BoroWill Posted 1 July 2017 Posted 1 July 2017 4 minutes ago, AKCJ said: We paid 12m for Maguire. Which could rise to £17m if he plays enough games for you and gets international recognition?
AKCJ Posted 1 July 2017 Posted 1 July 2017 4 minutes ago, BoroWill said: Which could rise to £17m if he plays enough games for you and gets international recognition? Yes, but right now we've paid 12m.
BoroWill Posted 1 July 2017 Posted 1 July 2017 1 minute ago, AKCJ said: Yes, but right now we've paid 12m. Crossed wires then, I'm meaning a total deal for Gibson worth a minimum of £25m.
gurru991 Posted 1 July 2017 Posted 1 July 2017 53 minutes ago, AKCJ said: If Gibson's price is 25m then I think he'll be a Boro player next season. I doubt that very much. Keane is apparently going to be low thirties, Stones was fifty. A young English CB like Gibson who is already on the England squad is going to be twenty with add-ons making it around twenty five give or take a few bob. He is definite quality, the type of player you build a team around.
Guest Posted 1 July 2017 Posted 1 July 2017 51 minutes ago, BoroWill said: You paid £17m for Maguire, who Gibson is much more proven than. Everton are paying £31m for Keane, who is equally as proven as Gibson. Somewhere in the middle for Gibson is fair in my mind. I'm not sure that gibson is any more proven than maguire tbh. Id have thought a fee with add ons to around 20m. I guess it depends how many clubs get involved and whether you can make it an auction
BoroWill Posted 1 July 2017 Posted 1 July 2017 Just now, toddybad said: I'm not sure that gibson is any more proven than maguire tbh. Id have thought a fee with add ons to around 20m. I guess it depends how many clubs get involved and whether you can make it an auction One has been a mainstay in a resolute defence for the past 3 years, the other only managed to get a consistent run of games at this level since Marco Silva went to Hull. Gibson played every minute of premier league football this season, Maguire missed over 1000.
gurru991 Posted 1 July 2017 Posted 1 July 2017 15 minutes ago, BoroWill said: One has been a mainstay in a resolute defence for the past 3 years, the other only managed to get a consistent run of games at this level since Marco Silva went to Hull. Gibson played every minute of premier league football this season, Maguire missed over 1000. Lets be honest, Middlesborough know what they have with Gibson. They don't need to fire sale him. The longer it goes on, the higher the price becomes. Once Keane signs for 30 plus next week then Gibsons value increases. We need to just get the deal done ASAP to let other players out there know that Leicester is serious.
st albans fox Posted 1 July 2017 Posted 1 July 2017 If it's true that rudders has gone on his jollies then the deals are either into the fine detail or they aren't happening anytime soon!
RoyFox Posted 2 July 2017 Posted 2 July 2017 4 hours ago, chadlcfc said: I've just been for dinner at my hotel (lopesan baobab in Gran Canaria) and Jon Rudkin is here with 9 of his family. Had a laptop briefcase with him so might try steal that tomorrow Really, are you serious?!
chadlcfc Posted 2 July 2017 Posted 2 July 2017 7 hours ago, RoyFox said: Really, are you serious?! Yes 100% will try get a picture. Didn't take my phone to dinner so went and got it. He had a laptop case with him so thought he might of gone to one of the wifi areas after but couldn't see him.
Lovejoy Posted 2 July 2017 Posted 2 July 2017 11 hours ago, gurru991 said: I doubt that very much. Keane is apparently going to be low thirties, Stones was fifty. A young English CB like Gibson who is already on the England squad is going to be twenty with add-ons making it around twenty five give or take a few bob. He is definite quality, the type of player you build a team around. The ironic thing about all of this is that Maguire, Gibson and Keane are all emphatically better defenders than John Stones.
sphericalfox Posted 2 July 2017 Posted 2 July 2017 7 hours ago, RoyFox said: Really, are you serious?! The DoF doesn't leave the country without access to FoxesTalk so he can gauge where to put his chips for our next signing. Hi Rudders!
st albans fox Posted 2 July 2017 Posted 2 July 2017 7 hours ago, waylander said: Gibbo Gibbo Why the chant ? cos Rudkin is in the canaries?
gurru991 Posted 2 July 2017 Posted 2 July 2017 8 minutes ago, Lovejoy said: The ironic thing about all of this is that Maguire, Gibson and Keane are all emphatically better defenders than John Stones. Yes .. Without a doubt. Man City overpaid as per usual....
Babylon Posted 2 July 2017 Posted 2 July 2017 12 hours ago, BoroWill said: You paid £17m for Maguire, who Gibson is much more proven than. Everton are paying £31m for Keane, who is equally as proven as Gibson. Somewhere in the middle for Gibson is fair in my mind. On what planet is Gibson as proven as Keane? Keane has played three seasons in this league.
gurru991 Posted 2 July 2017 Posted 2 July 2017 6 minutes ago, Babylon said: On what planet is Gibson as proven as Keane? Keane has played three seasons in this league. 57 premier league appearances for Keane 38 premier league appearances for Gibson
BoroWill Posted 2 July 2017 Posted 2 July 2017 13 minutes ago, Babylon said: On what planet is Gibson as proven as Keane? Keane has played three seasons in this league. Keane has two seasons in this league, 35 appearances this year, 22 two years ago when Burnley were relegated for a total of 57. I'd say that's fairly comparable when you account for Keane been given opportunities that Gibson didn't simply because he was a youth prospect from Manchester United. Both have England call ups.
waylander Posted 2 July 2017 Posted 2 July 2017 51 minutes ago, st albans fox said: Why the chant ? cos Rudkin is in the canaries? Colin Gibson Gibbo Gibbo . Played for us in he 90 s
brookfox Posted 2 July 2017 Posted 2 July 2017 12 hours ago, chadlcfc said: I've just been for dinner at my hotel (lopesan baobab in Gran Canaria) and Jon Rudkin is here with 9 of his family. Had a laptop briefcase with him so might try steal that tomorrow Apparently he's still there trying to negotiate a buy back clause into his dinner!
Babylon Posted 2 July 2017 Posted 2 July 2017 34 minutes ago, gurru991 said: 57 premier league appearances for Keane 38 premier league appearances for Gibson So he's not comparable then is he, because apparently Gibson playing 9 or 10 more games then Maguire makes him "much more proven".
Babylon Posted 2 July 2017 Posted 2 July 2017 26 minutes ago, BoroWill said: Keane has two seasons in this league, 35 appearances this year, 22 two years ago when Burnley were relegated for a total of 57. I'd say that's fairly comparable when you account for Keane been given opportunities that Gibson didn't simply because he was a youth prospect from Manchester United. Both have England call ups. So absolutely not even close to being as proven as each other then using your own logic.
filbertway Posted 2 July 2017 Posted 2 July 2017 He's not actually on holiday though is he? It wouldn't surprise me if he was but it's mental if he actually is.
Recommended Posts
Archived
This topic is now archived and is closed to further replies.