red card http://www.telegraph.co.uk/football/2016/12/17/howard-webb-calls-craig-pawson-stripped-new-years-eve-game-liverpool/ He knows his stuff, unlike Hughes who thinks it was a clear red lmao
Recommended Posts
Archived
This topic is now archived and is closed to further replies.